Took my 67 year old mother for her vaccination today. We live in a small village in the Munsyari block of Pithoragarh district of Uttarakhand. So went online to register her and the system allocated a time today 6th March afternoon at the local PHC. 2/n
The online registration was smooth and a quick sms came to her phone confirming her appointment. But when we reached the local PHC - the person at registration desk said “sorry we can not give you vaccine today” 3/n
My mother, herself a retired doctors asked - why. She was told we can not open a 10 dose vial for one person. Leave your number behind we will call when more people are there. You should have come in the morning. 4/n
My mother asked to speak to the doctor on duty. She asked him “what if I get covid in next two days, will you or this centre take the responsibly of refusing me a vaccine when I was legally allowed to take it because the rest of it would be wasted?” 5/n
To which the registration desk person replied “well I just turned a 69 year old away saying the same thing “ my mother then asked, “if that is the case then why did you confirm an appointment - confirm them only in multiples of 10. “ 6/n
They had no answer. She then insisted that they call the other gent also and vaccinate both of them. Finally they relented and called him. And then requested me to call anyone else we may know who would want to get vaccinated. 7/n
So we called a few village ladies above 60. Most said they didn’t even know they could get vaccinated. Didn’t know how to get their papers. So we asked the PHC why don’t they work with panchayat and gram Pradhans. They said it wasn’t their job. 8/n
Since we were feeling mortified that doses may be wasted we also called my husband 55 yrs old with serious hypertension and cardiac issues to bring his latest reports done at a Bareilly hospital - 14 hrs drive from here. And registered him. 9/n
He reached the centre and doctor examined his reports and confirmed that he can be given the vaccine. The registration desk person then came in and said that he had called the DCCM as he was instructed to do so when a comorbidity case first comes. 10/n
The Gent explained to the doctor that my husband would have to go to Bareilly hospital - 14 hrs drive away & get a letter from the same doctor first. That letter will then need to be sent to District headquarters at Pithoragarh for approval & only then he can be vaccinated 11/n
I then asked whether we could get it on a whats app. They finally relented and said we can try. I shudder to think what someone in a rural area with no knowledge of systems, English or access to tech would have done had they been in our shoes 12/n
So I am asking some questions to the govt : 1. Why are you making people in rural areas travel for 3-4 hours only to send them back because you don’t have a system that has taken into account basic dosage volume. Your system should only assign in lots of ten. 13/n
2. Why do you have such pathetic processes that no one in rural india can follow. You do know that districts don’t have necessary healthcare infrastructure. Where will the poor citizen go? 14/n
3. Why can’t you at each centre post 4pm open up walk-In’s so that dosages don’t go waste. I presume you also have expiry on some of these. 15/n
4. Why should someone with comorbidity or disability have to be made to run around when the govt’s job is to make their vaccination easy and safe - and 5. How may doses have been wasted already? Because they have been bought with public money some accountability must come. 16/n
update: my mother just received a call from same registration person who said he was being asked whether she had been vaccinated or not. She asked me to call him. I called him & said “we have said she was vaccinated post her insistence, my husband still remains to be vaccinated.”
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Since there was an overwhelming demand for me to be specific & share what changes are warranted in the Farm reforms I am putting this thread out. I will be objective & share what works & what doesn’t. I agree that we need agri reforms but these loopholes need to be addressed. 1/n
I would like to begin with The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Act 2020. Guidelines for Farming Agreement. The link to the full text is given below 2/n
Section 1 Farming Agreement - lays clearly and simply the need and purpose of an agreement between farmer/FPO and buyer and the relevant act that governs it. But calls the buyer a “Sponsor”. This is surprisingly not so in the act but in this guideline buyer becomes a sponsor 2/n
When you read the fine print of the farm laws-you realise the loopholes and gaps in these reforms. There are three mistakes in the approach here : 1. Not doing a focused parliamentary debate - an issue that affects 65% of country’s labour force, 3-4% of its GDP merited that 1/5
2. When farmers from some states supported and from some opposed the Govt should have realised that it was passing an ad hoc reform without understanding that you can’t apply rules of grains to pulses and those of pulses to fruits and vegetables. 2/5
3. In a democracy to pass reforms without public debate is hazardous & unnecessary. The process takes time but not doing it paralyses the functioning of it. The 1991 reforms were given much room for debate. Those who opposed it eventually became its ambassadors & benefited 3/5