My turn for a social media break friends. I thought I had last year packed up in a box but the covid ad is circulating, and keeps knocking that box off the shelf without my permission. But first, a rant. Content warning: avoid if you’re HCW or have lost someone to covid.
The ad you saw does not represent young people (in a functioning health system, which we have). They would never be left like that. For older people, it is a different story.
Ventilation, ICU, things drugs ending in β€’β€’mab, these all help us wait out diseases in well bodies. In unwell, ageing bodies, these things make the underlying problems worse, they accelerate the complications of ageing. Older bodies can’t tolerate the drugs used for ventilation
What this means for the older covid sufferer, is that they don’t go to ICU, because their bodies get worse from the interventions there. They never wake up, and if they do, their minds are gone forever, to a terrible new dementia. This is the reality of geriatric medicine.
But a professor of oncology once told me as a junior, there is never nothing we can do. Whether it’s medicine or surgery, morphine or ice cream, there is always something we can do. Futile is a dirty word in geriatrics.
Instead, we change our goal from trying to cure the incurable (old age), to supporting through illness, and if the illness starts to irrerversibly take hold, we change our goals to prioritising comfort and dignity above all else.
At our subacute outbreak last year, there was no ICU for our patients who caught it inside the hospital walls. There was no high flow nasal prongs.
There was 5L/min of nasal prong oxygen only, steroids, and faceless people in blue, holding their hands through an endless supply of blue gloves. And patient, after patient, after patient, all breathing like the young woman in that ad.
And for us and families, impossible decisions, and impossible discussions. Morphine to settle their symptoms and relieve their distress, at the expense of their oxygenation? Ie let them go?
Or hold their hands through that endless suffocation knowing they would likely not make it…but they might? If you chose the former, did you let them go too soon? If you chose the latter, were their last hours needlessly in distress?
We had over a hundred older patients at our outbreak. We rang their families every single day. Often more than once in a day. Had a spectrum of discussions I never imagined I would have in my career. That ad was our reality for too many. I cannot watch it.
I have held that hand more than I ever want to. No matter your age, no one deserves that. Those who say to let it rip and let the elderly die have never held that hand, and they know that they never will.
Our mortality rate was 30%. Subacute patients are special. They are with us for weeks, sometimes months. We make friends with them. We all said goodbye too many times, watching that ad play out. All the covid HCWs, turn off Twitter for a while now and protect yourselves.
I’ll be back in a week which in media time is like ten years. I hope it’s been replaced with something more human by then. That box shouldn’t get unpacked at random like that. Thanks for listening friends (I am okay, but in the interests of remaining that way, off I go). πŸ™πŸ’–

β€’ β€’ β€’

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
γ€€

Keep Current with Dr Kate Miller πŸ³οΈβ€πŸŒˆ

Dr Kate Miller πŸ³οΈβ€πŸŒˆ Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @DrKate_Miller

9 Jul
Someone posted the other day asking the question - what is the word for the pandemic induced sheer exhaustion that everyone is feeling right now? I thought a lot about it, and can't find the original post to answer, but I think the answer is...
Grief.

Grief is sneaky. It's exhaustion, it's mood swings, it's wondering what life is all for, it's random tears and even more random laughs. It's a bit like diarrhoea in the way it comes and goes. One minute you're okay, the next you're really not.
And we all have so. much. to. grieve. Our jobs, our working relationships, the dreams we had for the future, if we have a future, our kids lives. Grief makes you wonder if everything is ever going to be okay again. You feel like you're in a dinghy in a tusnami.
Read 7 tweets
8 Jul
Data duplication in medicine, a rant. So much time is taken up in our job of re-entering the same data, for each patient across different medical services. Medications. Medical histories. Mostly static information (in geriatrics anyway).
Then, there’s the time wasted finding information (such as blood test results). No centralised access to any of this information. So for every patient, I will re-enter their medical history and what medications they’re on.
The level of error that gets introduced by duplication is concerning. Especially for residential aged care residents whose histories are long. I have residents on up to 45 drugs at a time. Databases all have slightly different formats and nomenclature for this stuff.
Read 9 tweets
11 Jun
I know everyone is focusing on the new changes to medicare but I want to point out something more insidious. The freeze on the medicare rebates for GPs. This is the single biggest erosion of Medicare there is.
What does this mean? The amount Medicare rebates for your visit to the GP is about $37. Usually this price is indexed (rises a small amount in line with wage levels) every year. Until it was 'temporarily' frozen in 2013.
Other specialties item numbers have continued to be indexed (please remember that GP is now a specialty too with it's own training program, I'm aware it didn't use to be) but not GPs. So they are running practices on 2021 costs but being 2013/14 wages.
Read 13 tweets
9 Jun
Everything we see with Medicare, with private contractors managing hotel quarantine and vaccine rollouts, goes back to medical deregulation. It used to be that only doctors/allied health could run these organisations...
...but this was changed (deregulated) to anyone who wanted to own a medical practice could, no expertise required. That's how franchised GP clinics came about, how privatised medical organisations appeared etc.
This was done under the veil of 'good economic management' but what we know now is that the real result was taxpayer money going into the hands of those responsible for that deregulation.
Read 8 tweets
21 May
Alright, a tweet series on what I currently think about the AZ vaccine. This is NOT medical advice, I am not an expert by any means, I don't have the same access to data that the public health guys do, I'm just a geriatrician trying to figure this out too in an info vacuum.
So before you get stuck into me about being a murderer/playing god/being Bill Gates drone...just don't. I'm not here to shame anyone, I'm here to discuss. Whatever you choose, based on your own personal circumstances, is just fine.
In 800 AD smallpox had wiped out millions. Chinese doctors discovered that by taking scrapings of smallpox and pipetting it up peoples noses, they could prevent smallpox. The fatality rate of this was a whopping 1%. People still took it; the smallpox death rate was 35%.
Read 25 tweets
21 May
Roots of geriatric medicine stretch back 5000 years ago, in the Nile Valley, Egypt. Demonstrating a hieroglyph for the world 'old'. It's a bent over person with a gait aid! #ANZSGM2021 Dr William Browne - The Unexpected History of Geriatric Medicine
(I am loving this talk SICK). Ptah-Hotel 2000 BCE - "Old age makes a man miserable". #ANZSGM2021 Dr William Browne
Ancient Greek depiction of 'Geras' the god of old age - the root of the word geriatric. #ANZSGM2021 Dr William Browne
Read 24 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(