And poof. Just like that, Clubhouse—and its rare outpouring of freewheeling debate on taboo topics in the Chinese-speaking world—appears to have been cut off in mainland China. A lovely requiem for the hit Silicon Valley audio-only chat app by @xinwenfan
on.wsj.com/3q4E8nR
@xinwenfan On Monday evening, Clubhouse users from Beijing to Shenzhen said their chats—some of which touched on the plight of China’s Uighur Muslims or the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989—were disconnected mid-conversation, replaced by an error message.
on.wsj.com/3q4E8nR
@xinwenfan Thousands then quickly swamped newly created Clubhouse chat rooms to confirm the blockage after climbing back in using VPNs to circumvent China’s internet firewall. After trading notes, they concluded Chinese censorship was the likely culprit.
@xinwenfan on.wsj.com/3q4E8nR
@xinwenfan Clubhouse users in China had been anticipating a crackdown in the week since the invite-only app began drawing large flocks of new mainland Chinese users. For a moment, it conjured up memories of unblocked Twitter and Facebook a decade earlier.
@xinwenfan
on.wsj.com/3q4E8nR
@xinwenfan In one Clubhouse chat group featuring the voices of food delivery workers, discussion quickly became heated after two of the app’s product managers joined. Long after the delivery workers had left the chat, users continued to debate how they were treated.
on.wsj.com/3q4E8nR
@xinwenfan Clubhouse's surge in China coincided with the first anniversary of the death of Wuhan doctor Li Wenliang, whose death triggered a brief storm of dissent unseen for years in China. On Saturday, users created a chat room to offer a silent tribute to Dr. Li.
on.wsj.com/3q4E8nR
@xinwenfan Hours before the Clubhouse access problems in mainland China, thousands gathered in one chat room created by @badiucao. There, the exiled artist @aiww shared his own experiences about living under surveillance.
@xinwenfan
on.wsj.com/3q4E8nR
@xinwenfan @badiucao @aiww The #MeToo activist Xianzi lost access to her 6,700 Clubhouse followers, but was up to 90 on a new account. Thousands in one chat room exchanged memories of 1989, while in another Hong Kong protesters took questions from Cantonese speakers in Guangzhou.
on.wsj.com/3q4E8nR

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Jonathan Cheng

Jonathan Cheng Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @JChengWSJ

22 Sep 20
How can you ensure that Xinjiang factories aren't using forced labor? You can't, an increasing number of Western supply-chain auditing firms are concluding—a move that could force Western businesses doing work there to exit the region.
@evawxiao
on.wsj.com/2ZZkBKO
@evawxiao Five organizations—from France, Germany, Italy and two from the U.S.—have said they won’t provide labor-audit or inspection services in Xinjiang. The withdrawal of auditing groups adds to the difficulty for brands working with Xinjiang-based suppliers.
on.wsj.com/2ZZkBKO
@evawxiao Auditors face a range of challenges in Xinjiang. Auditors have reportedly been detained or threatened by Chinese authorities. Auditors may have to use government interpreters who convey misinformation when they are visiting factories employing Uighurs.
on.wsj.com/2ZZkBKO
Read 5 tweets
21 Sep 20
Mike Pompeo: "The single rule is this: We don’t want American data in the hands of the Chinese Communist Party…It will end up in the hands of their MSS, their security apparatus, their military, their civil-military fusion programs."
state.gov/secretary-mich…
Pompeo: "The transaction around TikTok, I’ve seen the outlines of it…This deal…will ensure that no American’s data has any access to anyone in China that has any capacity to move this to a place we don’t want it. We will ensure…that firewall is real."
bit.ly/2FLEqye
Pompeo: "Whether there is still some Chinese ownership or they still collect a royalty check from the benefits of the business, there will be an American headquarters…controlled by Americans. And the data…will be in a place that we have confidence."
bit.ly/2FLEqye
Read 4 tweets
10 Sep 20
Fraying ties between Beijing and the West have become the biggest worry for U.S. and European businesses in China, reports from a pair of business groups said this week. “This Beijing-Washington dialogue—they need to work this out."
@Trefor1 @AmChamSh on.wsj.com/3ijoIZ9
@Trefor1 @AmChamSh Worsening bilateral ties now overshadow the rise of Chinese competitors (58%), China’s slowing economy (49%) and increasing labor costs (38%) as the main source of anxiety for U.S. companies operating in China.
@Trefor1 on.wsj.com/3ijoIZ9
@Trefor1 @AmChamSh The European Chamber is also concerned. “There now seems to be a growing list of sectors that either restrict foreign investment, or in which support is provided to China’s national champions to the extent that it squeezes out any potential…competition."
on.wsj.com/3ijoIZ9
Read 4 tweets
9 Sep 20
The Australians' accounts suggest new levels of intimidation of foreign media, raising fears that as ties fray between China and the West, Beijing is less constrained in acting against foreign citizens in the country.
@Chao_Deng @RachelPannett @PhilipWen11
on.wsj.com/2ZjN25w
@Chao_Deng @RachelPannett @PhilipWen11 “What we are witnessing is the greatest deterioration in China’s media controls in decades and that will leave a vacuum of credible reporting at a critical time…It presents a gravely concerning picture of authorities who desire total control.”
@IFJGlobal on.wsj.com/2ZjN25w
@Chao_Deng @RachelPannett @PhilipWen11 @IFJGlobal Chinese state media reported Tuesday that Australian law enforcement seized the computers and mobile phones of Chinese journalists suspected of violating the country’s law against foreign interference. One said the raids took place on June 26.
on.wsj.com/2ZjN25w
Read 4 tweets
5 Sep 20
Senior Chinese diplomat Lu Kang on Meng Wanzhou and Sino-Canadian relations: "This is an issue that could bring about more opportunity costs for the Canadian Government and for our bilateral relationship in general."
@nvanderklippe h/t @felixliuworld
bit.ly/2F4aNrl
@nvanderklippe @felixliuworld Q: If they are not hostages, then why were they arrested so quickly together on the same day after Meng Wanzhou?
Chinese diplomat Lu Kang: Actually for today’s world, that happens…You can’t just link everything together.
@nvanderklippe bit.ly/2F4aNrl
@nvanderklippe @felixliuworld Q: Is this the goal of China’s foreign policy to make other countries fear China?
Lu Kang: That is never our policy. And that is not the whole picture for Chinese diplomacy…Don’t just focus on a couple of countries…It just happens…there are some issues.
bit.ly/2F4aNrl
Read 5 tweets
4 Sep 20
Police in one Inner Mongolia city published photos of 90 people who joined protests against Mandarin-language education policies. The photos appeared to be taken from surveillance-camera footage. “The police will thoroughly investigate them all."
@evawxiao on.wsj.com/3hV2rRh
@evawxiao "In response to the civil unrest and boycotting of classes this past week, the local government also instructed cadres to discipline those who spread rumors, especially those with 'inappropriate views' of the central government."
@evawxiao on.wsj.com/3hV2rRh
@evawxiao “Our ethnic language will slowly disappear—parents are worried about this,” said one woman whose daughter is starting third grade. In Inner Mongolia, which is one-sixth ethnic Mongolian, children already pick up Mandarin via TV and daily life, she said.
on.wsj.com/3hV2rRh
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!