The thing that depresses me about the last few days of Copyright Discourse is how many people have cheerfully told me, in so many words, that yes, they really do want me to starve.
I have also been informed that “writing is only for rich people and a few rare talents” that I shouldn’t get royalties because “Society doesn’t owe me a living,” a couple variants on how we are greedy and selfish and capitalists (but we actually do own the means of production?)—
—that lots of people would be thrilled to write books and can’t so why should I get to, and that elderly comic creators screwed out of royalties by gigantic entertainment megacorps are at fault for not having put enough in Social Security and should just get jobs.
I have the hide of a rhino and this is starting to get even me down a bit. Like, apparently a non-zero people are genuinely angry at writers for having the gall to write. I don’t even know what to do with that.
Ooh! I just got “Copyright was never meant to reward authors or any such silliness.”
I have just been called a neoliberal rivaling Clinton! Go me.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Wow, in the "rippling consequences" department, manufacturing has already been stretched thin because of COVID, and now the freeze in Texas shut down the resin production that makes plastic, which means my feed store is like "You order your greenhouse plastic NOW, people!"
Apparently there are now products they can't stock because there are no plastic bottles for the manufacturer to put the product in.
This is honestly fascinating, in a "fragility-of-civilization" kinda way.
(No, the solution here is not necessarily to use glass bottles--we're talking about chemicals, some of which are nasty before being diluted, some of which you really, really don't want to break all over the floor, like bug spray.)
Dude tweeted that “Biden decided” to drop $100 from unemployment because Manchin was making noises about it. But Biden is not actually Manchin, AND it was all still in negotiations in Congress AND it didn’t turn out that way.
Right! Here is your friendly neighborhood Salvia enthusiast weighing in to remind my fellow white people that white sage (Salvia apiana) is sacred to indigenous people, many of which have expressed the desire that we leave it alone because we’re killing it all off!
I am not equipped to talk about the spiritual side, but boy, can I talk about Salvia cultivation, and boy, is S. apiana in a world of hurt! Let’s talk about why!
White sage is a shrub that lives in coastal sage scrub, on the edge of the desert. Amazing habitat, coastal scrub. Still is, even though it has been badly overgrazed by cattle. Cattle don’t eat sage, but they do eat a lot of other things, and their hooves cut up the soil.
Seriously, one of the creepiest drives of my entire life was pre-dawn in hill country. The roads were lined with hundreds of Axis deer, their eyes in headlights. Worse, the blacktop was absolutely smeared in roadkill.
Every few minutes, the lead car would radio back a warning because there’d be a carcass in the middle of the road still intact enough that you’d have to swerve around it. And you’re doing it with these hundreds of pale white eyes staring at you out of the gloom.
Since apparently some people need the reminder: Letting a book go out of print is not censorship! Books go out of print all the time! I myself have several books that are out of print in various formats. They have not been censored, they just aren’t being printed any more.
If you are yelling censorship because an author’s estate said “Mmmm...nah...let’s not keep printing those...” then I’m not sure what to tell you. Do you want the government to force those people to print the books? That seems excessive.
I must conclude that perhaps you are completely ignorant of the publishing industry, where books are not eternally in print. No, not even with POD. A gazillion books are out of print!
90% of the conversations I have with other authors about our books consists of stuff like “This book is not working, I will never finish it, my editor will have me killed,” “I will die before that book earns out,” and “That book over there did well, god knows why.”
Conversations I do NOT have: “The symbolism of this book is deep and meaningful.” “That book is an exploration of themes of loss and longing.” “I wore pants while writing that other book.”
10% is one of us saying enthusiastically “Okay, but I LOVED your book!” and then the author gets flustered and says “oh my god I didn’t actually expect you to read it wow thank you jeez”