I hate lockdowns and I hate schools being closed. Which is why I don't want a fourth lockdown later this year. How do we avoid that? 1/
First let's counter this idea that scientists are pessimistic. This isn't true. In my experience, generally, they're rather an optimistic bunch. My rule of thumb is that if you listen to many scientists, they're actually giving you an upbeat interpretation of the facts. 2/
Luckily, I left the lab 20 years ago and I'm a born glass half-empty kind of person. So let's look at where we are without rose-tinted glasses-and where we might be at the end of the year. Then you can decide what the government should do now. 3/
My first conclusion is that vaccination is not going to get us out of this mess entirely. They will help a lot but perhaps not enough to prevent surges and hospitalisations--and the resulting lockdowns. Why? 4/
Let's do some sums. Assume we get every adult willing to have the jab, one dose by September. Let's say 90% of adults agree to have the jab. They get 70-80% protection. That still leaves <18 year olds unvaccinated. So we have approx 50-60% of the whole population protected 5/
That's enough to take pressure off the hospitals hopefully. But there's a problem. We have new variants popping up all the time. Looking at what we know about the Brazilian and South African variants, and taking a pessimist's view--let's say they knock down vax efficacy by 20% 6/
Well now that's not looking so good at all. So we really can't let these strains spread here. Let me repeat: we cannot let these strains spread here. That means we cannot start easing restrictions in mid-February no matter what Johnson's backbenchers are telling him 7/
Because you see with these variants, if they are knocking down efficacy by even 10-20%, we're down to less than half the population being protected. And that's enough for Covid to spread-more slowly for sure-but still at R>1 with no restrictions 8/
If you're with me so far, keep following me down the pessimist's path and see where we get to. We know that there are going to be parts of the world that tragically get vaccinated late--maybe in 1-2 years. We know that there are a huge number of cases+little monitoring 9/
We know that the UK variant is probably more deadly, and spreads faster. We know that some strains may partly evade vaccines. So the pessimist would assume we'll get a strain appearing that has some combination of these attributes 10/
And perhaps one that is more vaccine resistant too. How quickly could one emerge? Well, that depends on the size of the unvaccinated population in the world and how long some countries continue not suppressing this virus really really hard 11/
I find it strange that many who argued for 'taking back control of our borders' are arguing with equal passion for allowing our borders to be completely porous to new Covid strains🤷12/
Boris Johnson's talking about 'debate' but really, if we want to avoid the potential for a surge in infections later this year as we race to get second doses out to the population+don't want new, nastier strains circulating, there's no 'debate' necessary 13/
We need to:
1) Supress infections really, really hard until we're close to 0
2) Get every facet of TTI working - that includes the 'isolate' bit. If there's evidence that £500 will get people to isolate (and I think there is)-do it.
14/
3/ EVERYONE coming in has to be tested and has to isolate.
4/ We can't talk about 'saving summer'. This is short-sighted nonsense, just as talk of 'saving Christmas' was. No foreign holidays this year. Anyone that insists on going abroad should isolate in a hotel on return. 15/
5/ We absolutely cannot let up on restrictions until we have infections at a level we are *sure* is managable by TTI. 16/
17/ If we want children to go back to school after Easter, and I do, we need to be planning for that now. That means - no holds barred mitigation to avoid spread within classrooms. Ensure good ventilation (including staff rooms), masks in classrooms for older kids... 17/
18/ ...think about using outdoor spaces (marquees, heaters?), more funding for more staff TAs etc, key year groups back first (early years/exam years?)
Let's not just reopen to all and hope for the best with no precautions in place. 19/
If we want to take our country back from covid, then we have to stop playing catch-up with the virus. There is no honest option left now, even with the vaccine, other than this if we want to return to something like normality. 20/
I'm sorry that anyone else is saying anything different. If they are, look at what they said about the virus 6-8 months ago publicly and see if it holds up to scrutiny. If it doesn't ask yourself seriously whether you should trust them again now ENDS

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Ananyo Bhattacharya

Ananyo Bhattacharya Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Ananyo

6 Oct 20
Great series from @PhysicsWorld on scientists (nearly all women) overlooked for a Nobel. Additional reason that Meitner was overlooked: as a refugee in Sweden, she was working in Manne Siegbahn's lab... 1/
Siegbahn was a physics Nobelist, very influential in the higher echelons of Swedish science and, apparently, a notorious misogynist (see Ruth Lewin Sime's ace biog) who was resentful about Meitner's presence.
Sime's quarter-century old biography is a compelling portrait of Meitner's life-- including a record of the many many slights she endured during her life at the hands of some of her closest colleagues-slights we now commonly call microaggressions and gaslighting. 3/
Read 5 tweets
19 Apr 20
1/ Thread on Sweden, #coronavirus, the mathematician John von Neumann and the war that didn’t occur
2/ Von Neumann helped invent, among other things, the modern computer, game theory and the atom bomb. He predicted WWII, the Holocaust, that France would be overrun quickly, that the US would enter the war when UK struggled...
3/ One of his predictions, however, was that there would be a catastrophic nuclear war with the Soviet Union before 1950. He advocated pre-emptive war-a massive nuclear strike on Russia before it could get the bomb
Read 10 tweets
6 Apr 20
1/ Some thoughts on medium/long term 'exit strategy'. I can't see one without significant drawbacks if, as seems likely, relatively small proportion of population infected with #coronavirus. Very happy to be corrected. Possibilities...
2/ Option A: Slowly lift lockdown measures when peak has subsided eg send kids back to school, reopen shops - but continue social distancing. This will result in second wave of infections, which would have to be followed by another lockdown lasting weeks...
3/ ..There might have to be a third cycle of lockdowns before vaccine arrives. Given economic devastation caused by first lockdown, I can't see UK/US/EU governments going down this route.
Read 13 tweets
10 Jun 19
Fun #Boris fact. About 13 years ago, when I was news ed at @ResFortnight, we sent a reporter along to interview the then shadow higher education minister about universities and science policy. It was a total farce. He neither knew nor cared one jot....
@ResFortnight At one point, he blustered (approximately), "Well you clearly know more about this than I do, Why don't you tell me what our policies should be."
@ResFortnight Universities and research, I've always believed, are incredibly important-economically and socially. I was naive enough at the time to be shocked at such blatant disregard of the issues that I still regard as central to Britain's future.
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!