I’m not quick to judge pedagogy out of context. But there is only ever one context for the “imagine being a slave!” assignment, in all its many iterations. It is bad.
As someone who spent some time in a teacher training program once, the commitment to teaching this way runs the gamut from k-21. It’s a worldview & its adherents rarely care how dangerous it is because it makes THEM feel better.
These assignments are generally about the instructor’s discomfort with their own empathy gap. To assuage their identity conflict over that empathy gap, they inflict psychological trauma on Black students and intellectual malpractice on non-Black students.
You don’t, for instance, see the same corpus of assignments for “experiencing” Hiroshima or concentration camps or other global, catastrophic historical events.
The worldview is absolutely about whiteness but all kinds of instructors deploy this strain of whiteness. It’s active anti-blackness and no one is immune to that.
Stop doing these assignments, in any form.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Well lookie there, a handful of Black women just happen to be talking about race, gender & country music on @HearToSlay this week, f. the inimitable @RissiPalmer
And my quick round-up of country’s biggest racism news day yesterday:
Wallen’s timing sucked. The world has been handed to him on a platter. Seventy-two hours ago he was poised to be a breakout pop country-to-rock star. This morning, @SIRIUSXM country-news channel framed their critical response as: “we hate to do it but we just broke up with MW.”
I rant about this all the time but never on Twitter because I don’t need that on my permanent record. I fantasize about subjecting the CEO of every consumer goods company to open the packaging on their most popular items.
We have had some great planning and research discussions about the contours of precarity, entrepreneurial ideologies in a digital economy, as well as the historical sediments of that work (eg MLMs, piecemeal work, franchises).
Some things I’m reading around this topic, include:
@lanalana’s new book on digital money, “New Money
How Payment Became Social Media”
This is amazing content. It hits differently when you see it than when you only read it. The $20 thing is so visceral because the amount of routine theft that everyday white people did and do is impossible to measure. Impossible.
I’m not that old & i have these same stories. I clearly remember buying some Day’s Work from a convenience store for my auntie. I was a smart 9 or 10 year old. Quiet in front of authority but smart (shut up). I remember counting the change a white cashier gave me for the purchase
He had crumpled the bills up and shoved them in my hand. I was smoothing them to count them. And he got red and started screaming at me. Screaming. Because I was counting the change he knew he had just shorted me. Just everyday violence and theft.
I have a 3/4 baked argument about what’s going on with these “a nation/family divided” stories. Maybe I should jot it down quickly.
Tl;dr is you were always going to have to choose between family and cult of marriage and whiteness. Always. These have been on a crash course for three generations. It sounds like it sucks and I’m sure it does. But this was always the price for having a soul.
Either the “how to be good white people” books don’t cover this OR people didn’t read them all the way through. I don’t know because I’ve not read any of them, to be honest. But yes, uh, breaking up with many of your white people is exactly the end game.