I'm kind of an Afro-pessimist about black folks in science. What I've learned from the recent successes of women in breaking down barriers is nothing will happen if you don't have a critical mass of people. Black folks are spread thin. Programs often only let one or two in. 🧵👇
There aren't enough black folks in most scientific fields to build our own community, to demand respect for our norms, values and interests, and to create an organic self-sustaining pipeline of black scholars that exists outside of majority white institutional power.
One analogy I've used before is this. Imagine you're switching from fossil fuels to sustainable energy. Do you think that this could happen without a massive investment in providing subsidies for new businesses and building up the sustainable fuel infrastructure?
There obviously needs to be some attempt to mitigate the absolutely massive head start that the fossil fuel market has over the market for the alternatives. It requires an acknowledgement that one might have to operate at a loss for multiple years or even decades.
Why would it be any different when trying to increase the number of black students coming from an educational pipeline? We seem to think it will all just magically happen with a minimal cost effort. I fear that perspective is deeply misguided.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Kareem Carr 🙃

Kareem Carr 🙃 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @kareem_carr

25 Jan
I wrote a short thread on being a racial minority within math academia. I didn’t propose any changes to the status quo or solutions. Just pointed out why I think race is an issue in the context of my experiences. Here are some of the EXTREMELY racist responses I got back. 👇🏾
It’s funny because a lot of the responses say it’s not about race and accuse me of forcing race into the conversation. Meanwhile, many of those rather naive comments are located right next to insanely racist crap like this...
This one came close to calling me the N word but chickened out at the last moment. (I’m not American or African!Nobody has even metaphorically come close to “giving” me any of these things.) Image
Read 12 tweets
24 Jan
It's said that when women started working more, divorces increased. It seems that once women had their own money, they no longer wanted to deal with men's shit. Similarly, I suspect many of the prosperous non-whites (and women!) of today are becoming tired of white male bullshit.
In this analogy of civic life as a marriage, cancellation and the associated financial ruin which many white men fear in their public life is the equivalent of divorce and financial ruin which coincidentally many men in the mostly white "manosphere" fear in their private lives.
I frequently have white males telling me that from their perspective, people are being divisive by "bringing up" race and gender when these weren't issues before. What one needs to understand is just because something hasn't been an issue for YOU doesn't mean it wasn't an issue.
Read 5 tweets
24 Jan
Have you heard of the "probability paradox" known as The Monty Hall Problem?

In my opinion, it's BARELY about probability and is DEFINITELY not a paradox! It's OVER-HYPED by folks that get a buzz out of "tricky" math puzzles!

I'm going to explain it to you WITHOUT ANY MATH. 👇🏾
FIRED UP? LETS. DO. THIS! First, let's talk about what the Monty Hall Problem even is...
You're on Mr. Monty Hall's game show. There are 3 doors. One of them has a car behind it. The other two have goats. You pick an unopened door. At the end of the show, you get to keep whatever is behind your door. Image
Read 12 tweets
23 Jan
Many white males seek out math as a refuge from the complexities of society. So when I bring up the role of race in math culture, they see me as destroying their safe space. As a black man, I too wish for math to be a safe space from race. Sadly, for many black folks, it is not.
"Who do they make eye contact with? Not you."

This is a good article on what it can be like to be black in mathematics and reflects a lot of my own experiences: nytimes.com/2019/02/18/us/… )
Who am I to say this? I have a MSc in Math. I once gave a report to the president of the American Mathematical Society. I worked directly with the vice-president. I've been on committees within the AMS. I'm not some rando that has no clue what US mathematics culture is like.
Read 7 tweets
6 Jan
Here are my TWO simple rules for deciding who's an expert (both during a pandemic and in general)! 🧵👇
I don't think we should automatically believe people who say they're experts but we also shouldn't automatically dismiss them either.
I have 2 simple criteria for identifying experts:

1. Am I confident that this person has spent a lot of time formally thinking and reading about the topic?

2. Am I confident this person has spent lots of time gathering direct real world experience about the topic?
Read 7 tweets
5 Jan
The Pandemic has got me thinking. On TV, people of the future are always very comfortable with data. They collect it. They analyze it. They adjust their strategies in real time. Not in days or hours or minutes but often literally in SECONDS.🧵👇
They run simulations of different outcomes. The simulations aren't always right but they seem to put them in the ballpark of what's reasonable. People take the simulations and data seriously. They factor them into their planning.
Even when the future government is evil, it's still smart. Even when the future government is rigid and uncreative in how it responds to stuff, it's responses are still logically related to the assumptions it has made, the data it has collected and the analyses it has performed.
Read 12 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!