Mani Shankar Aiyer has just begun a room on clubhouse to discuss how Rajiv Gandhi built digital India. Please join and record for use in 2024. Pretty sure he will end up insulting all kinds of people
Sam Pitroda has also joined. He is speaking very slowly. As if every word is being first approved by 10 JP first
Jai ram Ramesh has now joined. Jai ram has no profile picture. Is he losing his famous hair?
Everyone speaking so slowly as if they learnt speaking English on Duo Lingo during COVID months
Technical difficulties have cut off Sam Pitroda. He was in the middle of explaining how he brought about a technical revolution
The other Congress speakers are struggling to figure out how to use Clubhouse. Awkward silence all around. To remind everyone who have just joined the thread, the topic is Digital India.
All Cong speakers on mute. The poor moderator is begging them to unmute themselves
Someone needs to remind the speakers that this isn't a CWC session. They can speak here.
Wajahat Habibullah has entered the chat and made a bold claim. Even beggars are using cell phones thanks to Sam Pitroda.
Wajahat Habs has the accent of someone who has watched too many silent movies and has decided to just guess how a foreign accent may sound like
Waj Habs has been speaking for 16 hours I think - yet to make a point.
Just checked google and my suspicions were proved right. He is an ex-bureaucrat
Congratulations - Jairam Ramesh has FINALLY been able to unmute himself!
Now lets listen to what he has to say about how he made India digitally savvy.
JR makes a solid traditional start - begins by crediting Nehru
Motilal always gets ignored - no idea why.
JR used a word 'obscurantist'
For those listeners taking a vodka shot everytime the words "Nehruvian legacy" is said, please admit yourself to the nearest hospital
Mani Shanker Aiyyar has STILL not been able to unmute himself. Biggest blow to Modi's hopes in 2024
Modi's luck shines through yet again. MSA has finally figured out the unmute button. Starts with a good joke
"Took me a lot of trouble to get in. Not sure if I can now log out"
Aiyer proves he is a legend in 30 seconds. The topic is Digital India. He starts with Shah Bano case
Pretty sure the moderator is deeply missing the time when Mani was on mute.
At this point Congress digital team needs to call for an emergency meeting to discuss who goes to Aiyer and tells him the topic for discussion today
Aiyer is coughing a lot. I hope he is doing OK. We desperately need him for 2024
Aiyer is talking about the legal implications during the chastity period of a recently divorced Muslim woman - the most niche topic in Digital India ever imagined.
After Shah Bano, Aiyer has now moved to Bofors
Iss Clubhouse room ke piche RSS ka haath hai
Mani sir has stopped speaking finally. The moderator sounds more relieved than a goat on the day after Eid.
The moderator just let it slip that there was a rehearsal. Followed by the speaker not being audible for the next 2 mins.
Till now, every speaker has struggled to speak. The topic, as everyone knows by now, is Digital India.
Apparently Rajiv asked his team to use his charm around the world to open doors to technology transfer.
Sounds a bit shady tbh.....
Rajiv's strengths listed
Warm
Humble
Could understand jokes
Remarkably similar to how we usually describe the most boring people in the world
THEY ARE OPENING UPTO AUDIENCE QUESTIONS
Moderator makes a breath-taking claim - today's Clubhouse session is happening because Rajiv dreamt about it decades ago
Maybe he should have slept even more.
Jairam celebrating the outstanding success of the polio vaccine program
It took India only 50 years to implement it. Hardly a long time if we see it in context of our 6000yr history
Jairam said they built national consensus over many many months and years to get the strategy for polio vaccine right. And this was not done for Covid which has proved disastrous
So it appears the Congress accusation against the Modi Govt is it moved too fast?
Sam says we have got to build a functioning democracy. Then says we can't have 5000 trolls who jump at you for saying something
Jairam says India needs a "HUGE RESET"
We may be minutes away from him wistfully mentioning the need for a Final Solution.
Jairam says it may take more than a few months to finish COVID vaccinations.
2 mins ago they celebrated polio vaccination which took 5 decades.
