This is a momentous decision, but California has not abolished cash bail.
Although there is a presumption of release, people can still have bail set that will hold them in jail if a court decides they are a flight risk or a risk to public safety.
California Public Defenders Association President, Jennifer Friedman, makes this point, saying the court, "failed to clearly describe the limited category of individuals who may be detained."
Sadly in situations like this: where reform comes with vaguely-defined exceptions, or where discretion is given to judges, the result can often be a continuation of the status quo - which, in this case, means poor Black and Brown people will continue to be held in jail pre-trial.
I am in no way trying to minimize the significance of the decision. But tweets like this are misleading.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
BREAKING: The Daily Mail has been denied press credentials for the Derek Chauvin trial after a court found they published stolen police body camera footage of George Floyd's death last year.
The court said it was unclear if they stole the footage themselves, but a minimum they paid for footage that was clearly stolen.
The court decision is scathing.
“This Court assumes that the Daily Mail paid for the stolen video footage. The Court is therefore confident that the Daily Mail can pay to obtain the trial exhibits associated with this case."
I feel very conflicted about words like "caged" and "bodies" because my first experience of them being used in the criminal legal system was by court and corrections officers.
In the courtroom, when a person who is incarcerated is being brought up from the holding cells, the court sergeant or even the judge will refer to the person as a "body," as in "another body coming up" or "can we bring up another body." It's completely dehumanizing.
In 2019, 3 Louisiana police troopers choked and beat Ronald Greene, repeatedly jolted him with tasers, then dragged him face-down across the pavement until his body went limp and he died.
Mr. Greene was stopped for a routine traffic violation and then chased by police. He stopped immediately, and put up his hands, saying "I'm sorry.."
There is bodycam footage of the entire encounter, although the trooper who was suspended turned his boydcam off.
Mr. Greene's family have viewed the bodycam footage, but it has not been made public.
The police department initially told the family that Mr. Greene had died in a car accident, but it was clear from his injuries that that was not the case. apnews.com/article/john-b…
DA Jean Peters Baker said that the evidence is not enough to support a conviction beyond a reasonable doubt.
Here's the thing tho, to get an indictment a prosecutor needs only to show there is probable cause a crime was committed (the same standard police need for an arrest).
In any regular case, prosecutors do not assess whether a case can be proved beyond a reasonable doubt before they charge someone or before they present their case to the grand jury.