When I left an abusive relationship I told people he raped me, he hit me, he psychologically and financially abused me, while he told people that it's actually quite complicated. In my experience that's generally the case when one side defends abuses with "it's complicated".
You see it over and over again, the party that's obviously in the wrong trying to make their abuses look complicated when they are quite simple. You see it with Israeli abuses of the Palestinians, you saw it when John Bolton defends the Iraq invasion:
"It's complicated." No, usually it's quite simple, especially when the accused abuser is in the up-power position.
"You don't get to drop an entire colony on top of an inhabited country, grind those inhabitants into the dirt for generations, and then claim self defense every time they retaliate. That's not a thing." caitlinjohnstone.substack.com/p/fifteen-thou…
The US-centralized power alliance in general is a gargantuan globe-spanning juggernaut that feeds on rivers of human blood and every time its victims try to escape from its fangs it shows up on the news sobbing that it is merely defending itself.
I'm building a new house. There were people living where I wanted to build it, so I just started building it on top of them. They tried to stop me so I had to kill them for being terrorists. If you disagree with my actions you're basically a Nazi. My house has a right to exist.
The Israel Narrative Is Crumbling Because Of Phone Cameras And The Internet
There are only so many viral videos of unconscionable acts that can be dismissed with "Actually this is way more complicated than it looks." caitlinjohnstone.substack.com/p/the-israel-n…
"Twenty-four people, including nine children, were killed in Gaza overnight, most of them in Israeli strikes," reads a new report from AP. apnews.com/article/middle…
Nine children, killed with the help of United States funding to the tune of $3.8 billion a year.
Israel is losing control of the narrative because there are only so many viral videos of unconscionable brutality that can be dismissed with "Actually this is way more complicated than it looks."
A big part of the difficulty in controlling the narrative is that Israeli apartheid isn't something that's being managed by a few elites, it's got rank-and-file people upholding it who don't know it's bad narrative management to do shit like this on camera
Back when plutocratic media outlets had the narratives locked down, they could ensure everyone was only seeing what the empire wants seen. Smartphone cameras and the internet shattered this paradigm. @Jonathan_K_Cook shared his ideas on this recently here: jonathan-cook.net/blog/2021-05-1…
"Moving the Democratic Party to the left via primaries and electoral engagement is the easiest way to advance progressive change."
Sure it's easy. So is praying for progressive change, or wishing upon a star for it. Just because something is easy doesn't mean it's real.
It's like that old joke where a drunk guy is looking for his keys under a streetlight at night and a cop sees him and helps him look.
"You sure this is where you lost them?" the cop asks after a while.
"No I lost them down the road, but this is where the light is."
Or that scene from The Land Before Time where one dinosaur knows where to go but the road is hard, and the other dinosaur is like "This way's too hard, I'm going an easier way" but it's the opposite direction from where they need to be.
It's the way that term is now used. I've got nothing to do with Stalinism; I'm not even a Marxist. My opposition to imperialist agendas against Russia and China have nothing to do with communism whatsoever. Yet I get called a tankie every day.
This is how propaganda occurs in the west. It's not that Jeff Bezos emails WaPo employees saying "Promote US wars!", it's that only reporters who protect imperialism see their careers rise. "If you believed something else, you wouldn't be sitting here."
This is why you see blue-checkmarked reporters tweeting in service of imperialist narratives and smearing leftists and anti-imperialists. They're not (usually) being paid to tweet that stuff; they're promoting their career by signalling that they'll protect the establishment.