Chris Cook Profile picture
1 May, 17 tweets, 24 min read
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord 1/n I was a Director of International Petroleum Exchange then (I oversaw IPE Gas Oil contract deliverable ARA) with10 yrs DTI experience as a forensic accountant in insolvency & corporate law (fraud investigation) & regulation at AFBD (one of 5 initial UK regulators) @seatradelaw
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord @seatradelaw 2/n IPE developed the first Windows-based trading system & this began my 25 years interest in the area where law, accounting & ICT converge...we didn't call it Fintech then! In 1998 I raised £250k to develop NewClear, which is a generic, globally valid shared transaction registry
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord @seatradelaw 3/n Three elements: bilateral messaging/ trade matching; market database schema & globally valid market user agreement/club rules which provided that once the transaction had been registered in unique time order ie no need for blockchain, it was legally binding on participants
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord @seatradelaw 4/n I specified the agreement in terms of legal design & David McFarlane of Pinsent Curtis and I refined it into a robust agreement in the first #OilClear instance. Everybody wanted to own it, but if the sell-side owned it the buy-side would not use it & vice versa.
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord @seatradelaw 5/n The Internet Paradox: if fintech is neutral, it's not liquid and if it's liquid it's not neutral. Proprietary 'for profit' ownership is of course not neutral - IPE was still a members club when I left in 1996. I also failed to interest Platts (not their greatest decision)
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord @seatradelaw 6/n In 2001, I blew the whistle on IPE market manipulation & lost everything I had & essentially rebuilt my life from the ground up. Meanwhile ICE acquired IPE & launched eConfirm & CME subsequently launched TradeHub - both appropriating the NewClear trade capture concept.
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord @seatradelaw 7/n My essay on an archive site summarises my conclusions then opencapital.net/markets.htm My 10 yr fintech action research @ISRS_UCL is legal design of globally valid institutions/instruments ("contrats de société") as distinct from "Anglo" statutory/judge made "contrats de mandat"
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord @seatradelaw @ISRS_UCL 8/n In 2013 in a submission to @scotgov (abortive) land reform review blogs.ucl.ac.uk/resilience/201… I coined the term #Nondominium to describe a collaborative framework for the Property relationship
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord @seatradelaw @ISRS_UCL @scotgov 9/n The institutional legal design innovation is: 1/Deconstruct fiduciary/agency relationship into: (passive) custodian, with veto rights; (active) manager/steward subject to joint oversight of users & investors with the outcome that no single stakeholder can impose on any other
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord @seatradelaw @ISRS_UCL @scotgov 10/n The legal design (re) novation is the financial instrument which I have come to define as a credit obligation ie an (undated) assignable accepted promise/IOU, returnable in payment for supply of goods & services by the issuing promissor.
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord @seatradelaw @ISRS_UCL @scotgov 11/n The key point is this is not a 'hard' obligation enforceable by rule of law and which may be commoditised & exchanged ie @iang_fc Ricardian Contract : it is a 'soft' voluntary agreement as a relationship where the disciplines are transparency & self-exclusion from "clubs".
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord @seatradelaw @ISRS_UCL @scotgov 12/n Here the pragmatic platform/service provider architecture of the Protection & Indemnity (P&I) club mutual assurance of shipping risks Lloyds will not take is instructive. Mutual 'clearing union' assurance of distributed performance & credit risk is the solution here
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord @seatradelaw @ISRS_UCL @scotgov 13/n Having written this essay blog.p2pfoundation.net/fintech-2-0/20… I realised two years ago that the collective corporate 'legal person' (public/private/third sector) may be transcended by mutual risk, cost, surplus, asset/data use agreements.
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord @seatradelaw @ISRS_UCL @scotgov 14/n Post-Covid, complementary 'mutual aid' solutions are emerging. My lecture to the 2020 @UniStrathclyde Fintech Masters cohort posits a #BacktotheFuture distributed architecture of 21st C Treasuries, Mints & Exchequers. To be found here nondominium.co.uk/2021/01/11/pro…
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord @seatradelaw @ISRS_UCL @scotgov @UniStrathclyde 15/n In summary, digitisation of intermediated global commerce & finance founders on the underlying metaphysical point that value is definable only in relative terms & absolute binary/digital property rights can only be approximated/hacked by judges in whatever jurisdiction
@craigaatkinson @iang_fc @CommonAccord @seatradelaw @ISRS_UCL @scotgov @UniStrathclyde 16/n In particular, there are lacunae wherever instruments of indefinite duration are involved eg l/c's, bank issued credit obligations and so on. Our entire financial system is founded on myths eg the Myth of Debt blogs.ucl.ac.uk/resilience/201…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Chris Cook

Chris Cook Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @cjenscook

14 Mar
@BobMurphyEcon @Coach_JIB @intangiblecoins @WilliamJLuther 1/n While a currency may have a USD exchange rate it does not have a $ 'market cap'. Bitcoin displays the monetary scarcity/liquidity paradox obscured by gold's residual utility: to the extent a currency is scarce it is not liquid & to the extent it is liquid it is not scarce.
@BobMurphyEcon @Coach_JIB @intangiblecoins @WilliamJLuther 2/n In my analysis, at the heart of the monetary relationship is the credit obligation (promise). This is not an exchangeable object, but an assignable (IOU) relationship between subject & object returnable in exchange for useful goods & services to be provided by the promissor
@BobMurphyEcon @Coach_JIB @intangiblecoins @WilliamJLuther 3/n Personal promises may be settled by currency (generally acceptable credit obligations) or by circular clearing mdpi.com/1911-8074/13/1… Promises have come to be guaranteed by intermediary private & public banks & treasuries.
Read 7 tweets
7 Mar
@Big_Orrin 1/n This is interesting 'Oil war' bollocks hid the reality of a Covid demand shock blowing through a Saudi-funded WTI peg. So Saudi pumped like mad & sent a fleet to deliver into the May 2020 WTI delivery window. Why? The reason is USO oil fund
@Big_Orrin 2/n Both @petromatrix & @izakaminska documented strange 'bloat' of USO (in 2009) when Supercontango bizarrely combined with a rising market. They both remarked on a similar bloat in 2015 (I think) & Izzy wrote some great stuff on #DarkInventory @FTAlphaville
@Big_Orrin @petromatrix @izakaminska @FTAlphaville 3/n Now, a $2bn USO pool of physical crude oil which required only 30m bbl at $70/bbl required 80m bbl at $25/bbl. Hence Saudi panic pumping & wave of oil to the Gulf during the May 2020 window. This informs the barking mad April 20 May WTI 2020 expiry
Read 17 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!