THREAD: The loss of 1 in 1k Americans (including about 175k white ones) due to COVID & the pandemic's economic devastation are both the collateral damage of anti-Black and brown racism. Sound hyperbolic? It's not, and it's easily proved. Please follow along...
2/ On the one hand, sure, the Administration's nonchalance in the face of the virus is the initial cause of the devastation. And that had been evident since January. But that was actually starting to shift a bit by late March, right up to April 7. What happened then?...
3/ As @Thom_Hartmann has noted, that day the NYT & WaPo (among others) reported that the disproportionate death toll of COVID was among Black & brown folks. THAT NIGHT, Tucker Carlson (who had actually been taking C19 seriously) changed his tune. A few days later so did Trump...
4/ Suddenly Trump began demanding the re-opening of the economy and focusing on getting people back to work at all costs. That was when protests for re-opening began. Once the face of C19 was of color, many white folks (egged on by the right) clearly shrugged...
5/ It was Black & brown folk in blue states & cities, so who cares? It was old folks sure, including whites, but as Ben Shapiro explained, 'if an 81 year old dies from COVID, it's not like they were 30. And ya know, life expectancy is only 80' so...The mentality was eugenic...
6/ And that's the thing: once you construct a society on the scaffolding of a hierarchy of human value (which this society has been from the start), the poison is not containable. Oh you can say it's just white over everyone else, but that mentality metastasizes...
7/ And so it becomes easier to accept the loss of elderly and working class of all colors and those with pre-existing conditions. Oh well, so sad, but we gotta get back to work! Those who die are seen as weak and the weak are expendable...
8/ and so we end up rolling the dice on everyone...rather than paying folks to stay home till the crisis could pass, rather than guaranteeing paid leave, rather than mandating a small inconvenience (masks and social distancing) for the greater good...
9/ And here we are pushing 350k dead, with many more to come and the vaccine rollout a shit show...and all because of who this thing was disproportionately killing. If it had been dispro white, younger healthier and richer folks you KNOW things would have been different...
10/ We'd have shut everything down and sent weekly checks to everyone to get them through. We'd have frozen mortgages & rent indefinitely. And white folks wouldn't have been screaming about their 'right' to go unmasked in Costco or Trader Joes...no camo demos at state capitols...
11/ But bc the dead were dispro of color, racism said "meh." Dispro working class, classism said "meh." Dispro older, ageism said "meh." Dispro less healthy, ableism said "meh." This is what happens when your society is founded on the idea that Black life doesn't matter...
12/ ...and why it is so crucial to insist that it does. Because when Black lives don't matter, pretty soon neither do the lives of any others deemed relatively lesser. And the kicker is, that's going to be ALL of us at some point. We all get older. We all get sick...
13/ Once you accept a hierarchy of human value, all are at risk. So white folks who have buried loved ones from COVID, especially after 4/7, know this: if Black lives had mattered in this country from the start -- if they mattered enuf NOW -- your pain might have been avoided...
14/ And only if we construct a society where Black and brown life IS valued equally -- in short, where all lives really DO matter, and that's not just some shit people say to rhetorically smackdown Black people -- willing of us really be safe. END

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Tim Wise

Tim Wise Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @timjacobwise

31 Dec 20
1/ Wanting M4A is righteous & correct. Forcing the vote bc 'people are dying & can't wait' is empty rhetoric bc every rational person knows it won't pass. Doesn't mean forcing the vote is wrong but supporting it as if it will stop even 1 person from dying is grossly dishonest...
2/ The only other arguments I hear are essentially: a) this way we can figure out which Dems to primary (i.e., the ones who won't support M4A) and b) "we've tried it the patient way and it hasn't worked, so fuck it!" Let's look at these in reverse order...
3/ The "we've tried it your way" argument is vapid bullshit. First, the people saying that rarely have tried anything. They scream on Twitter & YouTube. They aren't organizers. They haven't run for office to try it that way. They're just pissed (rightly) and think rage = change..
Read 19 tweets
31 Dec 20
1/ Trumpism is not about ideas. It’s a politic of grievance, which grafts policy onto disaffection as an afterthought. This is why we can’t defeat it with policy proposals or logical appeals to supposed self interest. Trumpers aren’t motivated by these things, but by rage alone..
2/ This is the most fascist thing about Trumpism: its lack of coherent ideology. That vacuum is what makes it possible for a fascistic cult of personality to thrive, and the notion of an autocrat motivated by grudges and the desire to dominate for domination’s sake to flourish...
3/ It’s not even necessarily a conscious fascist politic but a fascism that derives from the base’s “nothing matters” mentality...the idea that owning the libs, making liberals cry, or hurting one’s perceived race, ethnic, religious, gender and sexual enemies is everything...
Read 5 tweets
31 Dec 20
1/ Some people on the left have this magical thinking problem when it comes to why our ideas don't often carry the day within the Dem Party. We act like it's all "big Pharma money" etc. And yes, that money is corrupting. But it's not magic...
2/ If a Rep knew the majority of THEIR constituents (not Dem voters from other parts of the country but THEIR constituents) supported more left policies *and would actually show up & vote against them if they didn't vote for those policies* they would vote for them, obviously.
3/ A major goal of a Rep is to keep being one, so no one would go against the wishes of the majority of their constituents just to get contributions, if that would cost them the job. But it WON'T. Either bc the folks who could punish them don't bother to vote, or, more likely...
Read 13 tweets
29 Dec 20
A few thoughts about the Nashville bombing and how folks are reacting to it. On the one hand, yes, were the bomber Arab and/or Muslim, the "sad loner" narrative would have been eclipsed by talk of possible religious/ideological motives and the label "terrorist." That said...
2/ the fact that we'd affix that label to others doesn't make it proper to call this bomber a terrorist. The answer is to STOP affixing that label in cases where it clearly does not fit. Allow that everyone can have motives for awful shit that aren't linked to their identities...
3/ So in the case of Muslims, they can just be loners, w/mental illness & personal grudges or who want to commit suicide for the same reason others do: reasons that are personal not ideological. And white guys can do evil shit and not have it be about white nationalism or Trump..
Read 10 tweets
26 Dec 20
1/ Conspiracy theories are for those who don't understand how systems function, so they cling to the idea of evil forces behind the scenes, when in fact, most awful things that happen happen because the social structures within which we operate contribute to various outcomes...
2/ Sadly, American culture is so hyper-individualistic, it is easier to think of everything (good and bad) as flowing from either good or bad people, rather than social systems and structures that are far more complex...
3/ And unfortunately our schools don't really teach systemic thinking, or encourage people to have a sociological imagination. So it's easier to blame false flags and a "pending gun grab" for mass shootings, rather than look at the mental health system or violent culture...
Read 12 tweets
26 Dec 20
The worst takes on the Nashville bombing remind us how awful some people can be..

"Nashville's run by Democrats!"

???

Who was Mayor of NY when 9/11 happened? Oh yeah.

Bombings happen in cities bc it gets more attention than bombing a barn, dumbass...
2/ Or how about...

"The bomb exploded outside the AT&T data center" (true)...

"And that's because they had data proving the election was stolen" (and there's the shark...make sure to jump)...

To be clear it also exploded right outside the Melting Pot, so...
3/ Or "it was antifa or BLM"...neither of which have ever bombed anything, anywhere, even once, as opposed to right wingers (who may not have done this either -- it might not have been ideological per se), but who have done literally dozens of bombings in the past 25 years...
Read 10 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!