Defra Committee cross party MPs release bruising report on “considerable trade friction” & “substantial” new red tape leading to “substantive & enduring” post Brexit costs for food exporters.
- Flatly contradicts in line 1, PM’s assertion of “no non tariff barriers”.
* Report calls for Govt to re-enter discussions with EU to lower new burdens on exporters through veterinary partnership. Says it wasnt achieved by Lord Frost’s negotiation “in part because Govt did not place sufficient priority on it resulting in creation of non-tariff barriers”
* the consequence so far of the non tariff barriers for food exporters, the MPs report says is not just “teething problems” but “imposing enduring costs” which may result in big business “shifting processing to the EU” and smaller businesses finding such exports “unviable”.
* While praising maintenance of zero tariffs with the deal, report also says exporters “have not received the standard of support they should have done to allow them to prepare”, saying Government help was “not sufficiently timely, targeted or joined-up” for new trade barriers
- Also says delay in introducing import checks on food imports from the EU “places British business at a competitive disadvantage, creates incentives to relocate factories and jobs to the EU and increases food safety and bio security risks” & reduces incentive for EU to negotiate
So PM asserted his deal creates “no Non Tariff Barriers to trade”.
Cross party Conservative-chaired group of MPs, after evidence from dozens impacted says new NTBs
- exist
- are substantial, making exports “unviable” for some
- result partly from Govt negotiation priorities...
Govt response to this report:
“The TCA has allowed us to take back control of our money, borders, laws and waters. It enables us to strike trade deals around world, to benefit of agri-food businesses across the UK”... stresses agrifood benefit from new trade deals and support
Helpful thread from my colleague with some of the evidence from exporters that contributed to this report:
NEW: Fishing groups decry failure to strike 2021 deal with Norway as a “disgrace” & “disaster”. UK Fisheries group say Government was “unable even to maintain the rights we have had to fish in Norwegian waters for decades”.
Say Norway will continue to export cod here tariff free
Defra confirms:
“We put forward a fair offer on access to UK waters and the exchange of fishing quotas, but we have concluded that our positions remain too far apart to reach an agreement this year.”
Operator of the UK’s biggest fishing vessel, currently in dock in Hull, suggests it may have done its last catch, and that all cod will have to be imported now, after failure to secure deals (apart from Svalbard) in waters fished routinely last year
Subpostmasters have their names cleared at High Court after incredible and awful Horizon IT scandal... bbc.co.uk/news/business-…
Hits home this one - my Dad was a subpostmaster, was pressurised enough with all risk piled on to small biz owners, & PO having veto on selling up... we just swerved Horizon -
the stories of honest hard working community servants criminalised by IT incompetence are just awful.
“The request is simple, please include... supply chain finance” Bank of England release FOI correspondence with former PM Cameron, lobbying for inclusion of supply chain finance, offered by Greensill Capital, within post COVID support scheme to buy forms of commercial debt:
Greensill contacted Bank/HMT on ‘a number of occasions’.
Cameron contacted Bank on 5th and 7th March 2020.
DC/ Greensill/ Bank call on 17 March.
On 18 March Bank announced CCFF scheme, excluding supply chain finance.
V interesting story from Laura about ventilator challenge..
At the time, other manufacturers felt that in the key March 16th meeting the PM was especially keen to involve Dyson and JCB, as manufacturer-supporters of Brexit, rather than carmakers and aerospace (who succeeded)
Those manufacturers had quickly determined ventilator challenge could only be met by using existing blueprint (for an approved medical device) and told me at time they were bemused by focus on Dyson (whose plans did not proceed)...
At same time there was tension with car and planemakers who had begun to argue pandemic would require an extension to Brexit trade deal negotiations to get deep deal that protected manufacturers...
Bit of context, but some on call left with perception PM overly focussed on Dyson
On the Super League - interesting that the Government/PM says it will do everything it can to stop the proposals...
Raises the question of whether it can actually do anything.
Simpler time to act might have been when these teams were all bought up.
Ultimately private companies acting legally - cant see competition issue in banning relegation. Indeed it is UEFA trying to impose restriction on right of players to choose teams if they want to play in internationals...
So what could Govt do?
Some interesting replies in thread...
Govt could say it would immediately list ESL as “of national interest” to be offered free to air under ‘96 Broadcasting Act, thus greatly reduce TV revenues.