By linking Critical Race Theory to "Gender Ideology" and calling both an attack on "American life", Shier proves once again that transphobia is deeply intertwined with white supremacy.
Shrier frames Critical Race Theory as an attack on white people and "Gender Ideology" as an attack on (white) cis women and girls. She is horrified by the idea of children being educated about gender diversity and given freedom to decide what gender they are.
Shrier claims that "gender confused people" are prone to joining BLM or antifa movements and claims that "trans activists" and adherents of "Gender Ideology" are recruiting young people into becoming both trans and revolutionaries.
Anti-racists and anti-fascists working to overthrow white supremacy, fascism and authoritarianism and trans people working to resist and uproot transphobia and patriarchy are both cast as threats to Shrier's version of America.
Shrier distinguishes between "reasonable" transgender adults who agree with her and dangerous irrational "trans activists" who are a threat to society and "vulnerable" (white) cis women and girls. She makes it clear there's a place for trans people w/ right-wing politics.
She also recites a history of gender dysphoria and trans people that is pure transphobic mythology. As someone who's researched trans history, including the history of trans medicine, it was painful to read such blatant bullshit. Transphobes don't care about facts.
Here's a link to Shrier's article for those interested. archive.vn/eoZuk
I also highly recommend people check out the work of @gp_jls, including her fantastic book Histories of the Transgender Child, for the real history of trans children and pediatric transition and how it intersects with white supremacy and racial politics. jewishcurrents.org/the-anti-trans…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Ideological detransition/"alternative treatments for gender dysphoria" is basically an alternative health scam directed at trans & questioning people. Like other alt health scams, it preys on people's negative experiences w/ the healthcare system, in this case trans healthcare.
A lot of people have horrible, sometimes traumatic experiences with more mainstream healthcare and then turn to alternatives looking for better treatment. Problem is a lot of those alternatives are grifts or culty as all hell or don't have good research to back them up.
A lot of detrans people have had traumatic experiences with transition or the psychiatric system or other forms of healthcare and are looking for something more helpful. Unfortunately, the ideological detrans scene is full of transphobic theories and conversion practices.
Lots of cis people want to talk about how lesbians are supposedly being pressured to identify as trans and transition but I've found the reverse to be true. Transphobic lesbians pressure transmasculine people to identify and live as lesbians and forgo medical transition
I've encountered way more pressure from TERFy lesbians to live as a lesbian than I've ever encountered pressure from trans people to call myself trans and transition. Hell, lots of trans people I met judged me for being too genderqueer or too masc or whatever.
Transphobic lesbians do whatever they can to discourage transmasculine peope from coming out, including valorizing the idea of the "dysphoric butch lesbian", "bravely" denying the impulse to identify as trans or transition. It's just a way to glorify internalized transphobia.
I just found an article by an ROGD mother who referred to herself and other with similar views as being "trans-realists". Do these people not know what they sounds like? I guess I shouldn't be surprised since many ROGD parents are fans of Quillette and "anti-woke" bullshit.
If you want people to think that you're not a bunch of bigots maybe don't use language that sounds like "race realism", the kind of bullshit white supremacists use to try to hide their racism behind pseudo-science.
The author also mentions trying to help two detrans men find legal assistance so they can file lawsuits and says that more lawsuits by detrans people are coming. They're going to try to pull some Keira Bell shit in this country.
Taking t signficantly reduced my dysphoria and made me feel more comfortable with my body. I couldn’t say this when I was detransitioned. I couldn’t be honest because I was supposed to be discouraging people from transitioning and promoting “alternative treatments” instead.
When people asked me how I overcame my dysphoria, I couldn’t tell them that taking t for four years and then stopping once I’d gotten the changes I wanted had helped me feel more at peace with myself and less disconnected from my body.
I always said I felt more at peace with my body because I had worked through trauma or internalized misogyny and maybe that helped too but I didn't say that until after I became a radical feminist. Before that I acknowledged that taking testosterone had helped a lot.
Something else left out of many media detrans stories is that many detrans people still deal with dysphoria after detransitioning and rely on "alternative treatments" to cope. Most detrans women I knew were struggling with some degree of dysphoria.
It's not like most people in the detrans women's community detransition and are then are totally comfortable living as women. There are plenty of detrans women working hard to "accept that they're female" because that's what they think they need to do to be happy.
A lot of detrans women struggle with gender dysphoria but are convinced that they can't find happiness transitioning or living as a trans person. They live as women because they think their dysphoria is rooted in internalized misogyny or trauma.
I recognize that gender dysphoria can manifest in many different ways and different people are going to find that different treatments work best for them but I in no way support "alternative treatments for gender dysphoria" that are really conversion therapy/practices.
Not everyone needs to medically transition but often "alternatives to transition" is just a euphemism for conversion practices. There's nothing healthy or feminist about suppressing who you are or denying yourself something that could make you happier.
Accepting one's body without modification is not inherently good or superior to transitioning. Transitioning isn't selling out, betraying women/lesbians, indulging mental illness or whatever. How many people would go for "alternatives" if transition wasn't stigmatized?