To all the SNP parliamentarians whooping today and about the ruling of lady carmichael and hashtagging with both votes SNP. Firstly, this result was expected. Very few of these types of cases succeed in the outer house. Going to the inner house was expected.
Secondly! Hang your head in shame for trying to campaign for your party on the back of this case. The "Premature, Academic and Hypothetical" would not have been a thing had your party released the 11 point plan the day before they actually did.
Why? Because it falls apart at point 5 and actually goes into EXACTLY the thing we've been asking in the case. You're not telling me that legal advice was not sought on something that substantive and that the party and its counsel did not know about it BEFORE the hearings.
We'll find out, because I have referred the matter to parliament!.
Finally, we're not finished. This was just us getting warmed up! Inner house here we come.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
@trader_buddha@pjnichols@No431onthelist@BBCPhilipSim@AUOBALBA Part 1, Article 1, Paragraph 1, International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights "All peoples have the right of self-determination. By virtue of that right they freely determine their political status and freely pursue their economic, social and cultural development."
@trader_buddha@pjnichols@No431onthelist@BBCPhilipSim@AUOBALBA The States Parties to the present Covenant, including those having responsibility for the administration of Non-Self-Governing and Trust Territories, shall promote the realization of the right of self-determination, and shall respect that right, in conformity with....
I want to say something about @action4indy (AFI) which is now registered with the Electoral Commission (a saga caused by it's unique design -but nothing worth doing is easy).
I am an outsider. I've never really prescribed to one party or another. I'm staunchly pro-independence and I staunchly protect my independent status. I'm all for advocating for independence and I am all for advocating for my local community.
I've always hated what I refer to as the "party whip" and have always felt that having to vote stringently along party lines takes something away from politicians. If you vote the party line all the time, it's not always a good thing for your own constituency.
I just want to clarify something about the #peoplesas30 because of a misconception. I've seen quite a few posts saying that the case, if lost, would be detrimental to the cause. It can't be and here's the reason why.
THE UK GOVERNMENT ADVANCED NO ARGUMENT AGAINST OUR OPINION.
What I mean by "opinion" is the original legal opinion written by Aidan O'neill QC that says that the Scottish Parliament already has the power to legislate for a referendum. The UK Government has advanced no argument against it.
The only arguments that the UK Government have advanced is against the right of the electorate to ask a perfectly legitimate question like this.
Obviously, this mornings update was done quickly on the back of the ruling having just arrived.
Counsel has spent the day going much deeper into the ruling and while I am not able to go through everything at this stage, what I can say is that our grounds for the inner house of court of session are stronger than we first thought. Which is great.
Joanna Cherry also piped up this afternoon, being a QC she had a good read of the judgement. Her assessment was put out on Twitter:
Disabled. I am disabled. All these PC terms like "less abled" and person with a disability etc. These are all meaningless to me. Why? Because I am not defined by my disability, I'm defined by how I overcome it. All these terms used to describe me are created by...
...the able-bodied because they feel awkward about interacting with someone who is disabled. They are created so other people can feel more comfortable about the fact they feel uncomfortable around disabled people, not so I can feel more comfortable around them.
All you do when you keep changing the terminology is to paint over the underlying issue. Namely that people who do not share the characteristics I have (disability) keep trying to come up with stupid ways to label me and others like me rather than using "person".
You know there's one thing that gets me. Boris Johnson's visit just proves why we need independence. Think about it like this. He came to Scotland to a Lab that he was informed the day before had 14 cases of COVID 19. And despite that, he went there anyway.
So straight away, that shows us the Tories are wreckless morons that put their own political advantage about the health and welfare of those in Scotlands communities. Prime Minister superspreader.
But at the same time, it also shows the limited power that Scotland actually has to protect its own citizens because it cannot legislate when it really matters. Why? Because if the Scottish Parliament actually had the powers to do everything - one thing that would have...