There's a famous Hemingway quote describing going bankrupt two ways: "Gradually, then suddenly."
I think that's what's been happening with trust and goodwill with BC public health officers and yesterday was the suddenly.… @CTVVancouver #bcpoli
Someone leaked these reports to the @VancouverSun. Yet the dep PHO tried to spin the idea it wasn't a leak despite the fact CDC didn't publish them and several pages clearly say “For authorized internal public health use only –not for public distribution."…
Gustafson & Henry claimed these were working docs (that didn't say 'draft' or 'V.1') and they're fine with info being public. Henry tried to downplay, insisting most info already public.
Not true. That level of detail has systematically been kept from the public for 14 months.
The biggest shock was when Dr. Henry delivered this whopper: “We are releasing what other provinces are releasing - more than what other provinces are releasing."
That is demonstrably untrue with links and evidence here:…
In the next breath, both Henry and Gustafson explained the reason we're not getting as much info as other cities is because we have a poor data collection system and they're working on giving us more info, like in Toronto.

So are we the best in the country or playing catchup?
Gustafson: “One of the things we really aim for is provincial-level data”
Henry: "There’s a process that it goes through before it’s meaningful"
When they can filter it.
They don't want the public/experts/journos scrutinizing and @katiederosayyj shows why:…
I used to love watching the People's Court with Judge Marilyn Milian and remember her snapping at someone, "don't piss on my leg and tell me it's raining."
She flashed into my head as I was listening to the explanations from public health officials yesterday.
The gradual erosion of trust examples: resistance to mask rules, refusal to acknowledge schools as a source of transmission, blindsiding restaurants on New Year's Eve and the stubbornness to acknowledge how significant airborne transmission is.…
Where does this leave us?
@sangherabaldev is urging a data reset, with a new era of transparency, which BIPOC advocates have been asking for.
@CarolineColijn points out the data is about you and me, and public health are just stewards of that info.…
Gustafson said the "goal" is more info in the coming weeks, Henry says they've been working on an interactive website (which other cities had months ago). When I asked if they would commit to the SAME level of detail as in the leaked reports Gustafson emphatically said "Yes."
Then there's this guy, who thinks pointing all this out means I'm trash. Face with raised eyebrow
Anyhow, have a good day, y'all, and get vaccinated when you can!

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Penny Daflos

Penny Daflos Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @PennyDaflos

7 May
The BCCDC acknowledged airborne transmission of COVID-19 this week but the province isn’t changing its messaging or recos: “We have always said, there is a continuum of droplets.”
A UBC air quality expert says msg/recos have to evolve. @CTVVancouver 1/5…
Michael Braur says ventilation is key and we should add open doors and windows to our layers of protection whenever indoors with people we don’t live with.
Simple and effective — while keeping our distance.
Much harder to do at workplaces, where air filtration is important. 2/5
@TeriMooring points out many school windows don’t open and teachers/parents have resorted to buying HEPA air filters for classrooms on their own since the province still hasn’t provided them despite committing to do so. 3/5
Read 5 tweets
7 May
This is a huge scoop by @njgriffiths and deeply concerning.
In other provinces, a lot of this kind of information is easily available online.
BC has a significant transparency problem, in addition to ongoing communication and messaging issues.
The fact @CDCofBC hasn't responded isn't a surprise: their comms are overseen by @PHSAofBC and they avoid responding whenever possible -- the same PHSA that didn't let me speak to the acting CEO or board chair to discuss this story.…
Read 4 tweets
21 Apr
Healthcare workers keep telling me BC hospitals are in worse shape than govt COVID stats suggest, even though we saw a new record today.
Assmts on the floor, beds in halls, but @VCHhealthcare isn’t opening the field hospital at Convention Centre. More: ⬇️…
The many precautions in this piece are still in effect…
Remember, hospital doctors have been raising the alarm for weeks…
Read 6 tweets
9 Apr
Seeing some inconsistencies in government messaging around testing in BC right now. @Fraserhealth just issued a bulletin urging those with even mild symptoms to go straight for a test, and “Fraser Health has testing capacity.”
Their website supports this.…
What happens when you go to the provincial self assessment tool? It tells you to stay home and call 811 with mild to moderate shortness of breath. You need to select at least 2 symptoms from the subsequent list for direction to a test.
The @CDCofBC website has this handy chart with the latest guidance, which is in line with the Thrive screening geared at the most serious symptoms, unless you have more than one. Shouldn’t we test with any of these symptoms? We have the capacity to do a lot more tests.
Read 9 tweets
8 Apr
MORE: From now on, Dr. Henry says they'll assume anyone who's tested positive for COVID has a variant because they've become so common.
The strategy now will essentially be spot-testing to see which variants are becoming dominant and may cause re-infection and/or escape vaccines.
This is good background on this issue of percentages, which are much likely higher than officials are revealing.…
This is scary: BC is now seeing entire families in hospital, with parents in ICU and their adult kids in COVID wards.

Some hospital ICUs are overflowing. My heart goes out to healthcare workers on the front lines.
And yet, no new widespread restrictions.…
Read 4 tweets
7 Apr
When Dr. Henry said ON is about a month ahead of BC in terms of variants, I asked her whether we should be proactive and take the similar measures now rather than wait a month -- especially given concerns doctors are raising about overflowing ICUs ⬇️…
I also pointed out she seemed to be minimizing the presence and impact of variants here, but she insisted they're treating each case as if it's a variant & responding aggressively.
A few things to unpack. Let's start w testing, which is consistent low despite more cases: ImageImageImage
DBH said contact tracing continues and providing help to isolate from family/roommates also being done, which is great. But is that a response commensurate with the surge we've seen, which is being driven by variants? She insists they're doing that "as aggressively as we can".
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!