I became aware of this ?guy? because everyone in my feed was dunking on the first tweet, but I got curious -- how the heck is a "Kiss Army General" also a religious fanatic? -- Looked at his feed & spotted the second, the "Jesus lends you a hand" tweet --
Which, coming up just after this tweet, gave me Thoughts.
Like, having been raised in the evangelical church I'm extremely familiar with the mem that Jesus is there to help you out but I'm still not exactly sure what he's supposed to do for you.
"Mem" = "meme"
Anyway, long before leaving the church entirely I was really cynical about that "reach out to Jesus!" stuff because it seemed pretty obvious that there was absolutely no correlation between being a Christian &, for example, dying/not dying of cancer.
Even as a kid -- with no conscious intention of leaving the family religion -- I rolled my eyes at the favorite evangelical narrative of the "lost" person who "finds" Christ & turns their life around because I didn't actually know anybody like that.
Everyone I knew who was a Christian, it was because their parents or their spouse or somebody was a Christian already and brought them into it. Or, they were raised in a DIFFERENT Christian religion & converted to the evangelical church as adults.
So, the first thought I had was this: ex-evangelicals who leave & tell the story "you know, actually, the church really messed me up" are a terrible threat to the evangelical story.
Because if what WE say is true (and, uh, it is) then the evangelical faith is exposed as a lie, because it doesn't work at all the way they say it does. It's not a guaranteed path to meaning, comfort, happiness, success in this life and blessed assurance of bliss in the next life
Which is correct, because there is no guaranteed path to any of those things. Everyone has to find their own way. The fact that evangelical Christianity is that path for some -- I mean, good for you? But it means nothing to me. I was ALREADY there, I ALREADY tried it.
But, for evangelicals, who hard-sell their faith as the Best-EVER Product For Life, it's devastating to the brand to have a bunch of unhappy customers leaving no-star reviews on the website.
As in yesterday's "Jesus is chocolate ice cream" thread
But the second thought I had was about how Christianity itself is another "if you need help just ask for it" lie. Like, you're having trouble in life? Oh, sorry to here it, try this imaginary friend!
And it struck me as really weird how normal we seem to think that is. To look at people who are hurting in life and our solution is to try to get them to start talking to our imaginary friend.
<end>
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
RCSJ: "why do people leave the church
well to hear tell from the people who have left the church it's because the people in the church are such horrible big fat jerks"
This is variant of strawman fallacy that I like to call "haters gonna hate" -- to construe all criticism as coming from a place of irrational "hatred" which therefore does not have to be addressed on substance.
I had this idea that it would be funny to have one of the werewolves into making extremely specific & weird perfumes like the "odorifics" from Harold and Maude. yesterdaysperfume.com/yesterdays_per…
So, Russell Moore has just dropped the big premise -- when he was 15 he considered suicide *because he didn't want to lose his religion* and I find that an interesting framing of his crisis because at a similar age I experienced a similar crisis --
Okay, I'm doing it, a close look at that Russell Moore piece. It starts with a bold claim as a title, "Why the Church Is Losing the Next Generation" which promises he's going to do it, he's going to give us THE answer.
"Almost everyone in the world of American religion has spent the last couple of weeks thinking through what Gallup just revealed: that, for the first time since they’ve been surveying the topic, less than half the country belongs to a church of any kind."
"My first thought was grief. But what came after that was a strange sort of almost survivor’s guilt."
"When I was fifteen years old, I considered suicide—and it was because I didn’t want to lose my religion. "
When people like Moore talk about having had moments of religious doubt, or a faith crisis, they always talk about it like it's a problem they overcame, with this kind of attitude of "I did it, you can too!"
And I get it, in a way, because if they're ultimately happy in the religion, they're glad they stayed/came back.
But it reinforces this idea that staying in the religion is, or should be, a *goal*
Since everybody's talking about Disney today, I will too.
Because my Extremely Evangelical grandparents were ALSO my Extremely Disney grandparents -- my grandfather basically got out of the navy and worked for Disneyland until he retired.
So, we could get in cheap, so when I was growing up
(until the age of 12) my family went to Disneyland extremely regularly, maybe every 2-3 months.
But more than that, because Disney was a family legacy, it informed every aspect of my life. Gifts for Christmas & birthday were frequently Disney, we watched The Wonderful World of Disney every week, when we went to see movies as a family at the drive-in they were Disney