( This article was published by Malaysiakini on 9 June, 2021 at m.malaysiakini.com/columns/578145 )
COMMENT | Thanks to voices from the public and within the political class, including that of Deputy Dewan Rakyat Speaker Azalina Othman Said, a hybrid sitting is now being studied after de facto Law Minister Takiyuddin Hassan (cont'd below)
and Dewan Rakyat Speaker Azhar Azizan Harun revised their opposition to the reopening of Parliament under the state of emergency.
Let’s be blunt. If social distancing is the reason for Parliament’s suspension, the challenge can be overcome in many ways: virtual, hybrid or even a physical session in two venues connected electronically. The obstacle is neither technological nor constitutional, but political.
It ultimately hinges on two questions:

• Will Parliament bring down the government?

• If the government needs to be kept in power, what is the necessary political settlement?
The emergency appears to be all about keeping a fragile government in power. If Parliament is reconvened, a vote of no-confidence can be passed, like how Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin’s party deputy Ahmad Faisal Azumu (cont'd below)
was dethroned as Perak menteri besar last December, with Umno and Pakatan Harapan joining forces.

If the presiding speaker or deputy speaker stands in the way, he or she can be removed too.
If a government is voted out, there are two possible outcomes in normal circumstances: a new election to produce a fresh Parliament, or a new government of a different combination, formed within the same Parliament.
The Covid-19 pandemic rules out the option of an election, which the king has rejected out right since last February. However, until Harapan and Umno – the two blocs that want Muhyiddin out – can agree on the next government’s formation, (cont'd below)
the ouster of Muhyiddin may trigger another round of MP-fishing, with no guarantee of a more functioning government than the current one.
This then leaves the palace with a few options on the menu:

(a) Partial opening of Parliament, allowing special select committees (SSCs) and all parties' parliamentary groups (APPGs) to operate and keep the ministries accountable;
(b) Full opening of Parliament without a political settlement with the risk of the government collapsing and a political stalemate;

(c) Full opening of Parliament with a reconstructed government with a stronger majority; and
(d) Full opening of Parliament with the same government, backed by a Confidence and Supply Agreement with the opposition.
Since the second option is least likely, I will first discuss the third and fourth options, which allow for a full opening. The first option with a partial opening will be discussed in another article.
*Unity government*

In theory, the second option of reconstructing the government can be achieved in more than one way. The simplest way is to reunite Umno and Bersatu, but that would be harder than reuniting Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie.
The next possibility is to bring Warisan’s eight seats into the government, which would raise the government’s majority to 121 (including Umno’s 36) versus the opposition’s 99 (including Umno’s Nazri Abdul Aziz and Ahmad Mazlan).
Warisan may be interested in an offer of having a few key ministries in the federal government, Sabah government, or both.
But the public is in no mood to stomach any more expansion of the federal frontbench to please job-hungry politicians, so any gain for Warisan would have to be a sacrifice from Umno or Bersatu.
Likewise, any state-level concession with Warisan having 21 state seats would certainly be at the expense of Umno (16 seats) or Bersatu (15 seats), further destabilising the Gabungan Rakyat Sabah (GRS) government.
Next is the idea of a "unity government" bringing in all or most parties, which effectively means adding Harapan. This is appealing to many, including well-intentioned intellectuals.
The 1974 formation of BN that brought into the government’s camp all but two parliamentary opposition parties - DAP and the now-defunct Sarawak National Party (SNAP) - is often the reference point.
That reference is very useful if we ask two questions: How long will this unity government last? If it is to be a permanent structure, how will parties in government compete against one another?
For BN, it was meant to be permanent, because its architect Abdul Razak Hussein wanted to eliminate “politicking”. This permanent characteristic caused both BN’s stability and corruption.
But even that could not work for parties with overlapping electoral markets - after six years of cohabitation with Umno, PAS left bitterly after losing Kelantan.
Ironically, unless elections are abolished, any unity government will only bring about more disunity for one simple reason: Perikatan Nasional (PN), BN, Harapan, GPS, and GRS have overlapping electoral markets and will take on one another in the next election.
The crazy inter-ministry rivalries we see between ministers Azmin Ali, Ismail Sabri Yaakob and Khairy Jamaluddin will only be worse than now. And any cabinet reshuffle will cause more political fights!
If the Muhyiddin government cannot even deliver "Muslim unity", how can adding more parties that distrust each other produce "national unity"? If two Panadol pills cannot cure your diarrhoea, would half a dozen of Panadol pills do the work?
However, as many Malaysians have this insatiable fetish of unity, this idea will never die, even if it can never work. It will remain as a “what if” zombie for good people who do not understand politics.
*Confidence and supply agreement*

A Confidence and Supply Agreement (CSA) is a deal between government and opposition that keeps the government in power (cont'd below)
with the opposition agreeing to support the government, or at least abstain, on motions of no-confidence or budgets (technically termed, “supply bills”).

