Self isolation post pinging is posing enormous difficulties for hundreds of thousands of people/businesses across the UK-see below. PM and Chancellor have been pinged but said they’re taking part in a pilot study which will allow them to keep working in Downing St.
This study may well unlock the same privilege for many businesses. But the political risk is clear. The opposition has already sought to emphasise the idea that there’s one rule for ministers and another for everyone else. You’ll be hearing that *a lot* today.
This govt has been at its most vulnerable precisely when that sense has been at its most acute- Cummings, Hancock etc.

On a disease management level hard to see how govt comprehensively refutes charge that they don’t consider self isolation post pinging as being that important.
Politically speaking they did well to nip that in the bud before it consumed them for a day or more. But equally, it does not speak especially well of the political instincts of those in Downing St at the moment that someone/anyone thought that was a good or saleable idea.
Of course that didn’t stop Robert Jenrick being sent out to defend the idea this morning.
Robert Jenrick this morning: “They will be isolating but using the pilot scheme for daily testing which is available for a variety of public sector organisations...the scheme is a well known one...the app is doing what it’s been asked to do.”
Jenrick this am: “it is important that if anybody is contact by NHS track and trace they do take the steps that are required of them...it’s an extremely important part of our way of keeping the virus under control.”
The other way of looking at this episode is that it is unrealistic to continue to expect people who are double vaccinated to self isolate after contact with someone who is infected (who are themselves vaccinated). But that is (for another month) government policy.
ONS say that 25% of those asked to self isolate face financial hardship. It’s already an extremely difficult choice for many. Today won’t have done much to persuade anyone in that position they should absorb that hardship for the greater good. ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulati…
No 10’s actions this morning indicate that their thinking is testing for the double vaccinated is a more sensible policy than current rules on self isolation. That’s a perfectly legitimate view many agree with. The problem is it’s not the policy for everyone else at the moment.
Blair: “The system isn’t rational...people are thinking it’s ridiculous. If I’m not pinged I’m able to go into a pub, mix with people with no restrictions whatever. If I’m pinged even though I’m vaccinated and tested, I’ve got to go into isolation.”
Blair: “I don’t want the prime minister of the country to be isolated at the moment, he needs to be at his desk doing his job, if he’s testing and coming back negative. But the point is that system has to be there for everyone.”

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Lewis Goodall

Lewis Goodall Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @lewis_goodall

20 Jul
FIRE SAFETY LATEST

Yday spent the evening talking to leaseholders of Richmond House on the south west London/Surrey border.

Or rather- what's left of Richmond House, it burnt down in 2019. The fire cavity barriers were labelled as "defective" in an independent report 🧵 Image
RH is instructive because it potentially highlights two central weaknesses of the government's response to the crisis

1) idea that litigation is a credible solution
2) idea that problem is only or mainly with buildings which were 18m or over with cladding problems
First background

Richmond House burnt down in September 2019. It was built in 2010/11 by Berkeleys one of the biggest building firms in Britain.

The estate "The Hamptons" is a big one. As the name would suggest it's got an American air. Big houses. Wide avenues. Opulent.
Read 24 tweets
20 Jul
Endless paradoxes with Cummings, as ever. He works to make a man he says is an incompetent prime minister. He does so because he thinks it would be dangerous not to honour democracy. Having been democratically elected with big maj,DC says days later he is discussing removing him.
Key exchange below

Laura K: "Some people will be listening to you saying you were thinking of getting rid of Boris Johnson and just wonder who you think you are?"

Cummings: "Possibly but the situation we found ourselves in was that within days the PM's gf is trying...
...to get rid of us and appoint clowns to certain key jobs. Do you just go, OK that's fine or do you say, OK that's a disaster and try and avoid that happening?"

So Mr Cummings believed the survival of he and his core team was more important than the survival of the just....
Read 6 tweets
20 Jul
NEW: Covid related absence in England’s schools continues to increase. On 15th July Covid related absence in English state schools was 14.3%. That’s up from 11.2% on 8th a July and 8.5% on 1st July.
Picture is even worse in secondary schools- was 17.9% on 15 July. This is up from 13.5% on 8 July and 10.4% on 1 July respectively. So going on for 1 in 5 English secondary school pupils off for Covid related absence (not necessarily nor likely because they actually had Covid).
You’ll see that demonstrated here. Vast majority of absence as a result of contact with Covid+ pupil (or suspected), not because they themselves had tested positive. Image
Read 5 tweets
18 Jul
NEW: England has moved into Step 4 of the roadmap and lifted remaining Coronavirus opening restrictions. Hence 👇
Doubtless Twitter is going to be flooded with people expressing concern about nightclubs. Whatever you think, do dial down any judgmental comments. Loads of young people have sacrificed a lot in the pandemic and now doing what the govt (rightly or wrongly) is saying they can.
Well all the replies to this demonstrated the grace, understanding and lack of judgment we’ve come to expect on here during this period.
Read 4 tweets
18 Jul
Boris Johnson: “We did look briefly at the idea [of the pilot test scheme] but I think it’s far more important that everybody sticks to the same rules.”

Looked at briefly? Until the u-Turn we were told that was the actual plan. Indeed Robert Jenrick was sent out to defend it.
Number 10’s statement this morning: “They will be participating in the daily contact testing pilot to allow them to continue to work from Downing Street."
The Prime Minister, having said that Numbers 10/11 only “briefly looked” at the idea of using the pilot programme (despite No 10 briefing they categorically would be and a cabinet minister defending said action) goes on to urge the public to “stick with the programme.”
Read 8 tweets
18 Jul
The question of coherence (or a lack of it) is at the heart of the govt’s Covid problems right now. Freedom day with pinging still in place. Fully vaccinated in isolation but unvaccinated with full freedom. Domestic restrictions laissez faire yet tough intl travel rules.
It feels as if government is willing us to move to a new stage with much of the old apparatus still in place and without much sketched out in terms of a new system which will enable us to “live with it” as ministers say they want. We’re neither in one place nor the other.
The place we’re in is high vaccination plus high prevalence which has clearly taken ministers but surprise as a result of Delta. But that means it is v difficult if not impossible to, as ministers want, to move the dial back to something “normal” w/o a new plan in place.
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(