Far better informed people than me have commented on the actual winners and losers associated with #GameStop and the #RedditArmy attack on the stock market (see @StephenPunwasi to start) but what fascinates me is the political angle. Which is real, but also completely absent. 1/9
This incredible movement of dollars, headlines, and memes is fundamentally driven by frustration with elites winning endlessly in a game perceived to be rigged. Leaving aside whether the response is productive or destructive, the motivating force is clear, pure, and real. 2/9
This movement has been compared to everything from Trump-inspired insurrectionists to violent Antifa activists. Such comparisons, from every side, are unfair and miss the point. Because this movement hasn't taken any side politically and hasn't come close to breaking any law. 3/9
Will the retail-investor-revolution end up wasting money? Maybe. Probably. But compared to the vast amounts of money poured into politics (especially in America) I can't see any valid argument that people aren't allowed to waste their money to make a point. 4/9
To me, the overriding message is this. Politicians on all sides have been harnessing anger at a system correctly perceived as rigged for a long time. Every side does it. And whether intentionally or not, by splitting that anger in half it's being used to neutralize itself. 5/9
The vast force of this movement isn't only due to stock market voodoo and the angry #RedditArmy. It's due to the fact that by staying politically agnostic, it really is about average people vs. the system. However muddy it may get from there, that much is pure. 6/9
Truly, the system IS rigged. And not just the stock market. I say that even as someone who - whether due to luck, hard work, or born-with privilege that goes beyond my working class upbringing - has been a moderate winner in this system. It IS rigged. 7/9
If it was ever the case that capitalism gave everyone a fair chance to be one of the winners in this game, that time is in the past. And there are far, far more people who know that's true than are still pretending it isn't. Which means that something's gotta give. 8/9
Leaving aside the stock market bingo, the real story is that everyone pissed off at the rigged game refused to be played off against one another and divided into rival political teams. And holy shit look what happened. The lesson must be applied elsewhere. We need it. 9/9

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Jeff Rybak🍁😷

Jeff Rybak🍁😷 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @JeffRybak

1 Feb
It's still too early to invite post-Covid deconstruction of what Covid really means, beyond many families suffering losses, massive disruptions in our lives, isolation, etc. But this latest snowbird controversy has pushed me to it. We need to talk about privilege. #cdnpoli 1/12
The widening gap in economic reality is the defining issue of our time. "We're in this together" isn't just a Covid slogan. It's the binding promise of society. As long as it's true, we can act together to solve our problems. When it stops being true, we're screwed. #cdnpoli 2/12
The only way we all have an equal stake in society is if we all have a fair chance to enjoy its rewards. And that's the promise, isn't it? Work hard, do well, dash of luck, and you too can be one of the winners. Even if you started from behind. Pull yourself up. #cdnpoli 3/12
Read 12 tweets
23 Jan
I have a new appreciation for conservatives who believe in "me first" politics. They believe the haves should keep what they have, the have-nots should stop looking for hand-outs, and that's the way it is. It's ugly, selfish, and short-sighted. But it's honest. #cdnpoli 1/8
I've been wondering why so many otherwise lucid right-wingers believe insane things about progressive leaders and politics. They can't accept it's about helping people and redistributing wealth. They believe in satanic, pedophiliac, supervillain Socialism. Why? #cdnpoli 2/8
My theory is that intelligent people who can see human suffering, and who understand they have enough to share but don't want to share, suffer from cognitive dissonance. They want and need to believe they are good, but also know they are selfish. So what to do? #cdnpoli 3/8
Read 8 tweets
14 Nov 20
I was asked recently about divisiveness on twitter, and how I engage reasonably with a range of different people and opinions. It led me to some interesting thoughts I'd like to share, and which may be useful to anyone - even people who hate my opinions otherwise. 1/10
First off, let me say it's hilarious to be cited as a model for constructive engagement. In real life, I'm considered blunt and tactless, if not an outright asshole. But I maintain roughly the same tone here, while others crank it up to 100. There's a lesson in that alone. 2/10
The big thing is this. I don't consider twitter to be the main outlet for my social engagement. I see great value in social media. Talking to one another is good. Shouting all the time, maybe less good, but still it's something. In the end though, it's all hashtag activism. 3/10
Read 11 tweets
12 Nov 20
This pandemic is a chance to consider the delivery of healthcare in Canada, as it has become both more difficult and more urgent to access care. Erin O'Toole is on record favoring expansion of private options. I'd like to share some recent personal experiences. #cdnpoli 1/13
My right knee is messed up. I don't really know why, but it swells easily and I can't walk long distances. My doctor ordered x-rays and ultrasounds I got locally very quickly. That worked great. Now I need an MRI and I'm totally stalled. No idea when I'll get one. #cdnpoli 2/13
Someone pointed me at a private option where I could pay my way in. The loophole is that an employer can pay for the service if required, but I'm self-employed so arguably I could order one for my most critical employee - me. Gotta be honest, I thought about it. #cdnpoli 3/13
Read 13 tweets
11 Nov 20
As we argue on twitter with all our strong opinions, on Remembrance Day, I'd like to acknowledge one of the least noticed aspects of military service. When any man or woman agrees to serve they set aside their opinions, whatever they are, and accept higher authority. #cdnpoli 1/5
Almost everyone agrees we need some kind of military. We may disagree in extreme terms on how it's to be used. But unless you believe passive resistance will somehow solve everything in a world where others are not passive, we need to use force at least sometimes. #cdnpoli 2/5
Having a functional military at all, to supply the option of force when needed, depends on the willing service of those who accept civilian authority wherever it leads. They don't know in advance the orders they'll follow or even who will give them. That's amazing. #cdnpoli 3/5
Read 5 tweets
11 Nov 20
I argue far more with self-righteous lefties on twitter than anyone else. Some think I'm giving right-wingers a pass, but truthfully they just aren't worth my energy. Despite my centrism, I don't have enough common ground with the right to hope we'll ever find agreement. 1/10
I sometimes see commonalities between the extreme right and left. What I'm seeing now is a common tendency to give up and invite the great reset. Is there a difference between the religious right yearning for Rapture and the hard left for wholesale revolution? I'm not sure. 2/10
I know I don't want to stop trying to make what we have work somehow. Work better, hell yes. For everyone, but most of all for those who have the least. I know the ongoing unfairness in our society is hard to swallow. But look at how far we've come. It's worth saving. 3/10
Read 10 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!