Like rental contracts and unlike marriages, CSAs are meant for a limited time, normally for a parliamentary term.
This is very common in countries like Denmark and post-1996 New Zealand, when governments are minority blocs or do not have a strong majority.
New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Adern’s first term (2017-2020) was a minority coalition government of her Labour Party and NZ First, backed by a CSA with the Greens.
Realistically, this is the only solution that may deliver political stability for Malaysia for the next 12 or 18 months or until Sept 16, 2023, when the next election must be called.
This was offered by the opposition last August and October but snubbed by Muhyiddin and his senior ministers for fear of losing face.
For the sake of Malaysians' lives and livelihood, Muhyiddin should now go for a CSA that can buy him time to leave a positive legacy. As CSA does not cause cabinet reshuffles, he can please his ministers, upon whom his political survival depends.
For the CSA to effect ceasefire, it must come with two things:

• Fair treatment of opposition MPs and parties with key reforms of Parliament, Constituency Development Fund, Attorney General’s Chambers, MACC, etc;
• A promise of a free, fair and inclusive 15th general election (GE15) with a fixed date now, so that all parties can do their best preparation without feeling ambushed.
More than a political ceasefire, it will restore and enhance check and balance on the executive, paving ways for more coordinated and effective policies on the pandemic and economy, (cont'd below)
as well as the elimination of the “dua darjat” (dual-class) phenomenon in law enforcement, which ordinary Malaysians hate.
For such a CSA to be possible, both Harapan and Umno must also come to a consensus on what specific reforms they want from the government. Such consensus can be the basis of an alternative government if Muhyiddin cannot see his limited options.
WONG CHIN HUAT is an Essex-trained political scientist working on political institutions and group conflicts. Mindful of humans' self-interest motivation while pursuing a better world, he is a principled opportunist.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Mikhail Hafiz

Mikhail Hafiz Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @IMMikhailHafiz

8 Jun
The Malaysian government's failure to curtail the most recent CoVid-19 outbreak, further exacerbated by a sluggish vaccination program, has put our national health services under a tremendous amount of strain, reports @NileBowie .

"Malaysia’s health crisis is taking a turn for the worst as new Covid-19 cases rise exponentially, a viral surge that as a percentage of the population is now higher than India’s daily infection rate."
"With a record number of critically ill patients occupying almost 1,200 intensive care unit (ICU) beds, the healthcare system is at a breaking point amid reports of doctors giving priority care to patients with higher chances of recovery."
Read 30 tweets
8 Jun
"The cancellation by UTM said to be the recommendation of their 'Islamic Center' poses serious questions on the role of the university as a place to enlighten minds or a place to condition knowledge based on a narrow perspective of religious tolerance."
"One of the important aspects of nation-building that is lacking in this country is the sharing and appreciation of other cultures like those of the Kadazan, Murut, Dayak, Iban and Orang Asli."
"The issue also raises the questionable role of universities in nation building with regards to knowledge of a shared heritage in arts."
Read 15 tweets
8 Jun
The Srebrenica War Memorial not only serves as a commemorative focal point for the Bosniak genocide and the final resting place for many of its victims, but also as a damning indictment of man's inhumanity to man.

Radko Mladic - the infamous, unrepentant Butcher of Bosnia.

"The UN court upheld the life sentence for his role in the killing of around 8,000 Bosnian Muslim (Bosniak) men and boys in Srebrenica in 1995."

"The massacre, in an enclave supposed to be under UN protection, was the worst atrocity in Europe since World War Two."
Read 4 tweets
8 Jun
"This is an appeal to the prime minister and the cabinet. It is a constitutional requirement that the proclamation and emergency ordinance be laid before parliament and it must be done at once." @Ambiga_S

"IT should be patently obvious by now that the January 11 proclamation of emergency and the ensuing Emergency (Essential Powers) Ordinance 2021 have primarily served to contain our parliament, rather than the pandemic."
"Repeated calls for the reconvening of parliament, including by no less than the deputy speaker, have been ignored. Worse, the recent announcement by the home minister that parliament will not convene (cont'd below)
Read 17 tweets
8 Jun
@1AmyChew 's meticulously researched analysis on how close Chinese planes came to encroaching Malaysian airspace, a claim that is given tacit backing by the US Air Force, and its consequences re: ensuing diplomatic relations between the former two countries.
"Malaysia’s claims that 16 Chinese aircraft came close to violating its sovereign airspace last week in a rare incident which Foreign Minister Hishammuddin Hussein condemned as an “intrusion” has been given tacit backing by the US Pacific Air Forces."
The major command of the United States Air Force also expressed support for the Royal Malaysian Air Force, which scrambled jets on May 31 to visually confirm the Chinese planes that were detected within 60 nautical miles of the eastern Malaysian state of Sarawak, (cont'd below)
Read 35 tweets
7 Jun
"Stop using the emergency to cripple the progression of the Sexual Harassment Bill that was birthed by Harapan, to be tabled in Parliament. Prioritise it. Reach out to us. Speak to members of civil society who have been advocating this for decades." @PattoKasthuri
"In the recent furore surrounding the courageous exposé by teenage trailblazer Ain Husniza Saiful Nizam of rape culture sparked by her teacher, many students in institutions of higher learning have also taken to social media (cont'd below)
to share their experiences being sexually harassed and to reach out to other survivors at the hands of their lecturers and even security guards at their varsities."
Read 12 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!