“Without changing […] relationships in society – […] those between men & women, adults & children, whites & other ethnic groups, heterosexuals & gays […] – society will be riddled by domination even in a socialistic ‘classless’ & ‘non-exploitative’ form.”
– Murray Bookchin
Continued:
“It would be infused by hierarchy even as it celebrated the dubious virtues of ‘people’s democracies,’ ‘socialism’ & the ‘public ownership’ of ‘natural resources.’”
Continued:
“[…] as long as hierarchy persists, as long as domination organizes humanity around a system of elites, the project of dominating nature will continue to exist & inevitably lead our planet to ecological extinction.”
Some of us squander so many opportunities for good-faith discourse and education on here because we’re more concerned with looking smart for followers or going viral than appealing to the humanity of others.
Don’t be a “Leftist” absorbed by the neoliberal logic of this platform.
Anyone with a conscience should be using everything at their disposal – which includes social media and technology more broadly – for problem-solving right now, with the urgency of someone trapped in a burning building with everyone else on here and in need of an escape plan.
The sentiments espoused in the clip above are steeped in a dangerous, neoliberal logic of competitive, industrial expansionism, as opposed to a social logic of cooperation for ecologically sustainable democratization of productive forces for the commons.
Nothing “Left” about it.
Please see the clip below for a quick introduction to how/why the sentiments expressed in the clip featured at the top of this thread are an issue.
Also consider looking into the concepts of “hard” and “soft” power – very crucial for this specific topic.
Anarchists (Libertarian Socialists) are perceived as a threat and attacked by all sides of the political spectrum (if you will) because what all other sides have in common (Left or Right) is an acceptance of top-down hierarchy and coercive authority (even if some try to hide it).
Anarchists understand Capitalism as not only a system of exploitation, but a system of domination as well, and they understand that domination (in some form or another) has essentially existed since human beings have been around (well before Capitalism even had a name).
Anarchists believe production must be controlled by the people themselves in service to the commons, just as most self-described Socialists/Communists do.
But they have never believed that production must first pass through the hands of some bureaucratic body for this to happen.
Why is it so hard for some white Leftists (of every tendency) to stay in their lane?
Just because you know Black people who agree with you on some things doesn’t give you license to insert yourself into Black community dialogue.
This shouldn’t need to be stated in 2021.
We started our org in 2018 because it was just as clear then as it is now that we need our own institutions to cover our own history and make our own decisions about our own futures. Unfortunately, we don’t yet have our own public digital spaces for clear, uninterrupted dialogue.
So if you are white and claim to be a comrade, and see Black folks with similar views having a discussion about something online, and sense that there is a disagreement on matters that don’t necessarily concern you, it’s probably best for you to stay out of it.