Here is a fragment of a powerful speech by the great historian of WWII Mark Solonin in which he is responding to the speech given by the President of Germany, on the anniversary of German invasion of the Soviet Union on 22 June 1941. The title of Solonin’s talk is
“Has the former FRG transformed into the former GDR?”



“As is usual among you in the West but somewhat unusual for us, you began your talk about these grandiose events of the great world war with a story about the fate of one oridnary, simple person.
You began the story with the fact that there was a Soviet soldier, Boris Popov, who met the war a few kilometers from Minsk, and on a sunny day he was resting together with his comrades on the grass, and then the first shots and the first explosions were heard.
Excuse me, but for about 20 years I occupy myself with the study of the hisotry of the first few days and weeks of the Soviet-German war and I feel obliged to tell you that your advisors who prepared this text for you have made some mistakes.
Boris Popov and his comrades were not a few kilometers to the west of Minsk, he was several hundred kilometers to the West of Minsk.
That is a fact beyond all doubt, because on the morning of 22 of June nobody bombed Minsk, not a single German airplane appeared there and certainly German artillery could not reach Minsk which is hundreds of kilometers from the border.
After that you say that he was in a mechanised unit, that they were three comrades and armored car that was lost, so one can roughly understand where Boris Popov could have been at that time, where he met the first hours of the war.
It could have been the 11th Mechanised Corps in the Grodno region, it could have been the 6th Mechanised Corps in the Białystok region, it could have been the 13th Mechnised Corps in the region of Bielsk or the 14th Mechanised Corps in the region of Kobryn.
It could also have been a tank regiment of the 6th Cavalry Corps which was located in the region of Łomża.
Grodno, Łomża, Białystok, Bielsk or Bielsk Podlaski in Polish, and Kobryn.
Where were these places?
I have not the slightest doubt that you know very well the political map of pre-war Europe so the answer is obvious: that was Poland. All these 4 places were within the internationally recognized borders of Poland.
(From me: today Grodno and Kobryn are in Belarus, the other two in Poland).

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Andrzej Kozlowski

Andrzej Kozlowski Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @akoz33

3 Jul
Radzinsky on the famous Soviet-Union Yougoslavia football clash at the 1952 Olympics.
Near the end of

(34.03-37.35)
My translation lacks his laughter and tone of voice which must be heard for full effect. The comments in brackets
are mine.
But of course football did not always bring happiness to the Leader. In the first Olympic Games in which we participated our footballers came up against, I think it was in quarter-finals (actually 1:16), the team of Yugoslavia.
The thing is that at this time it was not simply Yugoslavia. It was Yugoslavia which had gone off the correct path, it was Yugoslavia whose head was the renegade Tito. He was no longer referred to as Tito but as the Tito Clique.
Read 9 tweets
1 Jul
I posted this already several times before (there were also articles in the New York Times and The Atlantic).

science.sciencemag.org/content/368/64…
It may seem to be now obsolete because of the presence of specific vaccines but in view of the arguments about vaccinating children etc, it seems worth while to post my translation of a fragment of interview with Konstantin Chumakov about the importance of non-specific immunity,
interferon and why these well known tools are being totally ignored.
Read 15 tweets
1 Jul
Here is Radzinsky’s answer to Steven Pinker (from the Prologue of his series on history of Russia & not only)
““Because of this we shall talk about people who lived by great ideas, great tasks …
because our our age, which is somewhat an age of Lilliputians, lacks such greatness. As for ideas, we have had enough ideas:
the whole century everyone was concerned with the happiness of humanity, but somehow all these concerns ended up with concentration camps, the Gulag, executions,
Read 5 tweets
30 Jun
I greatly admired Donald Rumsfeld. His strategic views on Afghanistan and Iraq were quite different, in fact the opposite, of what became US policy. History, unfortunately, can’t be rerun but in my view had Rumsfeld been really in charge of US policy rather than the deadweight
Colin Powell, the world would probably today be in a much better state.
I remember the early meeting in Afghanistan between Rumsfeld and the Tajik warlord (& great warrior) Ismail Khan. At that time Rumsfeld wanted basically to build a US supplied but tribal-based Afghan army,
which was exactly what Khan wanted to. It was not to be and Ismail Khan, one of the heroes of the struggle against the Soviets & the Taliban became an object of vilification in US media.
I wanted to find a photo of this meeting but apparently there seems to be none on the
Read 4 tweets
24 Jun
Here is another story that Edvard Radzinsky tells which I think is also relevant to his view on the role of Destiny or God in history.
Here is a shortened version (he tells it much better than I can repeat it).
During Gorbacchov’s perestroika he finally managed to get hold of the famous Yurovsky note (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yakov_Yur… ) in which the murder of the tsar’s family was described I great detail.
So, in his own way, possessing this unique material that had not yet been seen by any historian, he started to write a novel based on it. And he was writing on what he says was one of the first PCs in Moscow.
Read 12 tweets
23 Jun
These remarks of Radzinsky about his religiousness in his interview with Posner connect with a lot of my own thoughts, so I will write a few threads on it, of which this is the first one.
What Radzinsky told Posner about the way he sees the “hand of God” in history, “even to the point of comedy”, is actually quite apparent in all his books and videos. It is probably one reason why he so often smiles or even loughs talking about terrible events:
like Camille Desmoulins being taken to the guillotine and shouting “it was I who started this revolution”. Radzinsky sees Russian revolution as a kind of God’s punishment for the terrible crimes of Russian history,
Read 28 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(