A thread on Savarna standup comics and their supposed 'jokes'.

The debate around the casteist 'jokes' or tweets of Savarna standup comics has deliberately been reduced to arguing if one should 'forgive' them for something they did long ago or not.
I just want to say a few things in this regard.

The English standup comic scene in India is an elite space that is entirely monopolized by the Brahmin-Savarnas. That includes both the comics and the audience.
Which is why when Neville Shah made those casteist 'jokes', he wasn't rebuked by the audience. Instead, they lovingly lapped it up. So it is not true that Neville Shah cracked those 'jokes' because his mom died or something.
He cracked them simply because it worked with his audience. He was able to prove his 'sense of humour' by being casteist.

This is what most comics did until the mid 2010s or so.
They cracked 'jokes' on reservation, drivers, domestic helps, security guards, Mayawati and the sort, because it worked for both themselves and their audience. And it wasn't just Savarna male comics but Savarna female comics too.
In fact, you would be astonished to find the number of times someone like Sumikhi Suresh caricatured domestic helps in her stand-up shows and sketches.
But then, why won't they do it when they can make money, build careers and create a brand around themselves by simply being their usual casteist self. It was a totally win-win situation until then.
However, since the mid 2010s, there has been increased political conversation around caste on social media, particularly by Bahujans and it had made it difficult for these comics to continue being casteist.
To sustain their careers and build their brand value, it became important for them to project themselves differently in the new woke climate. So they all conveniently became overnight radicals.
If you think about it, someone like Varun Grover was able to become a comic only because he is a Savarna. (Trust me! Talent or the absence of it has little do with anyone becoming a comic) When mocking Mayawati was what the Savarna market wanted, he gave it to them.
When the market suddenly become woke, he had to beat the market by becoming more woke than it. And so he officially became a radical.

Essentially, these Savarna comics were able to socially and economically benefit by being both casteist and later being super woke radicals.
How privileged should they be to play it both ways and still benefit.

The Chennai stand up comic scene might be slightly different to the Bangalore, Mumabi or Delhi ones. Here, the comics may not be making direct 'jokes' on reservation or Mayawati.
But SA Aravind, Karthik Kumar and the lot continue to play a huge role in reinforcing positive stereotypes around Brahmins and playing to the Tamil Brahmin market in India and overseas.
But as you can see, the English standup comic space in all these cities continues to be an extremely elite space whose gates are opened primarily for Brahmins and other Savarnas.
Since the social media uproar, several Brahmin-Savarnas have come out to defend these comics and claim how people can change with time and stuff. Yes, people can of course change.
But does that take away the damage they have done to the most vulnerable and oppressed sections of the society. And worse, these apology letters are not even printed on paper. So one can't even wipe their asses with it.
However, the amusing phenomenon is that, some Dalits and other Bahujans too have come out to give their clean chit to these casteist comics because they are supposedly 'ex-casteist comics'.
I don't understand why Bahujans should pressurize themselves to perform this forgiving act. Probably some of these comics are your partners, friends, workmates or even acquaintances. So maybe you want to give them a shoulder to cry. Which is fine.
Or maybe you want to buy them a drink, which is fine too. Or give them a bear hug. Which is absolutely fine as well. But to abuse a political identity and give out clean chits reeks of extreme irresponsibility.
Because that would be trying to erase the damage that these privileged brats have committed.

There is absolutely no need for Bahujans play the role of Jesus Christ and generously give out 'I forgive you' or 'This person has changed' certificates.
If anything, it is the headache of these Savarna comics to find ways to restore their credibility. Let them figure it out for themselves.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Rajesh Rajamani

Rajesh Rajamani Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @rajamanirajesh

22 May
One thread on sir-ing and anna-ing people.

There is this strange and amusing phenomenon I have noticed in the Tamil film industry networks. And in fact, this is true for the Tamil political circles as well.
Whenever you meet someone who is even slightly younger to you (or sometimes even older than you), they always begin addressing you profusely as 'anna' or 'sir'.
But because I have been uncomfortable with both these terms, I often tell them that they could just call me by my first name. They initially hesitate to do that. But after repeated nudging, they agree to address you by your first name.
Read 11 tweets
22 Apr
A thread on 'Geeli Pucchi'!

One thing that struck me about Neeraj Ghaywan's short 'Geeli Pucchi' from the Netflix anthology 'Ajeeb Daastaan' is that it is probably one of those rare films that problematizes the role of the Brahmin woman in the caste structure.
The last decade might have seen several films that engage with the subject of caste from an anti-caste perspective. But most of these films locate their central conflict between an OBC and SC caste.
And whenever some Brahmin-Savarna filmmaker is involved, a Brahmin savior character is also thrown into the mix.
Read 22 tweets
20 Apr
One thing I realized during my three weeks long covid quarantine is that Hollywood popular cinema can make for a great watch during this period. When the quarantine started, I was being a little too ambitious and started with Krzysztof Kieslowski's 'Deklog'.
But very soon, I realized that even if one's symptoms are only mild, watching serious cinema can be very exhausting and draining.

So I quickly abandoned all sorts of serious films that demanded a lot of emotional or mental investment and went with simple Hollywood classics.
And I must say they made my quarantine quite enjoyable.

I started with Steven Spielberg's 'Catch Me If You Can' (2002). The film had the right amount of thrills and also felt like a fuzzy Christmas movie at the same time.
Read 14 tweets
19 Apr
In August 2012, Outlook magazine came up with an issue that supposedly did some survey and found that Dr. Ambedkar is the greatest Indian after Gandhi. If I remember it right, that particular issue was put together by S Anand.
The cover story was written by Vinod Mehta and some of the other stories were written by Uttam Sengupta, Sudheendra Kulkarni and S Anand himself. There were also pieces by Gail Omvedt and Anand Teltumde.

The issue was a super hit among Dalits and other Bahujans.
Though there was some discomfort in leaving Gandhi out of the race, everyone still went berserk praising the issue and probably bought the magazine in large numbers too.
Read 12 tweets
16 Apr
A short note on 'Karnan'

I think there were exactly two or at best three points in 'Karnan' that put me off. But when I looked beyond some of those cinematic compromises, I think I loved 'Karnan'.
What an arousing and moving film on the human spirit and the extent it is willing to go to fight for its dignity.

'Karnan' is a story of a community's resistance.
That would fiercely guard its dignity and is willing to confront even the mighty power of caste structure and state machinery. It is unfortunate that some people intend to interpret the story of a community's resistance into a superhero's battle.
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(