NEW: Before he left office, Trump filed his final financial disclosures with @OfficeGovEthics. I’ve had a read through them. The income he is claiming in respect of his Scottish resorts is entirely divorced from the reality set out in black in white in his UK accounts. Thread 👇
Firstly, Trump lists his income from ‘golf related revenue’ at Turnberry as $9.8m. Which is interesting, given the latest UK accounts for Turnberry's parent company registered losses of £2.3m ($3.1m) for the 12 months to 31 Dec 2019.
Even the turnover in the UK accounts - listed as £19.6m ($26.8m) is a country mile off that income figure listed in Trump's OGE filings. Comparing like for like, even accounting for that weird 'golf related revenue' descriptor, it's not even close.
If you drill down in more detail, and subtract the administrative expenses at Turnberry's parent firm from its turnover in order to get closer to whatever that 'income' figure entails, the number is still £12.5m ($17.2m).
And if you go deeper, and account for the gains the company made in foreign exchanges, and deduct depreciation and amortisation costs, the figure is £9.9m ($13.6m). Still a way off the OGE number.
Trump’s OGE filings also detail income of $1.4m for his inaugural golf resort in Scotland, despite the fact its latest UK accounts show losses of £1m ($1.3m) and turnover of £3.2m ($4.3m) for the 12 months to 31 Dec 2019.
And again, if you take that turnover as a baseline, and subtract administrative expenses, you’re left in the region of £2.1m ($2.8m). Not so noticeable a gulf, but it's still an anomaly compared the OGE number.
The value of both resorts is listed as $50m+ apiece, which I think is fair for Turnberry, given what Trump has invested there. I’m not sure that figure is reflective of his Aberdeenshire property’s value, however.
Even weirder, his OGE docs also list Nitto World and DT Connect Europe, two smaller Scottish subsidiary entities, despite the fact the Trump Org is, er, liquidating both corporations. I’m not familiar with the workings of OGE disclosures, but it’s odd to omit mention of it.
I’m not sure what appetite exists for the US to explore all this given Trump's gone, but it’s worth highlighting. I’m not sure what timeframe he's claiming this income was made in, but if it’s after 2019, that’d be even more unusual, given the impact Covid-19 has had on his biz.
Anyway, my takeaway, for what it's worth, is the same as it's been for the past four years: it doesn't make sense.
A final, important point - Trump claims the value of each of his Scottish resorts is $50m+. It's worth remembering that Turnberry lists assets of £62m ($85m) in its UK accounts, yet is indebted to the tune of £113m ($154m). Which gives it equity of, uh, minus £51m ($69m)
There's a similar pic with his Aberdeenshire resort. Trump says its value is $50m+. Accounts show it owes £44m ($60m) on assets of just £32m ($43m).
In short, Trump claims his two Scots firms are worth $100m+
The accounts show they're in negative equity to the tune of $112m.
Trump's OGE filing and the UK accounts are all below. It's all in the public record.
This isn't the first time discrepancies b/w Trump's OGE disclosures & UK accounts have been flagged. I suspect it won't be the last. But given the circus has left town, there might be time for the folk who matter to explore it in greater detail. I wouldn't bet on it, mind.
And can I just say, given it's only been TWENTY SIX HOURS since Trump left office: for fuck's sake ...
Reports that the OGE disclosure spans 2020. That complicates comparisons with the UK (2019) accounts. Figs reflect a major downturn in revenue, expected due to Covid. But the central absurdity remains: claiming the firms are worth $100m+ when they’re laden with $197m of debts.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
It's been a wild four years covering Trump. Now seems a good time for a thread on some of my stories.
First up, how Trump repeatedly tried & failed to convince a Scottish bank to lend him £38m for a failed hotel venture, while claiming he had £1bn in cash scotsman.com/news/politics/…
2/ How Trump's Turnberry resort was paid £52,000+ by the US government as he made a private visit to play multiple rounds of golf, and watch World Cup football matches in his room:
3/ Wealthy Russian & US clients couldn't save Trump's Scottish helicopter charter firm. Pilots had to cover up the aircraft's TRUMP signage as his brand grew increasingly toxic. The venture was eventually liquidated, with the chopper shipped to the US
EXCL: Donald Trump's Turnberry hotel was paid nearly £25,000 by the Secret Service for business trips by Eric Trump & his wife, incl a private golf excursion with 30 'international guests'. The resort has received circa £300,000 from US taxpayers. Thread👇🏻 scotsman.com/news/politics/…
These trips included a golfing tour of Trump’s Scottish courses by his son, Eric, and dozens of Trump Organisation customers, who flew in via private jet as part of an upmarket golfing excursion marketed by the Trump Org as the ‘Ultimate Links Tour’.
They also include a stay at Turnberry by Eric and his wife, Lara, to attend a ribbon cutting ceremony at one of the resort's refurbished courses. They were joined at the ceremony an actor dressed up as a 14th century Scottish monarch (with big sword). Pic: Jeff J Mitchell / Getty
Thread: there's been interesting discussion in the Scottish Parliament this afternoon about the use of Unexplained Wealth Orders to investigate Donald Trump's deals to acquire his Scottish properties and ascertain the sources of the financing 1/
.@patrickharvie said there is a need to "protect Scotland's good name from association with the toxic Trump brand" and highlighted "serious and long-standing concerns about Trump's business activities," both in Scotland and further afield 2/
Those concerns, he said, include evidence to Congress citing patterns of buying and selling thought suggestive of money laundering, and which drew particular attention to the golf courses in Scotland and Ireland. 3/
The prominent anti-lockdown projection & URL, caught my eye. So I thought I’d have a wee shifty. The campaign is run by a firm called Restore the Balance. One of its directors, Jonathan Dobinson, is director of a company called World4Brexit. Here’s where it gets interesting 1/2
A lobbying firm by the same name, World4Brexit, was promoted by Nigel Farage last year. It launched in NY, attended by prominent Trump supporters, including Corey Lewandowski, the former Trump campaign manager.
So who’s funding a high profile anti Covid-19 lockdown campaign with the resources to project its message in parliament, and which features prominently on tomorrow’s front page of one the UK’s bestselling newspapers?
EXCL: Woody Johnson, the billionaire US ambassador to the UK, spent more than £1,000 on golf and dinner in a single day during a three-night stay at Donald Trump’s Scottish resort - and American taxpayers picked up the bill. My @TheScotsman story: scotsman.com/news/politics/…
If you're unaware of the ties between Trump and his extraordinarily wealthy ambassador to the UK, here's an accompanying article detailing their longstanding social connections. It includes a wig-themed birthday party. Forewarned is forearmed etc. scotsman.com/news/politics/…
Folk in the US may not be aware how Trump's Turnberry resort has discovered a rich new seam of revenue during his presidency. So here's a recap of how his flagship Scottish property is reaping plenty of US taxpayer dollars - while still running at a loss: scotsman.com/news/politics/…
At #FMQs, @AlisonJohnstone raises the closure of a @EdinburghUni Covid-19 testing lab - as revealed in today's @TheScotsman👇- saying that the decision to deploy testing to the full is a @scotgov policy choice which contradicts @WHO guidance.
.@NicolaSturgeon says the lab was never designed as a "permanent provision," and that the @scotgov is developing regional hubs to provide long-term capacity. (NB - is developing, not *has developed*)
.@AlisonJohnstone says the @scotgov strategy is outdated, and says Scottish universities are falling behind when it comes to testing. FM replies that testing strategy is subject to constant review.