Reminder that MBS is stuck in power. This guy locked up his own senior family members and regime elites and tortured them until they handed over their fortunes. There is no future for MBS out of power, once he's out of power a thousand knives await him.
Asking MBS to leave power is basically asking him to commit suicide, he can't do it even if he wanted to. Expecting the King to sideline him is also strange given how MBS actually runs the king and not vice versa. Asking the family to sideline MBS is asking for a coup.
Meanwhile hitting MBS with max sanctions will isolate him, but then he can't step down (see above). If isolated and feeling threatened, he'll become more ferocious and repressive, and will lean more on his buddies MBZ and Netanyahu to help him survive and repress
Today @gatnash and I mapped out a decision tree of all possible outcomes (will publish soon). It appears it's best to shoot for realistic demands such as release of prisoners + lifting travel bans + no more crackdowns; under pain of max sanctions.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The declassified ODNI report is now live. No surprises here. MBS ordered the Khashoggi murder: docdroid.net/9eJivlh/assess…
"We have high confidence that the following individuals participated in, ordered, or were otherwise complicit in or responsible for the death of Jamal Khashoggi on behalf of Muhammad bin Salman". 21 named.
I'm kinda uncomfortable with proposals that focus on punishing MBS without centering the causes for which Jamal died - democracy & free speech. I hope the pressure on MBS works, but I caution that turning MBS into a 21st century Saddam will not do justice to Jamal's legacy.
I'm tracking Saudi regime disinfo output to gauge the current mood there, and the messages are clearly ones of defiance. MBS is digging his heels. I'm happy to be proven wrong but it's unlikely US pressure will manage to dislodge him as Crown Prince or de facto leader
Reminder that MBS is not alone in the region. Israel has famously given him the hacking software he used to hack & track Jamal and others. Israel even analyzes the data he steals. And as of this morning, Israel is signalling they are standing by him:
قل اللهم مالك الملك، تؤتي الملك من تشاء، وتنزع الملك ممن تشاء، وتعز من تشاء، وتذل من تشاء، بيدك الخير، إنك على كل شيء قدير. تولج الليل في النهار وتولج النهار في الليل، وتخرج الحي من الميت وتخرج الميت من الحي، وترزق من تشاء بغير حساب.
اللهم إنه قد طغى وتجبر، وسرق وقتل، وظلم وفجر، اللهم وإن ناصيته بيدك، أنت مدركه أينما سلك، وقادر عليه أينما لجأ، وأنت أقرب إليه من جنبات نفسه، اللهم فانزع عنه سربال عزك الذي لم يجازه بالإحسان، واجعله لمن خلفه آية واشف صدور قوم مؤمنين
اللهم كما أنعمت علي بالإيمان، وكما نجيتني من غيابة السجن، وكما أنقذتني من التيه، وكما نجيت أهلي وأتيت بهم إلي، وكما أدبتني وأكرمتي وأسبغت علي نعمك، اللهم فزدني تأديبا وأحسن بلائي واكتبني في الصالحين. رب بما أنعمت علي فلن أكون ظهيرا للمجرمين
The spiritual teacher is nothing like the teacher we encounter in schools or colleges. The role of the spiritual teacher isn't to give you information. Rather it's to give you a chisel and then cram you into a difficult corner so you can sculpt yourself out of it.
In this, you are the tool and you are the subject, and you cannot become anything without literally hammering and digging into yourself, and shedding parts of yourself.
Many people raise their hands and say "I am ready", virtually all of them are not. If you are truly ready and truly understand what this entails, you will be saying it with trepidation, not with gusto.
Kidnapped, accused of treason, tortured, disappeared, brought before terrorism court... all while innocent of anything but campaigning for women's rights. Loujain is finally released but is still under severe restrictions. Alhamdulillah, the fight for her freedom continues.
As we celebrate let's remember that Loujain is not yet free. She is still under probation and under travel restrictions, and is not allowed to speak to the media or have full control of her own social media accounts. Let's commit to keep fighting until she is completely free.
Let's also commit to ensuring accountability and bringing to justice those who persecuted her, kidnapped her, tarnished her reputation in state papers, tortured her, covered up the torture, denied her due process, and convicted her of a non-crime. They should be the ones in jail.
The moral of the story is that it's easier for Arabs to reach Mars than to have free speech or human rights or due process or rule of law. Also that the UAE regime will throw money at any project that can sciencewash its horrendous human rights record
As an Arab, I don't need a mission to Mars by an insidiously destructive dictatorship such as the UAE regime. I need the right to live, love, and speak freely with full human rights and human dignity in my native region.
The UAE regime has the blood of countless Arabs on its hands. It has intervened to prevent democratic transitions across the region, costing the lives and liberty of millions of Arabs. Sending a mission to Mars is a cynical attempt to turn the world's attention elsewhere.