this will surprise no one who remembers Masha Gessen's fawning interview with Martina Navratilova at the height of her "I Hate Trans Women" world tour in 2019 without ever once mentioning her pivot to professional transmisogny... newyorker.com/news/our-colum…
but within a few days of Gessen's attempts to position themselves as an authority on trans youth, a polite intervention from @mckenziewark resulted in Gessen saying the quiet part loud:
here's (most of) the thread for reference, Mckenzie was polite, friendly, reasonable, and that was all it took for Gessen to snap:
The transmisogyny has been obvious for a while now, and the mission statement appears to be something like "Transition is cool and interesting if you're transmasculine and you take years to contemplate it. Trans women can fuck off lmao"
The lesson, for editors at least, is that if someone who has been conspicuously silent about transmisogyny and has a showy bromance with professional TERFs suddenly wants to write about trans kids? Don't publish it!
no one who was doing buddy comedy shit with Navratilova in 2019 and then suddenly had something important to say about trans youth in 2021 without a single intervening acknowledgement has done the work, or used a single brain cell. tremendously dumb, transmisogynist nonsense
and anyone who was part of signing off on Gessen's recent Deep Thoughts With Jack Handey has made a fool of themselves! "You're a credulous git, Mr Pepperdyne" etc
And @mashagessen went to that well immediately because Mckenzie had the gall to suggest they could have interviewed more & different people. When trans women didn't respond with immediate gratitude and praise, there it was. Disgusting. Entitled. Cruel. Transphobic.
It was a bush league, piece of shit, disgusting move, and Masha should be absolutely mortified to have made such an ass of themselves in public. I'm embarrassed for them. At your age, too.
the idea that Mckenzie should...sit in sackcloth and ashes??? to atone for being a trans woman with a basic, polite criticism like “you could have interviewed people with direct experience in this subject” is so grossly entitled!!! go sit in a damn corner!
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
quick update my dog is asleep on my chest/left arm so i can't reach my phone to document but he is letting out a very small puff/squeak/almost snore every, i would say, two seconds
his head? tucked right under my chin
I can't take a picture so if you could all just single file walk through my living room and take a look that would probably be the easiest way to get the picture
Grace and I both knew pushing for accountability and further investigation at Menlo was going to come at a cost. We knew it would be slow, difficult, painful, and that we’d meet with resistance. @graceelavery
We’ve spoken to school administrators, the police, current and former parishioners, parents, investigators, lawyers, and church staff. We’ve gone public when other avenues failed.
Almost eight months after our first report in November, and still no one has interviewed the children who were in my brother’s care over the years.
In November of last year, I reported to the Elders of Menlo Church that their senior pastor, John Ortberg, had conspired in secret to provide a person experiencing compulsive sexual feelings towards children with unsupervised access to young people through youth groups.
At that time, it was my hope that the Menlo Elders would conduct a confidential and thorough investigation of the report, and make such arrangements as were necessary to protect the community. In January, Menlo Church published the broad outlines of their investigation.
In my opinion, it was not a thorough one. The investigator did not, for example, interview a number of the key witnesses, nor do I believe did they investigate church-related work on international trips. Although Ortberg returned to the pulpit acknowledging vague regret,