To those fueling the current media trend of attacking masks as “unnecessary virtue signaling” now that the “pandemic is over” is that:
A. the pandemic isn’t over and
B. you’re going to get people harassed and hurt, and a disproportionate number of them will be Asian
Mask wearing has always been a prosocial behavior, not a selfish one. But it’s generally hard to convince Americans to do anything that doesn’t lean into self interest, so getting them to wear masks was messaged as about protecting YOURSELF. It isn’t. qz.com/299003/a-quick…
When you wear a mask, you protect OTHERS if you happen to be infectious. And it works best when mask wearing is normalized—or at least not actively condemned—because like vaccination, it’s a herd wellness phenomenon. And yes, people mask up in Asia regularly during flu season.
That carries over to Asian Americans. So we were the first to adopt masks during Covid, we ignored it when people said it was unnecessary, we will be the last to not wear them and the first to start again if there’s an outbreak.
Which is going to make us targets. It already has.
But again: THE PANDEMIC ISN’T OVER. It’s ravaging India and S.America. New strains are emerging as a result. Only 1/3 of Americans are vaxxed. We’re already seeing high-profile “breakthrough” cases (Bill Maher) and we’ll see more as Covid explodes abroad. nytimes.com/2021/05/15/ups…
Vaccination is a herd phenomenon. We need 80% of Americans to have antibodies before we can feel truly safe. We’re not even close. And yet high-profile people are not just attacking masks but mocking those who want to maintain mask wearing.
What’s going to come next (we’ve seen it already) is widespread contempt for mask wearers. Masks will be burned in public, people will try to yank masks off strangers, or harass and abuse people seen wearing masks. As noted above: Many will be Asian.
We lose nothing by encouraging people to wear masks simply to normalize it in the culture. Sadly the people who refuse to mask are also most likely to refuse to vaxx—and the most likely to attack and harass those who do. Is this what you want to normalize instead?
You may choose to not wear a mask—that’s fine. But by deriding mask wearers and pushing for demasking even among those who prefer to keep them on, you make it harder to get people to wear them again in the future—because this isn’t the last pandemic—and put masked people at risk.
And that means me, double Pfizer, my family and most of my Asian friends. You’re aiming people’s slurs and fists at us.
Two bonus charts for anyone who thinks the pandemic is over and we should return to “normal” immediately:
82% of Democrats have gotten the vaccine and 11% intend to.
Only 43% of Republicans have gotten the vaccine.
44% say they never will.
Half the country is not normal.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Three brutal and totally random attacks against Asians in less than 48 hours in San Francisco.
At this point, one has to wonder if this is just stochastic terrorism, copycat crime or something worse.
Yes. What we’re seeing now is something like “permissioned scapegoating.”
The early wave of Covid bigotry—fueled by racist rhetoric—framed Asians as a legitimate target of opportunity. These attacks now have nothing to do with covid.
Absolutely great point on civic failure amplification. Lack of healthcare, lack of housing, lack of opportunity all directly contribute to the impulse to lash out—and, especially in a city that’s 2/3 Asian, in a time when Asians are seen as “OK to attack,” Asians are easy targets
To those who feel it’s necessary to defend Jay Baker’s “bad day” quote by saying it was just a recital of Long’s words: Baker *put them into his own mouth* by paraphrasing them. He did not read a transcript.
Doing so frames Long with empathy that nonwhite criminals rarely get.
When cops paraphrase the words and describe the actions of Black suspects and even Black VICTIMS, it’s usually in a way that makes them seem more dangerous, or complicit in their own harm at the hands of law enforcement. We have seen that time and again.
By using subjective, empathic language in interpreting Long, Baker demonstrated how he saw him and how he wanted others to see him. This is what Baker said:
"He was pretty much fed up & kind of at the end of his rope. Yesterday was a really bad day for him & this is what he did"
When people talk about Asian sex work in tones that suggest that the victims of Robert Aaron along were somehow “asking for it” because they were engaged in an illicit activity, they speak volumes about their own ignorance on why America has an Asian sex work trade to begin with.
Think centuries of exotic sexualization of “the Orient,” reinforced by white supremacism, military conquest, colonial occupation, and a long history of media amplification of racist stereotypical images
Think of the Chinese Exclusion Act and how it banned Chinese men from bringing their wives to the US to prevent them from wanting to settle here, creating a situation where the only Chinese women in the US were undocumented sex workers—with clients who weren’t just Chinese
Horrific. Robert Aaron Long, 21, has been arrested in connection with a shooting that killed four women at Young’s Asian Massage Parlor in Atlanta. More shootings took place at two other Asian spas in the area. Police have not yet tied those to Long. ajc.com/news/breaking-…
In total, at least eight are dead and others seriously injured—most or all of them immigrant Asian women. Were they targeted for their race? Their gender?
Given the way things are right now, the answer is probably “both.”