solidarity with all those affected by this restructuring and whose jobs are under threat @VandPcs
Given this scale of loss, why not just cancel the white elephant that is V&A East instead?
omg in fact it's a chronological structure for Europe and America across four departments - BUT then hiving off Africa and Asia — which clearly don't have histories — into their own separate department
HOW did anyone think such a world view was acceptable in 2021?
incredibly shocked and upset by this news @TristramHuntVA - as I'm sure many who love the V&A and understand why it matters will be
maybe the imaginary National History Museum will come exist after all
reducing the @V_and_A's foundational ethos of celebrating design across cultures with mere chronology—while evicting expert material departments, separating out "research" in some ivory tower, and hiving off the global south to some "unhistorical" annexe
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
can someone close to @TristramHuntVA please persuade him that this is NOT the moment to resurrect Hugh Trevor-Roper's claim that there is no history in Africa?
even the British Museum lumps Africa and Asia with the Americas!
This proposed scheme is Trumpian in its world-view
the ideology that claims the global south exists outside history has a history.
the V&A scheme is almost precisely that adopted when Oxford divided collections between the multi-department @AshmoleanMuseum and the @Pitt_Rivers in 1884 — the same year as the Berlin Congress.
the consultants missed a trick by not including fascist architect Albert Speer's theory of Ruinenwerttheorie (ruin value) here — could've gone down quite well with the Common Sense Group
on knowing the price of everything, the value of nothing, and nothing at all about heritage management
Pretty sure it wasn't written by a "baying mob", but the new DCMS report on valuing heritage assets defines sculptures and plaques as — wait for it — "moveable heritage".
And, specifically, as examples of a class of heritage "that can be moved into a collection or is mobile"
(2/34)
I had always believed what I’d been told about the Benin Bronzes. That the British punitive expedition against Benin City (today in Edo State, Nigeria) was a necessary reprisal against a bloody massacre. That there was a grim justification to the looting of the city
(3/34) in February 1897, because the Government needed to auction African artefacts to defray the costs of the naval operation. That taking the spoils of war is a human universal, so special pleading in the case of the Kingdom of Benin would only open a Pandora’s box.