100%. Need clear separation of powers.

With direct elections for an executive President, who appoints the Cabinet of Ministers and sets government policy.

In parliament, the Speaker to be seen as the leader of the legislature. MPs responsible only for laws, amendments, repeals.
The Constitution and laws need to be democratised.

Rewritten in simple language, translated into every state language, and made available as original sources online, so people can access them and understand laws themselves instead of being dependent on self-appointed custodians.
We need more local democracy and fewer regional satraps.

Dissolve the current states and upgrade 740 districts into elected Janapadas/Prefectures, to improve policy outcomes on the ground.

No more MLAs and DMs acting like local feudal lords. Bottom-up, accessible institutions.
In each Janapada, assign community policing/crime prevention to local police, accountable to local citizens.

Assign law and order, crime investigation, counter-terrorism to a new central police force, independent of executive. Like the armed forces, with parliamentary oversight.
Split the Supreme Court into a Constitutional Court and Court of Final Appeal, with clear and separate functions and duties.

Give each Janapada a system a decentralised system of courts and alternative dispute resolution mechanisms, working in local languages and jargon-free.
The issue is not that we have too much democracy, we have too little.

The current unelected and unaccountable bureaucratic and judicial institutions suffer from a "democratic deficit" and are all designed to thwart any aspirations of the people that can challenge the status quo.
"In most democratic countries, ... the police work under the control of local self-government bodies.

But in India, the police is not answerable or accountable to the local people whose lives and properties it is supposed to protect." - @MNageswarRaoIPS

Many of the suggestions in the above thread may sound radical or utopian, but they exist worldwide, including here in the Indian subcontinent.

Sri Lanka being an example, which enacted such reforms despite similar levels of religious diversity and colonial administrative legacy.
For those looking for inspiration for what our next Constitution could look like, instead of copying dysfunctional and discredited models from the Anglosphere, let's learn from and improve on other Asian countries with similar challenges and experiences.

parliament.lk/files/pdf/cons…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Ruchir Sharma

Ruchir Sharma Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ruchirsharma_1

26 Dec
"The country, which is the world’s largest beef exporter, has seen a dramatic shift toward plant-based diets. The number of vegetarians in Brazil has nearly doubled over a six-year period, ... 30 million people, or 14% of Brazilians, reported being vegetarian or vegan in 2018."
"This transformation has turned the nation of 212 million people — globally renowned for all-you-can-eat steakhouses and increasingly under siege for the carbon footprint of its cattle ranches — into a powerhouse for plant-based food innovation."

nytimes.com/2020/12/26/wor…
"Brazilian plant-based food start-ups have seen soaring demand since animal-based protein analogues first became widely available in 2019 in supermarkets and restaurants.

A few years ago, giving up meat was unthinkable for the vast majority of Brazilians."
Read 5 tweets
1 Dec
In other words, "Clearing blockades and police brutality is only okay when I do it against indigenous communities to make the fossil fuel lobby happy." ImageImageImageImage
We also need no lessons in agricultural policy from a protectionist state which mollycoddles it's inefficient farmers with state patronage, to bribe rural voters.

All while pushing that African and Asian countries must end subsidies and open up their markets to Canadian exports. ImageImageImageImage
"Trudeau famously declared himself a feminist, but he sells weapons to the most vicious and misogynistic government in the world.

Calling poverty sexist, he nevertheless implements policies that impoverish women in Canada and around the world."

jacobinmag.com/2016/09/justin…
Read 8 tweets
10 Nov
He was an incapacitated alcoholic during his tenure, who would escape Cabinet meetings if they clashed with his evening whiskey-samosa routine, according to M.O. Mathai's memoirs.

Instead, he had Humayun Kabir, K.G. Saidayin, and Ashfaque Hussain run the ministry on his behalf.
The relevant passage, from M.O. Mathai’s 'Reminiscences',

"One day the Maulana’s favourite Private Secretary came to see me privately. He told me that he was worried about the Maulana because he was imbibing half a bottle of whisky every evening.
Falls were not infrequent ...
"... In fact he had broken his back in a fall and had to wear a metal plate to support his back.

Since then an able-bodied man was always available to support the Maulana whenever he got up during and after his drinks."
Read 7 tweets
14 Oct
Bold to assume that The Wire is an Indian media outlet.

It's a regime change NGO that just happens to have a blog. Run by Americans, Maoists, and Islamists trying to apply the Yugoslav disintegration model on India.

To them, anything that facilitates this outcome is desirable.
"Through the creation of a series of quasi-private "foundations", ... Washington began to filter funding and strategic aid to political parties and groups abroad that promoted US agenda in nations with insubordinate governments."

wikileaks.org/gifiles/docs/1…
"The recipe is always the same. Student and youth movements lead the way
with a fresh face, attracting others to join in as though it were the
fashion, the cool thing to do. There's always a logo, a color, a
marketing strategy."
Read 5 tweets
25 Sep
We were all taught "Gandhi won Indian independence through non-violence", but it was only non-violent for the oppressors, who then wrote our history.

For the millions of Indians jailed, tortured, killed in the freedom struggle, famines, and Partition, it was very violent indeed.
The non-violence myth was colonialism's parting gift, emasculating our nation instead of letting the blood of the fallen fertilise the soil of civilisational rebirth.

Instead of being able to say that their sacrifices were not in vain, we erased their memory to please the elite.
And who did it serve? Not the poor, not the oppressed.

Only the Anglophile, comprador bourgeoisie of the Indian National Congress who wanted to inherit the privileges and tools that their colonial masters enjoyed, in exchange for arranging a "non-violent" independence movement.
Read 8 tweets
25 Sep
"Co-opting the once revolutionary concepts of universal human rights, neoliberals refashioned the idea of freedom by tying it fundamentally to the free market, and turning it into a weapon to be used against anticolonial projects all over the world."

jacobinmag.com/2020/01/morals…
They made explicit links between the values of “civilisation” and the imperialist logic of the League of Nations’ mandate system which claimed to support “peoples not yet able to stand by themselves under the strenuous conditions of the modern world” by forcing “open-door” trade.
"The center was established, Whyte demonstrates, to challenge “the affirmations of postcolonial sovereignty and economic self-determination” of Third Worldist arguments at the time. Springing from the same logic that once prompted Fanon to observe ...
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!