1) All Biden had left by 2021 were bad options, but it didn't have to be *this* bad. This cake was baked a long time ago; missteps as early as 2002 and the distraction invasion of Iraq meant that we mishandled and mis-fought this war for twenty years.
2) I don't know anyone knowledgeable about Afghanistan who ever imagined that this would end differently. The reason we stayed for 20 years was the unspoken shared assumption that the Afghan government couldn't stand on its own.
Would the government we left behind last 3 years? A year? 90 days? 30 days? A week? At some point, it doesn't really matter. This was where things would end up.
3) Four presidents have mishandled this—and all share blame (most of all: Bush). Most recently, the Trump administration set in motion a destabilizing series of actions that made a bad-but-stable situation worse.
4) All of that said, the Biden administration does own *HOW* we left and the human toll of these final, all-too-desperate hours show a lack of planning that should forever be a moral stain on this administration.
tl;dr: We owed the Afghans better.
5) It’s just heartbreaking to see Afghanistan fall to the Taliban—again—on the eve of the 20th anniversary of 9/11. So much blood, so much treasure, and here we are again.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
THREAD: Today marks the 20th anniversary of the September 11th attacks. Throughout the day, I’ll be chronologically tweeting quotes from my book THE ONLY PLANE IN THE SKY: An Oral History of 9/11, following Americans as they experience that day.... garrettgraff.com/books/the-only…
We’re also collecting stories from the #my911story hashtag, as people share their own experiences of that day. I’ll be sharing selected tweets and others’ stories throughout the day.
(If you don’t want to see these quotes all day, just mute this thread.)
THREAD: The first episodes of my 9/11 podcast LONG SHADOW are out now. My goal with this eight-episode series is to try to tell the story of that day for a new generation as well as make sense of some of the questions that linger: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/lon…
In some ways, this podcast from @longlead and @goatrodeo, is the culmination of all the reporting and writing I've done on 9/11 and its aftermath over two decades—including five books where that tragic day serves as the hinge of modern history.
The first episode deals with the rescue and collapse of the World Trade Center—an unprecedented and unimagined catastrophe, the scene of some of that day's bravest heroism and greatest tragedy: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/why…
An honest question: Has a single pundit anywhere over this last week outlined a concrete and realistic plan for a better path forward in Afghanistan? For all the hand-wringing and pearl-clutching, I haven't seen anyone knowledgable offer a better solution.
Almost everything I've seen—in print and TV—are the same people who previously failed in their own efforts to solve Afghanistan over the last 20 years expressing disgust that Biden didn't miraculously solve all the intractable problems that they themselves kicked down the road.
I really find nothing more tiresome and hack-ish in politics than former officials tsk-tsk-ing on how to do something better, when in reality they—when it was their turn—didn't and couldn't do it better.
More than 2 1/2 hours ago, Texas Senator @JohnCornyn incorrectly posted that the US has 30,000 troops stationed in *Taiwan*, which should be obviously wrong to a US Senator. But he hasn’t corrected it and deleted the tweet. So enjoy this embarrassment:
Cornyn (or more like a staffer) misread a Google page and didn’t click through to see that the US command ended there in *1979*. It’s a dangerous mistake, but also mostly a dumb one. This is the kind of rookie internet error we expect from Marco Rubio!
THREAD: The seemingly coordinated right-wing noise and disinformation campaign targeting @Susan_Hennessey this week—another smart woman who worked hard to hold to account the worst excesses of the Trump admin—is a fascinating case study in the GOP's attempt to rewrite history.
1) As you may know, Susan—one of the smartest people I've ever encountered anywhere & former NSA lawyer—joined the @TheJusticeDept's National Security Division Monday as a senior counsel. Ever since, the right-wing noise machine has ginned up one false controversy after another.
2) First @ggreenwald attacked her for deleting old tweets, clearly a plot to disguise her past statements. The reality—as Susan has said!—is her tweets have long auto-deleted, a policy she began when…wait for it… @ggreenwald began auto-deleting tweets.
THREAD: In reporting my new oral history of the bin Laden raid, I was struck again & again about the incredible cloak of secrecy thrown around this operation. Five remarkable details of just how secret—and important—OPERATION NEPTUNE'S SPEAR truly was: politico.com/news/magazine/…
1) The precision model-builders at @NGA_GEOINT who constructed the mock-up of bin Laden's Abbottabad compound didn't know what they had built or what it was for until they opened the New York Times the day after the raid and saw a picture of the house. politico.com/news/magazine/…
2) The NSA paused all software updates for weeks ahead of the raid, to avoid any risk of disrupting intelligence collection. NSA exec estimates just *50* people across the agency knew of the op; only after did he told the teams that had provided overwatch. politico.com/news/magazine/…