El Salvador will be the first country to make Bitcoin legal tender but would not be the first country to use cryptocurrency to evade sanctions. North Korea and Venezuela have done the same, to varying degrees of success...
President Bukele’s announcement is aimed to impress tech investors, and it appears to be working. But it comes as US-ES relations are hitting nosedive due to Bukele’s authoritarianism, State Dept. naming officials to corruption lists, and Treasury likely preparing sanctions.
Notably a number of these Salvadoran officials in Bukele’s party who are likely targets for glomag sanctions are credibly accused of money laundering. These are through ties to Alba, a joint venture with Venezuela’s state oil company, and/or the Texis Cartel.
For sanctioned governments, the promise of crypto is that it would allow for them to evade the US’s SWIFT messaging system that monitors and tracks bank transactions. North Korea has used crypto to fund its nuclear program. worldpoliticsreview.com/articles/29092…
The problem for these governments is it doesn’t really work. Bitcoin transaction info is public. To have real control, governments have to create their own cryptocurrencies, as Venezuela tried to do with the Petro. No one really accepts it. NK profits from crypto by stealing it.
El Salvador is particularly dependent on the US. ES switched its currency to the dollar in 2001. 20% of its GDP come from remittances from Salvadorans in the US. Its debt is close to 100% of its GDP. It’s in negotiations with IMF for a loan that is now being held up by the US.
Recent moves by Pres. Bukele have been to shut down any corruption investigations against him: getting rid of the attorney general, commissioner of the transparency body IAIP, and anti-corruption body CICIES, after it had opened 12 corruption cases against his administration.
For an entrepreneur-president facing deteriorating relations with the country it is most dependent on, and preparing for sanctions and money laundering investigations, crypto has a real appeal. But it won’t work unless ES makes its own sovereign crypto, which is unlikely.
Bukele’s hope also lies in convincing Salvadorans in US to switch remittances to Bitcoin. This would be a tall order for a diaspora of 2m used to wiring cash...
The real value of the announcement though is the publicity. ES needs to attract investors and distract from fact that it’s a bad bet rn, with unsustainable debt, bad relations with US, and Bukele harassing critics in the business sector by sending regulatory agencies after them.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Why are Senate Republicans undertaking a quixotic mission to block Biden’s election? There could be lessons from Mexico...🧵
In 2006, left candidate Andrés Manuel López Obrador of the PRD narrowly lost to right candidate Felipe Calderón of the PAN by less than 1 percentage point. AMLO cried foul, which was not a crazy thing given a precedent of rigged elections in Mexico
For a long time AMLO refused to recognize the official election results. He declared himself the winner, set up a shadow cabinet, and held meetings as the legitimate president.
I read the Venezuela chapter of John Bolton’s book, which covers the first few months of 2019, from the January declaration of Juan Guaidó as acting president, to the failed April 30 coup/uprising. Some highlights (thread):
Trump’s attitude toward Venezuela policy vacillates between eagerness for a full on military invasion (opposed by his advisors) and open admiration for Maduro and disdain for Guaidó.
Trump had proposed an invasion of Venezuela in a speech in Aug. 2017. He also proposed meeting with Maduro in person. Bolton and Pompeo advised him against both.
“Why are Trump’s approval ratings for his response to COVID-19 so high when he’s (clearly messing up/spreading misinformation/exploiting it for partisan purposes)?”
1.Nearly all the heroin (and cocaine and meth) that enters the US today comes in through official ports of entry, i.e. legal border crossings and airports. It isn’t snuck in across the desert. Building a wall would do nothing to change this. See @adam_wolawola.org/analysis/four-…
2.“Millions of guns illegally pass via the border “ is deliberately misleading. The guns crossing the border are guns from the U.S. going to Mexico, fueling Mexico’s drug war. Estimates vary from 583 to 2,000 per day, including AR-15s favored by cartels. academic.oup.com/joeg/article/1…