Below is a top 10 of common media takes & narratives that aged, well, imperfectly.
Starting w/ #10: remember when Trump was going to use the Post Office to steal the election? @JoyAnnReid, @VICE, @ajplus & @ananavarro do.
#9: Early COVID coverage
I tried to cut some slack on early coronavirus predictions. But it’s worth reflecting on the way we talked about the virus back when it first started & how many people were so confidently wrong, like @Slate, @USATODAY, @thehill & @businessinsider.
#8: Masks
The worst specific coverage around the early outbreak was on masks.
Especially because the pro-mask crowd can be so militant these days, it’s worth remembering what the conversation looked like back then.
Prior to the election, we were told that Trump would rush out a potential COVID vaccine. That didn’t happen, and now the media won’t even give credit to the Trump Admin for the vaccine. Here’s: @VanityFair, @BuzzFeedNews, @jonathanchait & @ForeignPolicy.
#6: War with Iran
Speaking of things we were promised, by now we should be months into war with Iran, to hear @ForeignPolicy, @AP, @CNN, and @Reuters tell it (among MANY others).
That a potential war doesn’t even crack the top 5 is a testament to the year we’ve had.
#5: No vaccine in 2020
There have been millions of coronavirus vaccines distributed as the year ends. We were promised this simply wasn’t possible before the election.
Honorable Mention: whatever this was from @BillKristol.
Still trying to sort through this one, but I couldn’t leave it out, especially after he doubled down on it today.
No Insurrection Act yet, anyway.
#4: Defending China
While there may be some deserved slack for the early coverage of coronavirus in general, there’s no excuse for parroting Chinese Communist Party propaganda.
While much of the Russia story was prior to 2020, we got one notable entry: the idea, absent evidence, that Joe Biden’s son Hunter’s laptop was Russian disinformation & not to be reported on. The news blew up weeks later.
In the last few months, America saw its most violent & destructive riots in decades. Despite this, the media insisted that these were “mostly peaceful” protests.
This remains the weirdest, and surely most shameful, Orange Man Bad news cycle, where the media wrote off a promising treatment for a global pandemic simply because Trump liked it. Featuring @CNN, @brianstelter, @MSNBC and @Yamiche.
It can be easy, in a 24/7 news environment, to forget what previous predictions and ideas were common. But I think it’s worth reflecting on, particularly since these same people are still making predictions and driving the conversation around innumerable other important issues.
So perhaps in 2021 our collective New Years resolution can be to slow down, see our political opponents as three-dimensional and not mere strawmen, and recognize that there is much that we simply don’t know.
And maybe bite our tongue, once in a while, as a result.
Even if we all can’t muster this, it’s absolutely imperative that the national media does, if they want to have any hope of regaining the credibility that they’ve spent much of this past year lighting on fire through these and other news cycles.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Today @bradyleonard & I agreed the 2020 man of the year is @RonDeSantisFL for his leadership in response to COVID, despite endless attacks from the media.
To add some context, I’ve put those attacks side by side with coverage of @NYGovCuomo.
Spot the difference?👇
As of today, NY’s deaths per 100k from coronavirus (188) is about double Florida’s (96). Florida and Gov. DeSantis seem to be doing something right in that regard.
But you would have no idea that was the case if you spend your days listening/watching/reading @MSNBC
The worst offender had to be @CNN, which is no surprise given Cuomo’s brother works there.
Of all the really dumb conceits that are common among conservatives, the idea that we would miraculously have all the money we need if we would just do away with foreign aid is among the most ignorant.
The average American thinks the US spends more than 25x what it does as a percentage of the federal budget on foreign aid.
I’ve seen others do this, so a quick🧵of the pieces I’m most proud of having written in 2020.
Starting w/ my first piece ever in print. As someone who dwells on the retrospective, I think this, for @nytimes early in the pandemic, held up tragically well. google.com/amp/s/www.nyti…
I explored how things have changed since in a subsequent piece for @nytimes, focused on the unintended tragedies of our response to the coronavirus.
The lockdown has enormous, often overlooked, consequences. I unpack some of them here: google.com/amp/s/www.nyti…
That isn’t all that I wrote about the lockdown and coronavirus.
This one, for @dcexaminer, explores why defaulting to what medical/scientific experts think is best fundamentally misunderstands the role of public policy. google.com/amp/s/www.wash…
Despite all the hand-wringing about Georgia (remember this piece?) and Florida, each state has a death rate per capita that’s **less than half** of what New Jersey’s is.
GA - 98 per 100,000
FL - 96 per 100,000
NJ - 205 (!!) per 100,000
For context - and w/ a nod that we don’t have all the data from some places, particularly poorer countries or those lying about their totals (looking at you, China) - if NJ were a country, it’s morality rate would be ~25% higher than **any other country in the world**
(You can run the numbers yourself if you don’t believe me. The highest number of deaths per capita right now is Belgium, with 158 deaths per 100K.) statista.com/statistics/110…