So the defence journo @sneheshphilip wrote this piece in @ShekharGupta run @ThePrintIndia about @SecDef presser. If you read the piece, you will feel as if only issue that was discussed by Secy was on Human Rights with sideline comment abt Indo China standoff-typical media shit!
Defence and strategic affairs journalist at @ThePrintIndia - Sh @sneheshphilip wrote a piece -won’t quote link to give them free eyeballs. After reading that piece, you will feel as if US came with a msg following @SenatorMenendez ‘s letter & delivered it -however reality is diff
The organisers of @secdef s presser made it clear at the start that it will last for 20 mins and it started with first Qn thrown to Jim- journalist who was part of @SecDef s entourage and was travelling with him..benefit of hindsight helps me imagine the face of SP/VS at first Qn
Expectedly & more so after what happd at Alaska in d meeting b/w @SecBlinken & his Chinese counterpart Yang Jiechi (quoted tweet), Jim began @SecDef s presser by asking Qn on Quad/ Asean & how he foresee it materialising & operationalising- no mention in @sneheshphilips report!
What @SecDef replied to opening Qn is there for everyone to see. But what is bizarre here is that someone who calls himself a def journo & makes round of every strategic ministry & institution in Del - @sneheshphilip -didn’t find this ans worth reporting- see what he reported
3rd Qn of the presser went to @VishnuNDTV ; although his name was inaudible, yet the man was so charged up following @SenatorMenendez ‘s letter that expectedly so, he made it a centre piece. Ab agenda to chalana hai na.... I have already detailed this here
As presser in which @SecDef answered 14 Qns in total - of which 12 were abt issues like Quad, ASEAN, China, Afg, S400; only two of them were on matters not relating to strategic cooperation and def- one by @VishnuNDTV (thread below) & other by Sylvie!
If u ask me wt is agenda journalism/I will ans as below.

Imagine going to a presser of US @SecDef - where out of 14 Qns, u get to ask twice as Secy asks for clarification b4 answering (Pic 1 & 2);then u write a piece of 412 words & only 74 are dedicated to own Qn @sneheshphilip

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Alok Bhatt

Alok Bhatt Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @alok_bhatt

21 Mar
Politics, as we see from Twitter is no way closer to what it is from inside. It is super easy to sermonise from outside in 280 characters. Ditto for governance. Neither are there any full stops in politics nor are permanent friends. Hindu revivalism need power consolidation!
Supporters on our side don’t have patience; their best weapon against own leaders is sarcasm. Bhai aur behno, jinhonne 2 baar desh mein election jeeta hai aur jo har jagah jeet rahe hain, wo jaante hain ki kab kya karna hai- power consolidation is a must for long term safety!
Folks used to abuse BJP day in day out for tying up with PDP- crude reality is that but for that experience of governing JK and subsequent win in 2019, 370 would still be in force. Power consolidation ke results aise aate hain..... lekin patience kahan se laayein!
Read 5 tweets
21 Mar
“Q: Hello,Secy.Welcome to Ind. Do u share concerns expressd by Senate Foreign Relations Comm chief tht Ind was trending away fm democracy?In his letter to u,suggestd that crackdown on progressive farmers,intimidating journos & gov critics was problematic? Do u share tht concern?”
This Qn was asked by @NDTV ‘s @VishnuSom (who got this job thanks to his late IAS officer dada Himachal Som- ans loyally recruited by Prannoy Roy as per NDTVs recruitment policy) from American Defense Secretary Gen @SecDef yesterday. Why blame Americans for answering a loaded Q
Traitors from @ndtv continue their game of asking loaded Qns to visiting Americans- @nidhi did this to Obama, Mirchandani/Jacob were regular on this circuit during their stint in Washington & now @VishnuNDTV-did same to go to town to beat Modi with “Americans are upset”narrative!
Read 5 tweets
20 Mar
Pakistani Twitter is lit after their PM tested positive/ meanwhile PMs tweet must have been the succour he must have been looking for post testing- after all he tried everything in the book to receive his reply in the past!
Another one 😁😁
Comment on white tent!
Read 4 tweets
20 Mar
. @ShekharGupta ‘s lame yet cunning attempt to build a case for India accepting olive branch extended by Bajwa is not gonna cut much ice as present dispensation doesn’t suffer from “cousin syndrome”, nor were they fed on stories of how cool pre 47 life was in Karachi or Lahore!
This India will not be singing peace duets while the truce is on;I have no doubt that the truce, if it comes, will be used to squeeze Pak further & from all corners-“more the merrier” will be the motto!

Rest assured, Modi’s India won’t give them breather they are looking for!
I said this in 14 & I still believe in this-no matter how hard @ShekharGupta tries to build a case for trusting Bajwa by first distrusting him -fact remains that there won’t be any flip-flops as PM @narendramodi doesn’t come with notions of pre 47 Ind >
Read 4 tweets
20 Mar
He is a “Punjabi” Gupta and that explains why he is doing “Bhangra” to Bajwa’s dhol!
And anyone taking offence of my tweet need to read what he talked about Bajwa’s pucca Punjabi accent
“Nehru’s was a much weaker government in 1962 than Modi’s now. He had no choice but to go down fighting, Modi is too strong to fall in that trap. He would prefer peace, not war.” - glorifying Nehru’s defeat in @ShekharGupta ‘s words!
Read 5 tweets
19 Mar
#BhainsaRiots : country of one billion Hindus is finding it difficult to save Hindus of a small town with almost 50% Hindus; can’t have any media outlet,discussing a slap incident n ripped jeans, to debate rape of a 4 yrs old- whose fault? Whose fault it is- stop being victims!
Saw a small mob of 50 skull cap wearing men threatening a police officer; urging him to meet without uniform.....what gave them that power..... nothing else but भीड़; they are nothing without भीड़.....what stops you from assembling a bigger भीड़ in bhainsa? Why cry victim!
Hindus are prisoner of their own self- we are 1 billion individuals; not one billion Hindus & it starts from that.....every damn problem has its origin in that one individual existence of ours, even within that mass of 1 billion!
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!