Share this page!

Shadi Hamid Profile picture
Twitter logo
9 Jun, 4 tweets, 3 min read
If you missed it, our two-part conversation with @DouthatNYT on @WCrowdsLive is out. A deep dive into decadence, wokeness, interplanetary colonialism, anti-supernaturalism, and the perils of meritocracy

wisdomofcrowds.live/ross-douthat-p…
In Part 2, I ask @douthatnyt whether Christianity, in contrast to Islam, struggles with "rationalist" elites because it doesn't present itself as an explicitly rationalistic faith.

Full conversation here: wisdomofcrowds.live/ross-douthat-p…

Here's a teaser 👇🏽

The question of why educated elites don't seem to find Christianity compelling despite an obvious and often intense desire for meaning and structure is something of a puzzle. @douthatnyt has been excellent on this: nytimes.com/2021/04/10/opi…
I have my own thesis on why Christianity failed, which I teased out in a recent @WCrowdsLive essay. I find part of the answer in Christianity's relative "otherworldliness" compared to Islam. wisdomofcrowds.live/why-christiani…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
　

Keep Current with Shadi Hamid

Shadi Hamid Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @shadihamid

Shadi Hamid Profile picture
7 Jun
This is brilliant essay from @dmarusic on how the arc of history doesn't necessarily bend toward justice, and to assume that it does creates major blindspots in foreign policy. It's a tour de force of argument. But I disagree on some key points. wisdomofcrowds.live/how-liberal-tr… 1/x
This is exactly right. There was a naiveté in Obama and Kerry's notion that historic's arc was bending. *Someone* needs to do the bending, and Obama wasn't willing to back his own premise with hard power. And without power, the moralism was both empty and presumptuous. 2/x
In pointing to this false premise of the "liberal world order," @dmarusic argues that questions of order must be separated from questions of morality, but it's not clear to me that this is the right conclusion to draw. And I think this is where we diverge. 3/x
Read 14 tweets
Shadi Hamid Profile picture
4 Jun
This week's Friday Essay just dropped. @dmarusic pulls out the stops. You're not going to want to miss this one.

Like all our Friday Essays at @WCrowdsLive, it's for subscribers only, so do consider joining us if what we're doing catches your interest.
wisdomofcrowds.live/how-liberal-tr…
Here's a teaser. It's not so much the arc of history bending toward justice, but rather an "arc of despair" resigning us to sad fates.

wisdomofcrowds.live/how-liberal-tr… Image
Last week, my Friday Essay provided a counterpoint to @dmarusic's pessimism. In betraying our own ideals, we remind ourselves that we have them in the first place.

wisdomofcrowds.live/why-america-ne… Image
Read 4 tweets
Shadi Hamid Profile picture
4 Jun
Fascinating reporting from @SuneEngel in @WSJ on how the Taliban govern, whether they've changed, and what that means for #Afghanistan's future.

Includes some of my thoughts.

wsj.com/articles/the-t…
The tragic reality is that the minority of Islamist groups that use violence can often claim more success than nonviolent ones, whether the Taliban, Hayat Tahrir al-Sham in Syria, Libyan militants, or even Hamas

wsj.com/articles/the-t…
In areas where chaos and conflict are the norm, militants like the Taliban can come in and dispense rough often brutal justice, particularly when it comes to legal disputes and corruption. This gains them support, however grudging, as @SuneEngel reports.
Read 5 tweets
Shadi Hamid Profile picture
31 May
In this week's @WCrowdsLive essay, I make the case for hypocrisy in foreign policy, not because hypocrisy is good but because it is better than the alternative. I wish it were otherwise but apparently it's not. 1/x

wisdomofcrowds.live/why-america-ne…
As I finish a book about rethinking democracy promotion for the post-Trump era, I've been struggling with the question of hypocrisy. It's unavoidable now that the gap between words and deeds has returned with Biden, which is both bad and good. 2/x
The hypocrite has always been a subject of fascination, not merely because he is bad. Mere badness is pedestrian. The hypocrite is different (and worse) because of his ostentatious morality. But should a hatred of hypocrisy be applied to countries and not just individuals? 3/x
Read 7 tweets
Shadi Hamid Profile picture
23 May
I largely disagree with this.

But it's a brilliant, tour-de-force of argument. A reminder, if one was needed, of why @dmarusic is one of the most challenging and original American essayists around

wisdomofcrowds.live/the-pointlessn…
This is what I hope we can do more of at @WCrowdsLive—to find new and interesting ways of disagreeing. And use our disagreements to get to the bottom of *why* we disagree. How do we come to believe the things we believe?

When @dmarusic & I get in debates, we often find ourselves ending up at the most foundational question of all: the existence of God, because it is difficult to disentangle morality from the divine. Ostensibly, God shouldn't figure too much into our policy assessments of Gaza...
Read 5 tweets
Shadi Hamid Profile picture
20 May
By popular demand, we've decided to un-paywall my piece "I'm Angry About Palestine. Should You Be?" for a day. I didn't really write it for the public, but what the heck.

Sign up for free to get it in your inbox tomorrow morning: wisdomofcrowds.live/signup/
This is a more personal essay on what I was thinking and feeling last week as I was trying to making sense of the news in Gaza. It's as honest a piece as I could have written. I look forward to sharing it with more of you.

wisdomofcrowds.live/im-angry-about…
My piece was inspired in part by two old, estranged friends: Christopher Hitchens and Edward Said. Here, Hitchens' moral clarity cuts through. It's a beautiful passage.

wisdomofcrowds.live/im-angry-about…
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

Like this author's thread?

Get emails when @shadihamid has new unrolls!

Check out other threads from @shadihamid!

Read all threads by @shadihamid

:(