Subtle racism DOES exist. When I was in the nightlife business, a life-world ago, clubs paid a promoter friend $5 per head to bring in patrons. NO club - not one: white, Black, Hispanic - would pay for fighting-age males of their non-primary race, and this hit POC the hardest.
(2) The real question is how much impact this sort of thing - which is what probably 90% of good Sociological studies focus on finding - has in the real world, where it is countered by less-often-studied affirmative action, majority non-racism, and MINORITY group preferences.
(3) My take, looking at U.S. group income and education data is: not much. Many/most of the most successful groups in the USA (Indians, E. Asians, Nigerians) are POC, and even W/B gaps largely collapse after basic adjustments for things like age, region, and test scores.
(4) This also gets into the awkward terrain of "rational discrimination." No club, so far as I know, objects to pretty Black or Asian WOMEN - or white blondes, on the POC side. Is the ONLY reason to hesitate before mixing 100 white soldiers into a tough Latin club "racism?"
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I make four basic points about racism. 1st, there obviously is mild but REAL racism in the USA...like every human society. Studies find that that 8% of whites wouldn't vote for a qualified Black President (Pew 2016), Blacks are 6-9% less likely to be rented a nice apartment, etc.
(2) But, it can't be ignored that the USA spent an EXTRAORDINARY amount of blood/treasure compensating for racism this century. Brown v. Board dates back to 1954, the Civil Rights Act made discrimination ILLEGAL in '64, and pro-minority affirmative action dates to 1967.
(3) In the context of this actual history, we don't see "oppression" today as much as a complex mix of advantages for whites and POC. A Black or Hispanic student has a 200-300 point SAT advantage (Sander & Taylor 2012) over an equally qualified white kid when applying to college.
Short thread: my page has a pretty high healthy-banter level, and I often get asked: "Do you write off twitter?"
Yes. I've put out quite a few pieces lately. This is an article for the academically-focused 'Minding the Campus' series, with @NASorg: mindingthecampus.org/2021/01/28/the…
(2) This, for @Quillette, is an empirical analysis of the effect of police pullbacks - and other variables, such as the COVID-19 pandemic itself - on murder/major crime in 2020. quillette.com/2021/01/27/did…
The biggest "conspiracy theory" in the USA today is that there are massively powerful but almost entirely hidden racist forces at work, which explain every single discrepancy in performance between whites and POC, but somehow don't affect Asians or Nigerians at all.
(2) What does explain gaps? Dozens of empiricists (Sowell, O'Neill, Chua, Fryer, etc.) have found that adjusting for cultural/situational variables that differ between groups - mean AGE, region of residence (the South?), basic qualifications like SAT score - closes ~all of them.
(3) This doesn't mean Black or Native (or Appalachian) Americans can't be disadvantaged as re income/schooling by PAST conflict. It DOES mean no "subtle, untrackable" demons will cause a Nigerian Penn Stater with a solid 1300 GRE to have a very different life from a white peer.
A few last thoughts on the pro-Trump riot yesterday. 1st, it was illegal, ridiculous, and must be severely punished. Rioting is generally disgusting, because of the "dark fun" element of destruction for its own sake. Govts should beat rioters in 'battle,' then toss 'em in prison.
(2) That said, it's frankly difficult for me to see this as some "unique evil." In 2020-21, we've seen many places almost as unique/notable damaged FAR worse - active police stations (!), major federal court-houses, my hometown Mag Mile, what's left of where CHAZ was, etc.
(3) I also don't follow the argument that Black protesters would have been treated far worse than right-wingers. "Room to destroy" BLM/Antifa protesters were in fact often almost coddled. On the Trump side, at least 1 woman was shot to death by police, and 4 people in total died.
Gotta say: the claim that right-wing protesters/rioters in DC would all be dead "if they were Black" is....kiiiiiinda contradicted by the entire past summer of giant, 30+% Black, left-wing riots that caused $2B in damage and generally weren't punished at all. #so_theres_that
(2) For anyone arguing the summer rioters picked low-profile targets: they set an active police precinct - the Minneapolis 3rd - on fire with the cops in it. The "national church," St. John's across from the WH, was literally attacked and damaged at one point. The list goes on.
(3) Of course, ALL rioting is bad, and people found to have been actually violent during a riot should ALL be arrested and severely punished...right?
Speaking frankly, AS an academic, the reason many smart normal citizens distrust academic 'experts' is that they see entire fields ("____ Studies") as being full primarily of low-IQ radicals. This is......not entirely inaccurate, Sokal 2 being just the latest hard evidence.
(2) I searched this graphic, posted to the thread, and it seems to basically be accurate - although a bit dated, and presumably obtained via some kind of GRE norming. #IQs_by_field
These are GRE scores by field. Good to see POLS holding its own, son! ets.org/s/gre/pdf/gre_…
(3) Worth noting - "critical theory" under art history refers strictly to that in the context of art, the one field where po-mo can be useful. The "Studies" fields are grouped under "Other Social Science," IIRC.