I find it funny that the direct response and tracking complex can’t understand why a brand like Apple runs privacy image ads. Can’t fathom a brand creating desire and demand around attributes of a fundamental human right they’ve embraced while Facebook and Google have abused.
Watch trust in the Apple brand go up further at a fine of great vulnerability. This isn’t about winning or losing on being able to roll out a feature or even driving phone sales. It’s brand reinforcing for products that sell at prices considerably above their competition.
And in winning there, it also gives Apple a clear differentiator as more and more devices are connected to our lives. Heck it could be more about selling Apple cars in the coming years than anything the tracking complex keeps focusing on.
Many in media understand this. Many in tech don’t. There is a reason Facebook is buying full page ads in NYTimes, Apple buys expensive tv ads, et al. In fact, I’ll take it a step further….
These ads are economic signals to the public of their values and even their ability to spend $ on making the statement. They can afford to spend millions on these ads even when “they’ve already won” and that in itself is a signal to the market. Wrap your head around that.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Deeply concerning. To be clear, the report is that the Ryan Air flight headed from Greece to Lithuania was forced to land in Belarus by the government - in order to arrest a journalist who exposed and opposed them - under false pretense of a bomb threat.
Outstanding news from yesterday. Google failed to move the critically important advertising antitrust case out of Texas. This is the one where they botched a filing and we learned more about allegations of collusion with Facebook. Grateful East coast witnesses can go to Texas.
It also speeds it up so the trial can start next year rather than 2023. There are real-time market harms happening including Google’s attempt to design the market mechanics for the future. This coincides with major UK announcement Tuesday (note Texas case and UK are aligned).
Here is something from last night on UK announcement for those interested. I’ll also paste my notes on the Texas lawsuit. Counter to Axios bit this morning, FB/G reckoning is moving along. ps @scottros you left off FB sued by nearly all states plus massive EU loss this week.
ok, finally read the full announcement from UK yesterday. It's a BFD. Another major nation integrating thinking on competition and data policy. This adds to the German Cartel Office decision vs Facebook, state AGs and federal antitrust suits, US Congress and other parliaments. /1
"self-reinforcing" and "insurmountable without regulatory intervention"... /2
"We do not agree" that competition law and data protection are in opposition. /3
incoming. “Tracking prevention” is here in a big way. eg: Apple’s iOS 14.5 is kneecapping Facebook’s core profit model of mining our data while we use apps that Facebook doesn’t even own - aka “tracking.” 94% of users are saying NFW to prompts. /1
Conventional wisdom is tracking prevention helps Google and Facebook as they have a ton of data from owned apps (Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp, Search, Gmail, Maps) but that’s wrong. Regulators have shown most of their data comes from acting as third parties - aka “Tracking.” /2
Facebook, Google, and the most powerful lobbies in the tech media industry have spent more than a decade propping up narratives to defend their most important members' "surveillance economics." But they’ve lost enormous credibility everywhere in the past few years. /3
prob not a secret but my fav topic. It's why we launched DCN and all its principles around trust in 2014 - brands are proxies for trust. "You know what you're going to get!" NBC's brands ooze trust for news and entertainment with both viewers and advertisers. /1 #WhyTrustMatters
Trust by definition means a dependable, reliable value exchange built off relationships, experiences together, and even other trusted relationships brought to the table… and yes it does involve transparency when there is a gap. #WhyTrustMatters /2
for consumers, it makes life simpler because they know what they're going to get from that brand whether a consumer product, auto brand, a service or from a news or entertainment company, channel, series, etc. #WhyTrustMatters
If you work in advertising, adtech, media, or loathe Facebook, Inc, today’s NYT Daily is amazingly strong. Isaac does a remarkable job at peeling back the real motivations and importantly business impact of data protection to Facebook’s core biz model. /1 podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the…
My opinion is Mike Isaac prob was able to cut through the noise (FB needs to spin and fight this without showing its soft underbelly) because of years of covering the company plus digging deeper on back story which he did in this outstanding report. /2
In backstory, I just connected dots Apple-FB’s Davos showdown was Jan 2019 immediately ahead of Germany decision vs Facebook. Little doubt that Cook telling Zuckerberg he should purge all data collected outside of FB apps also played a role in FB rushed announcement. /3