This doesn’t mean they’re not an important construct. It means that we shouldn’t confuse Torah and Mitzvos with denominational affiliation.
A currency analogy:
A bill represents a value. But it is not the value itself. And there are many things it cannot account for. A good approximation? Usually. Easier than carrying a cow to the market? You betcha.
But don’t confuse representations of value with the value itself.
Many are rightfully pointing out some of the very limitations of this idea. People from *all* denominations seem to agree on that much at least.
As I think about it more, I think they’re correct and I didn’t express this well here.
I once wrote about the denominational unity I find so nourishing on twitter.
1. Our sisters are bff's from high school 2. He was the assistant rabbi in my shul prior to BKNW 3. His mom designed my parent's home 4. He introduced me to the study of Jewish history 5. He gave me a 68 in Navi his first year teaching 😢
There's a real lesson from #4.
On thursday nights we had mishmar. School ended later. RAL was a young teacher--first year on the job. He was taking over mishmar. Not a teacher's dream. But he gave it 100%. He retold Dr. Shnayer Leiman on the Emden Eibeschitz controversy.