1/ Yesterday we saw forceful and vocal response from Palestinians worldwide to incidents in which people waving the Palestine flags targeted Jewish neighbourhoods in London with vile antisemitic harassment and threats.
The response below is one of many.
2/ Antisemitism in the Palestine activism scene in the West almost never comes from Palestinians, almost always comes from non-Palestinian activists. We should acknowledge the heavy burden this places on Palestinians, especially in this moment.
3/ So while they face bombing, attacks, displacement, and brutalisation in Palestine, Palestinians also now need to find the time and space to reject what some racist idiots are doing in the name of their cause.
4/ We know that the charge of Antisemitism is often levelled against Palestinians and their supporters in an unjustifiable way. There are people for whom the mere presence of the Palestine flag is antisemitic. This must be rejected.
5/ But it is also true that some Antisemites are attracted to the Palestine cause, given that half the world's Jews live in Israel, that Israel defines itself as a Jewish state. For many reasons this is much more a problem in Europe than it is in North America.
6/ And that primarily often takes the form of conflating Diaspora Jews with Israel (and attacking them on that basis), or using antisemitic language to discuss Israel, e.g. as part of a global Jewish conspiracy.
7/ For a good resource on how to identify Antisemitism in this context, please see the recently published Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism. jerusalemdeclaration.org
8/ Pro-Palestine activists must not leave this work to Palestinians. They need to educate themselves better on identifying antisemitism, call it out when they see it, not downplay it or engage in knee jerk denialism.
9/ We should recognise the uniquely vulnerable and difficult position of Palestinians here.
They struggle against occupation and colonisation by Israeli Jews, people who themselves were, not long ago, refugees fleeing racism ...
10/ While for diaspora Jews, as a racialised minority, antisemitism is not a distant memory but also a lived experience; and, for many, Israel is a positive and reassuring anchor.
I can think of no other occupied and colonised people in similar circumstances.
11/ All this means that if and when Antisemitism is not taken seriously - it harms not only diaspora Jews but also Palestinians.

And the forceful response yesterday provided a clear direction on how to take this seriously, identify and reject it.

/End

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Yair Wallach

Yair Wallach Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @YairWallach

17 May
RE that John Oliver segment. Clearly the conversation in the US is changing among liberals/progressives. But the US was also 43,000 votes away from a second Trump presidency, and while Biden has been pretty terrible on this so far, under Trump things could have been much worse.
The global hard-right ascendancy has provided the context for Israel's consolidating unequal-one-state solution. That ascendancy was blocked in the US but not globally. That has ramifications and risks for so many issues, including Israel/Palestine.
In my view - the risks in Israel/Palestine are extremely high, higher than they've been in decades. And I'm talking about mass expulsions and similar scenarios. That's what the Israeli right wing wants.
Read 4 tweets
13 May
1/ It's a grim day in Israel/Palestine and more grim days are to come. In this moment we need to find new pasts that would make different futures possible.
And we can start where it all started this time, in Arab Sheikh Jarrah and its Jewish connection.
---------
THREAD
2/ Sheikh Jarrah was a Palestinian upper class neighbourhood developed since the 1860s. It also housed the cave-tomb associated with ancient priest Shimon ha-Tsadik, Simeon the Just, a site of Jewish pilgrimage since the middle ages, purchased by the chief rabbi in 1876.
3/ The annual celebration of Simon ha-Tsadik took place in Lag ba-Omer (late April/early May). It was the largest Jewish public celebration in 19th-early 20th century Jerusalem, of Sephardim and Asheknazim, known in Arabic as "'Shathat al-yahudiyya", the festival of the Jews.
Read 11 tweets
12 May
1/ Something about narratives:
For Jewish Israelis, the images of riots from "mixed towns" resonate with the Israeli narrative of 1948, which is about inter-communal strife, siege, and a sense of existential threat. Bear with me.
2/ This narrative will shock those who are familiar with the history of the 1948 Nakba, in which 750k Palestinians were made refugees and denied return, and their land and property taken away from them.
3/ But the Israeli narrative is not a fabrication. Rather, it highlights specific moments - January to March 1948 - the early months in which there was no clear Zionist advantage, and indeed the experience was of siege, strife, and lack of clarity on the eventual outcome.
Read 5 tweets
10 May
1/ The thing about al-Aqsa/Temple Mount is that it's the most important place in Palestine/Israel, and its in Palestinian hands.
Israeli police can storm it, take the keys, lock the doors, beat up or shoot people. All this doesn't change the fact that it's in Palestinian hands.
2/ Palestinian effective sovereignty in al-Aqsa is not due to diplomatic negotiations, or international law, or armed struggle (although all these played a role in defending it).
It's about moral authority.
3/ Israeli policies in the last decade threaten the status quo by effectively allowing ritual Jewish visits to the site (although nominally banned). But Israel has not dared to take over the site, and it remains in Palestinian hands, at least for now.
Read 5 tweets
10 May
1/ Overall, Israeli Judaisation of Jerusalem have failed. 1970s policy (yes, explicit policy) was to keep Palestinians at 30% of the population in the municipal area, but today they are 40%.
There are a range of policy responses to the bi-national reality:
2/ Integration (aka "Israelisation") - in education, employment, commerce and leisure. This is happening inevitably given that the Wall disconnected East Jerusalem from the West Bank, but there are attempts to encourage it.
But there's a very clear ceiling to this policy.
3/ Israel does not want 350k East Jerusalemites to become Israeli citizens. Citizenship applications are processed slowly and half are denied. Most Palestinians do not want to become Israeli citizens but even if they did, Israel would clearly try to prevent that.
Read 12 tweets
6 Apr
1/ This is well worth a read.
I agree completely that the "trope-ification" of the antisemitism discussion ad absurdum is unhelpful and even harmful. Antisemitism is about threatening or denying rights from Jews, and this should be the focus.
2/ This appears to me unrelated to the question of how serious the threat of antisemitism is in the US. As an observer from afar, the normalisation of antisemitism in sections of the GOP appears to me a very serious development.
3/ The reference to an (unlikely) "American Auschwitz" is unhelpful. Auschwitz is an anomaly in the history of antisemitism; not the norm. A more likely risk is, say, Argentina: the rise of authoritarian right wing, full of hatred to the "wrong Jews".
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(