Yesterday's House Oversight hearing on the insurrection was significant in the way it demonstrated that the Republican Party is fully in the grip of the antidemocratic/ authoritarian/counterfactual insanity of Trumpism after Jan. 6. A video thread of the clown parade. 1/
The most obvious gaslighter was Rep. Andrew Clyde of Georgia: "Let’s be honest with the American people: It was not an insurrection, and we cannot call it that and be truthful." Followed by two definitions of "insurrection" that match the events of Jan. 6 perfectly. /2
Clyde later said: 'You know, but the only insurrection I’ve witnessed in my lifetime was the one conducted by the FBI with participants from the DOJ and other agencies under the banner “Russia Russia Russia.”' Which, regardless how you felt, was nothing like an insurrection./3
Then there was Ralph Norman of South Carolina, who wanted to know how the media knew the insurrectionists backed Trump: "I don’t know who did the poll to say they were Trump supporters." /4
Um, well, Ralph, it was kind of hard to do polling just then. But you kind of got the idea. /5
Then there was Trump-loving Jody Hice of Georgia: 'Why don’t you talk about how the president used those words, “peacefully and patriotically,” instead of cherry-picking words that you want to use to portray an image of something that did not happen?' /6
Yvette Harrell of New Mexico clearly lives in Trump's Alt-America as well, calling reporting around the insurrection "fake news": "We’ve had so much fake news, cynical politicians, disinformation—far, far from the truth." /7
Clay Higgins of Louisiana seemed especially angry—about BLM and antifa, who may not have done an insurrection, but who he blamed for 19 deaths and 2,000 police injuries last summer: "And yet, we’re gonna discuss today, as if none of that happened, the events of January 6." /8
Arizona Rep. Paul Biggs (who in fact helped plan the Jan. 6 'Stop the Steal' event that preceded the riot) also tried to make the case that antifascist and BLM protesters had committed insurrection, and Democrats were being hypocritical about poor MAGA folk. /9
His Arizona colleague Paul Gosar (who has become the House GOP's go-to white nationalist since Steve King retired) complained bitterly that the DOJ was "harassing peaceful patriots across the country" for their roles in the insurrection. /10
Capping off the gaslight parade was James Comer of Kentucky, the committee's ranking Republican, who smugly observed at the end: 'You saw a sharp contrast between the behavior of the Republicans on the committee versus the Democrats on the committee.' Well, yes, you did. /11
The whole sad spectacle of self-degradation was a reminder that authoritarianism seems to eventually induce real cognitive short-circuiting. /12 / end
The worst aspect of this lede (and frankly, the rest of this piece) is how it utterly obliviates the asymmetrical nature of the dynamic that created this kind of 'sectarianism.' nytimes.com/2021/04/19/us/…
Democrats have only recently--mostly since Jan. 6--come to understand that the Republican Party is hostile not just to their party but to democracy itself, and that their worldviews are so irreconcilable that rapprochement or compromise really is nowhere in view.
Barack Obama spent the better part of his tenure reaching out to the other side and receiving back a bloody stump, literally on every issue: economic recovery, health care, immigration, gun safety. You name it, he tried hard to compromise.
Tucker Carlson trotted out this argument earlier this week to illustrate his “replacement theory” regarding immigrants and voting. It’s actually a perfect illustration of the up-is-down gaslighting of the theory. A thread. 1/
Carlson made this argument on Monday when he was doubling down on his claim that Democrats want nonwhite immigration in order to increase their power—an open embrace of white-nationalist dogma./ 2
Of course, we are familiar with Greenwald claiming there is “no evidence” of any connections to acts of violence and that claiming otherwise is merely “guilt by association.”
If it makes any difference, my paternal grandfather was a Ford mechanic in Twin Falls, Idaho, and my maternal grandfather ran a road-construction company also based in Twin. Here’s a pic of the latter out fly fishing, which was the closest thing to religion we had.
So yes, Mr. Beattie will be hearing from my attorney early this coming week.
For the nonce, let me post this officially, @DarrenJBeattie: I demand both a retraction and an apology.
I’ve been watching the right-wing narrative regarding the Jan. 6 insurrection with keen interest, and realizing that the American right again intends to resort to its well-worn “waving the bloody shirt” gambit. A thread about what that will mean. /1/44
We all know the phrase and its meaning: Someone who “waves the bloody shirt” is a demagogue whose rhetoric callously recalls violent incidents for the purpose of scoring cheap political points. /2
The phrase originated during the Reconstruction era following the Civil War. In the early years, white terrorists from armed paramilitary groups like the Ku Klux Klan roamed the Southern countryside intent on terrorizing black people and anyone assisting them. /3
Yesterday was the #DayofRemembrance—February 19, the anniversary of FDR’s signing of EO9066, which consigned over 100,000 Japanese Americans to incarceration for the duration of WWII.
I wanted to share a brief tour of a memorial to those who were its victims.
One of the more memorable photos from that episode is this one, of the first community to be “evacuated” to Manzanar, from Bainbridge Island, WA. These are the “evacuees” being loaded onto a ferry under armed guard on March 30, 1942.
You can go to the site of this tragedy today and see a memorial to the event, dedicated to those who were removed summarily from their homes on the orders of an Army general. Bainbridge is a 30-minute ferry ride from downtown Seattle. The memorial is just outside the town.