1/ What would the Founders say about millions of people under curfew?
First & most important:
There was no single block of "Founders." There were different people w/different opinions, so they would say a range of things.
There's no simple answer to that question
That said...
2/ Second:
"The Founders" WOULD agree on the existence of something called the "common good."
This, too, had no simple meaning.
The "common good" of who?
Even so, they recognized that--one way or another--gov't should protect it in some way
In a way, government is a big "we"
3/ Third:
And while we're talking about government & its role...
"The Founders" weren't anti-government.
They created governments.
A lot.
The Revolution was a revolt vs. one specific gov't.
Even as it was underway, people were creating new governments to replace the old one.
4/ Fourth:
"The Founders" would understand -- profoundly -- the risk inherent in epidemics.
The didn't fully understand the cause or cure of curses like cholera and yellow fever, but they understood the need for group action of some kind to fight it.
5/ Fifth:
"The Founders" knew the Constitution was more than a Bill of Rights.
The Bill of Rights was necessary because of all the ways in which the Constitution--brought to you by many of the same people who created the Bill of Rights--invested the new gov't w/a lot of power.
6/ Last but not least -- for now:
Asked what they thought about our current group quarantines, "The Founders" would say:
WHAT ARE THOSE FLYING METAL OBJECTS IN THE SKY?
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/ In 2020, we learned that some people don't understand what democracy is; don't know that it takes work; don't know that it's fallible; don't accept that the USA can fall; don't know what they lose when democracy falls; & don't know how hard it will be to get it back.
2/ And preventing people from teaching & learning how we've had to fight for democracy; the people & events that attacked it; the people who fought for it vs immense opposition; & the failures in our democratic system from the outset is NOT the way to protect & sustain democracy.
WHITE HOUSE CONFERENCE ON AMERICAN HISTORY?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
Oh good.
We're seeing "a coordinated attack on our heroes."
"Wise people learn from the past.
Unwise people bury the past."
But somehow, denying the negative is not burying the past.
Right.
1/ An interesting nugget from my preparation for "History Matters" this AM.
We were talking about campaigning & the threat of demagogues, and I recalled & wanted to use this quote from A.Ham:
2/ I had forgotten that this quote was from the very first Federalist essay.
Hamilton was arguing that opponents to the proposed Constitution would probably appeal to the passions of the public to get them outraged over the Constitution's alleged tyrannical powers.
3/ In Federalist #1, Hamilton was basically saying that opponents to the Constitution would engage in demagogic politics to stir public passions against ratification with untruths.
In essence, he was denouncing opponents to the Constitution as demagogues of a kind.