"'Inclusive excellence' is a way to maybe offer kinder or gentler exclusion, or a less transparent exclusion. But the category of excellence is still going to retain its ideological agenda until we confront it on a systematic, everyday, concrete basis." - Dr. Roderick Ferguson
(This is from Dr. Ferguson's #DiversityAtKU talk - couldn't fit the hashtag in this first Tweet!)
As I'm listening to Dr. Ferguson's talk I'm thinking about these current cluster hires for Black faculty (like at McMaster University, where I recently held a postdoc), and how universities talk endlessly about Black excellence but haven't even made commitments to Black life.
"We're asked to be satisfied by these individual and personal aggrandizements and enrichments, but what if you understood your meaning, your success, as the creation of collective opportunities for people?"
- Dr. Ferguson
Dr. Ferguson talked about doing that isn't claimed by institutions (for things like tenure dossiers), and the deliberateness of that choice. My reflection on that is to not always assume that folks *can't* do parts of their work in academia, but that they don't *want* to.
Which is to say I also think about this from the position of students as well, particularly with the pressures of doing more work that is legible to the institution being a way of getting more opportunities for career advancement (postdocs, other fellowships).
(But I also think about it from the perspective of those who aren't trying to re-enter the academy after we've chosen to leave or had no choice but to leave or both.)

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Lucia Lorenzi

Lucia Lorenzi Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @empathywarrior

25 Feb
I'm currently doing an intake form for the pain clinic that does surgical procedures and I think it's hilarious (in a bad and awful way) that we still give these pain questionnaires to people like they 1) are somehow neutral; 2) aren't written from an abled perspective of pain
I see you, questionnaires, trying to elicit a particular narrative from me.
"Patient note: I've opted not to complete these particular questionnaires for X reasons, I'm happy to discuss my relationship to pain and illness more at our intake session!" is a phrase I just annotated this with.
Read 11 tweets
24 Feb
I wonder for how many other scholars who have taken time away from their research (or from whom research time has been taken away) there is a significant forgetting of what you know. I can't name a lot of what I read anymore. I feel, often, like I would be embarrassed to teach.
In the five years since I finished my PhD, I have not done research for many reasons. First, because I was unemployed and too worried about money - for a while my only income was poorly-paid marking at a local college - to even think or write or read.
And then, I had a non-academic job, and I commuted three hours round-trip each day for it. At one point, I worked four days a week at that job and then commuted out to UBC to write sometimes, since I still knew grad students in the department.
Read 30 tweets
23 Feb
Can't wait to quote MC Hammer in my (hopefully eventual) MSc thesis one day. I am also working on risk of bias assessments of clinical trials today so am as always thinking about the broader ecosystem of judgment and knowledge-creation in which we do scientific work...
Which is to say that my thinking about questions about truth and certainty and reliability in the humanities (and the systems of power and relation in which they circulate) is what drives my interest in the sciences as well, and why I care so much about evidence synthesis.
This morning/afternoon, I'm attending a symposium on automation for systematic reviews, and the questions of who creates the automation and what underlying philosophies or assumptions we use to automate synthesis (as with any form of automation) are deeply important!
Read 6 tweets
21 Feb
I had such a great morning, then didn't realize how badly I was overheating in a shower, and just spent two hours out cold in my bed. I'm downing a ton of salt now. I think...I think this is the hardest part of chronic illness. Every day can be so unpredictable. #Dysautonomia
As I said to some folks in this morning's writing group, I'm re-learning to write in a sustained fashion when my health is worse than it was 6 years ago, when I was writing my dissertation. I still wrongly assume my baseline is "healthy" rather than "presently symptom-free."
I love the illusion of cure, and I won't say my attachments to it are entirely maladaptive. In a good run of days, sometimes weeks, I could really believe that the new roofing or the re-tiled hallway of the house that is my body somehow negates the slowly crumbling foundation.
Read 5 tweets
19 Feb
I woke up this morning trying to think through my feelings of envy around PhD admissions and TT job announcements, and I realized that it's much less about wishing I could do another PhD or have a TT job as it's about how academia has no space for independent scholars.
Or very little, anyway. I'm thinking about the restrictions on summer theory schools and intensives, about fellowships that are about wanting faculty with existing affiliations to spend time at another institution, and it's just like...it doesn't have to be this way?
So yeah, when you have a stale PhD but want to keep learning, pivoting fields, and trying to make time to get writing done, I don't think the envy around people newly-admitted to PhD programs or getting TT jobs is entirely unreasonable. (I think.)
Read 13 tweets
11 Feb
Whenever I see postdoc ads, I still click on them. And then I see that they have a 5-year limit on PhD freshness and I both laugh and cry. Especially when these are for Black and/or Indigenous scholars! And in this pandemic time? *sucks teeth*
There is a real sharpness to this violence of time and expired use value, not just of the ideas but of the bodies and the communities in which those ideas circulate, live, ferment. I am thinking about how this lives along the ideas of “Black excellence” in universities.
As a trauma theorist and memory studies scholar I just would please like a shirt that says my graduation year on it and then the word “BELATED” in all-caps and a loud font, but my point is, time isn’t neutral and I am not surprised how institutional time is further hardening
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!