"Neutral activist" and ex-IAS Kannan Gopinathan is speaking now
Starts off telling a story of how Rajiv used to travel in an open jeep in Mizoram - so much more exciting than those boring roads and bridges Modi is building there now.
Every speaker keeps repeating if Rajiv didn't set up the communication towers in the 1980s then this Clubhouse chat would have been IMPOSSIBLE!
Sharad Marathe spent 10 mins explaining the amazing job he did setting up India's communication infrastructure. Sadly he was barely audible and every second word got garbled because of communication problems
Tragic.
The moderator brings up the next burning topic in Digital India
Baba Ramdev
Nothing audible anymore. After every 15 seconds, we hear the word "data"
Moderator has gone rogue and completely ditched the digital india topic
Asking Waj Habs about Modi's attack on Bureaucracy. Thankfully Waj Habs accidently muted himself and is unable to reverse it.
Audience questions are fixed (rehearsal hua hai bhai, rehearsal)
Audience coming up and saying things like "You guys are so amazing, can we digitize your brilliance"
The audience member continues - "we are horribly misinformed, myself included" - after 10 mins of praising Sam Pitroda and gang for their "brilliance"
Audience member demands for an encyclopedia on what Congress has done for India
I think what she means is a pamphlet.
Sam Pitroda says Cong has a lot of achievements but they are not easily accessible. Like God?
Jairam mentioning how Modi has no tolerance for professionals like Raghuram Rajan and Viral Acharya
The phrase "monoculture ecosystem" was used
Waj Habs was asked to speak - he keeps repeating "Can you hear me" in a faint voice
I can hear you Waj. We miss you.
Waj Habs seems like a guy you would like to have a beer with. And then quietly slip out before the bill comes.
Moderator: Mr Ramesh, what do we do between now and 2024?
Ans: We need to do what we need to do. People need to read
Wise words. Good man.
Jairam leaves. Says, next time lets do this on Zoom
This man is SO on top on new media.
Folks, I need to sadly leave and get ready for my shift at KFC.
Apologies to those who were tricked into joining this room because of my thread. It was way more boring than how I tired to make it sound
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Thrilling conversation on Clubhouse right now - some disco Khalistanis from America alongside some desi Woko Haram trying very very hard to subtly justify the Hindu deaths in the Delhi riots
An American lady EXTREMELY confidently claiming BJP will lose Maharastra if elections are held today. Not sure about Bengal
A lovely lady from Tamil Nadu confidently claims - Dalits are not Hindus. Her argument slightly diluted by the 5 mins she took to pronounce Hindutva
A carefully planned long-term campaign of disinformation creates a fertile ground for justifying extreme acts of violence which otherwise would be indefensible
Since 2019, there has been a well-coordinated and consistent international effort to paint Modi as a tyrant – in 2019 the reason was Kashmir, in 2000 it was CAA and this year the farmers protest
The features of the narrative building have been remarkably similar every instance – untethered from facts, present anti-Modi operatives as neutral experts, out of context visuals and use of democratic freedoms to paralyze the host country
The popular narrative we have always been used to is that democratic societies are much stronger and resilient than autocratic ones - but how does that play out in practice?
Last year an obscure middle-manager in the NBA made some comments mildly supportive of the Hong Kong protestors - China's response to this insignificant event was worth taking note of
Mega-stars like Lebron James, who otherwise would love to ride the Woko Haram bus to glory, said people should think before talking - essentially do not piss the Chinese off as our revenue stream from that market immediately dries up
It will soon be 3 months since COVID shut down the world.
A lifetime worth of important insights can be gleaned from how countries reacted to it. Here are a few which seemed important to me
Trust in what the government says is very high in East Asia (Japan,SK,Taiwan,SGP,HK), robust in India and signs of severe decline in USA/UK
Lack of trust should be a leading indicator of political instability
Scientists and technical experts need to be trained on how to communicate difficult concepts to the mass public - especially the levels of uncertainty in their models and what that means for decision-making