Overarching principle: think first. Do not try every possible permutation of samples/fixed effects, etc. Think about what concerns readers might have & design robustness checks to address those.
Pick your preferred regression specification/sample before you know what your results are. You are not necessarily wedded to this, but it will help you be on firm ground conceptually.
When doing robustness checks, change one thing at a time based on the most likely threats to your empirical approach. There may be good reasons for changing >1 things at a time in some cases, but doing so is more likely to lead to too many tables!
Consider adding some falsification/placebo exercises, again based on possible threats to validity.
And, finally, remember that not all robustness check "failures" are actual failures.
See post for more details & please add your own suggestions!
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The current COVID-19 situation reminds me in many ways of Hurricane Katrina, which devastated the Gulf Coast in 2005. I've studied the latter disaster in my research, and I think we can learn a lot from it. Summary follows, full post is here: medium.com/@tatyana_57116…
Both COVID-19 and Hurricane Katrina are large external shocks that have nothing to do with overvalued housing markets, excessive leverage, or a sudden drop in consumer confidence. Let me tell you more about Hurricane Katrina.
Hurricane Katrina flooded most of the city of New Orleans, making it unlivable. It killed nearly 2,000 people, most of them elderly. Hospitals, schools, and businesses closed for extended periods of time. Across the Gulf region, an estimated 230,000 jobs were suddenly lost.
Some general paper-writing advice for students who are going on the job market next year (though this advice can be applied to any paper).
(No, it's NOT too early to be writing up your JMP!)
First and foremost, writing up your research results is difficult. Thus, prepare to spend a lot of time on it and do not worry if it is going slowly. If writing seems easy to you, you are either a prose genius or doing it wrong.
If you haven’t started writing up your JMP yet, but you know what it is going to be, I suggest you start now and write a little bit every day. Starting now will give you the time and space you need to think carefully about how to structure the paper and polish your writing.