I dunno, man. These stories make my antennae twitch.
What work are they doing?
Aside Re: @IBJIYONGI’s point about “the ruling class,” there was a version of this from 1990 in the NYT when a big-eared law student became the first Black editor of the Harvard Law Review. (He pointed out the broader context that shapes “firstness.”)
“But it's important that stories like mine aren't used to say that everything is O.K for blacks. You have to remember that for every one of me, there are hundreds or thousands of black students with at least equal talent....”
(Funny bc he became shorthand for “racism is over.”)
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
10 minutes into the @yourewrongabout episode on politics correctness and it already feels like a look at the intellectual history that led to that moral panic-y NYT story about Smith College a few months ago.
One thing that’s important context for fights over “culture” and “free speech” on campuses is that they are primary sites of conflict re: historical and ongoing segregation.
1) These are PWIs established *for* white students and white academics that are still reckoning with the reality that “integration” is more complicated than simply beginning to admit people who ain’t white. (Or straight or able-bodied or...)
Look, i hate the tourist-ification of this word, too. But we were saying this long before all these suburbanites decided they wanted to get their reverse-white flight on and putting it on t-shirts and ugh
Oh, a Penn Law professor from Montgomery County doesn’t like a piece of appropriated Black Philly slang?
@alwaystheself Yeah, it’s one of the confounding things about him. I went through a kick over a decade ago when i read a bunch of biographies of him and came away genuinely surprised at how often I’d heard the exact same views expressed by Black folks of all kinds — it wasn’t illegible at all
@alwaystheself Your point here, about him trauma bonding with white conservatives, is really sharp/important — it’s so much about personal anguish that it ends up not being scalable.
His personal relationship to his grandfather is revealing, too.
@alwaystheself His grandfather — who raised him along with his grandmother from a young age — was a mean, cold man who never showed him any love or tenderness. Thomas called him “the best man i have ever known”; his autobiography is literally called “My Grandfather’s Son.”