Since the 2020 protests, thirteen state legislatures have considered bills that would make the removal of public monuments more difficult, ranging from adding a few bureaucratic hoops to flat-out prohibitions. Here's my list:
Georgia HB 238 (2/2021): forbids authorities from removing or concealing any publicly owned monument to any military personnel, whether of US or the Confederate States of America.
Idaho HB 65 (2021): "No… Civil War… monuments or memorials in place prior to July 1, 2021... may be relocated, removed, disturbed, or altered without approval of the legislature via concurrent resolution."
Indiana SB 187 (2/2021): state support will be withheld from political subdivisions that have failed to protect public monuments, memorials, and statues from destruction or vandalism.
Kentucky SCR7 (2021): Concurrent resolution requesting state and local officials and judiciary to dedicate resources to protecting public monuments.
Mississippi HB 120 (2021): monuments located on public property shall not be relocated, removed, disturbed, altered, renamed or rededicated unless specifically authorized by an act of the legislature.
SB 2386 (2021): would strip local officials of authority to move monuments
Missouri HB 1751 (01-05 2020): prohibits authorities from modifying, removing, or concealing any state historic military monument
HB 55 (2021): prohibits removing monuments without approval from the Missouri advisory council on historic preservation
New York Bill No. S00242: Classifies military monuments and memorials as parkland and provides that no such monument or memorial shall be alienated, developed, leased, transferred, sold or discontinued for use as a memorial site without the approval of the legislature.
New Jersey: AR 116 (2021): Opposes any reduction in size of, or level of protection afforded to, any currently designated national monument.
Ohio SB 59 (2021): Amends 149.30 and 155.99 to enact 155.28 of Revised Code to prohibit certain war relics located on public property or cemetery association property from being disposed of, and the designate this act as the Ohio Veterans' Heritage Protection Act.
Pennsylvania SB 1321 (2020): a public monument may not be permanently removed, except as specifically approved by an act of the General Assembly.
South Carolina: HB 3358 (2021): prohibits local authorities from removing a monument; any member of a local governing body who votes for such removal is guilty of a misdemeanor and must be fined twenty-five million dollars.
Similar: HB 3249 (2021) and HB 3357 (2021).
Tennessee SB 1066 (2021): requires waiver from Tennessee historical commission for the movement or alteration of a memorial to be approved by joint resolution of the general assembly
SB 1288 (2021): violation of heritage protection laws by a public official = Class C misdemeanor
Thank you to @maczpriest for doing the legwork to track down the text of these bills!
Here's the companion thread on state legislatures seeking to increase criminal penalties for damaging public monuments:
I've been tracking state legislatures that have seen the introduction of bills proposing increasing criminal penalties for vandalizing monuments since the 2020 protests. Here's my list:
Alabama HB 133 (2021): would establish the crimes of damaging a public monument in the 1st and 2nd degrees, would provide criminal penalties, including a mandatory minimum sentence for a violation, and would provide for a mandatory holding period for an arrest.
Arizona HB 2552 (2021): damaging a public monument = aggravated criminal damage
SB 1639 (2021): recklessly damaging a public monument = criminal damage and enacts punishments for different degrees
Super specific question time: can anyone remember an instance of someone praising an artwork they deliberately destroyed?
I can only think of people saying what they destroyed or damaged was not really art, or not good art (with possible exception of Rauschenberg erasing that de Kooning).
I'm asking because I'm thinking about what a common move it is for iconoclasts (writ broadly) to say they don't think what they're destroying is art or good art. I had been thinking of this as a rhetorical technique, to convince an audience, but I'm starting to wonder if...
Want to know more about how white supremacy is baked in to the US Capitol Building? Let's think about the statue topping its dome. She symbolizes Freedom... and was made in part by Philip Reed, an enslaved man. (Thread)
Thomas Crawford was commissioned to sculpt Freedom in 1854 - but he had to redo his original design (left) after Jefferson Davis threw a temper tantrum about... her hat.
The future president of the Confederacy was then the Secretary of War and oversaw the expansion and decoration of the Capitol Building. He used his position made sure that none of the new sculptures and paintings for the building criticized slavery.
There've been many protests over monuments honoring people who did horrific things. But what does it mean that America's public art is filled with statues of generic white men? Read @intersectionist's brilliant essay on America's imagery of white heritage: intersectionist.medium.com/american-power…
Her essay starts from the question of why no statues have fallen in NYC this year and broadens to explain the white suprematism underlying America’s heritage of public art and architecture, from her point of view as a POC in the white-dominated field of historic preservation.
I'll summarize some of her essay in this thread. She begins by noting that NYC has the dubious honor of being one of the only major US cities that has not lost a statue during the uprisings after the death of George Floyd.
The reserve price for this fossilized heap of Weetabix hasn't been met - shocker! No one's willing to pay more than $12k for an object from a heavily looted conflict zone with absolutely no information about when it entered the US?!?
Also: "Bronze Age Limestone Votive Sculpture" described as standing "in awe before some god the world has now forgotten"? Look, if you can't plausibly fit your fake into a known culture, don't accuse the world of forgetfulness, buddy.