A footnote to my @TheAtlantic on the hazards of individual gun ownership. 1/x theatlantic.com/magazine/archi…
@TheAtlantic As the article details, the vast majority of American gun buyers buy their guns with a view to protecting themselves or their families. Very few entertain fantasies of waging private war on the government. They mostly buy handguns, not rifles, let alone military-style rifles. 2/x
@TheAtlantic Yet here on Twitter (and in the email I get), there is a lot of talk about the private gun as bulwark against state tyranny. If the Nazis come to power in the United States, gun carriers will mobilize to do battle for the liberties of us all. So let's talk about that idea. 3/x
@TheAtlantic Specifically, let's talk about Herman Presser, the German-born labor activist at the center of one of the US Supreme Court's landmark Second Amendment cases. 4/x
Like many Chicago working men, Presser was radicalized by the sharp downturn in the US economy after the return to the gold standard in 1873.

As prices plunged, factory owners cut wages. Workers resisted. Factory owners recruited armed enforcers against their workers. 5/x
Presser became convinced that the US was lurching toward a cataclysmic battle between Labor and Capitol. He recruited 30 fellow German and Czech immigrants into a militia against the coming class war. They got hold of Civil War surplus rifles and began to practice with them. 6/x
Appalled, the Illinois legislature in 1879 passed a law creating a National Guard as its state militia - and requiring any other would-be militias to request a license from the state governor.

Presser's little group applied and was refused. 7/x
Presser's group defied the ban. In December 1879, they shouldered rifles and marched in Chicago.

They were all promptly arrested - including Presser himself, who was armed only with a saber, an exemption specifically allowed by state law.

Presser was tried and convicted. 8/x
Presser appealed his conviction all the way to the US Supreme Court.

Presser's lawyers there argued that Illinois could not ban Presser's militia because US citizens possessed a Second Amendment right to bear arms and to practice together. 9/x
The Supreme Court ruled against Presser law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/t… on two main grounds:

1) The 2nd Amendment protects US citizens only against federal action, not state. (That part of the Presser holding was over-ruled in the 2010 case McDonald v. City of Chicago.)

But also 10/x
2) that states had near-absolute authority to define who and what counted as a "militia" under the 2nd amendment.

Presser's socialist group was a challenge to state authority, properly suppressed by state power. *THAT* part of Presser remains law even after McDonald. 11/x
It's now interesting to contrast Presser to the US Supreme Court's previous excursion into 2nd amendment law, US v. Cruikshank, in 1876. That case arose from the horrible Colfax massacre in Louisiana. blackpast.org/african-americ… 12/x
The Reconstruction government of Louisiana had recruited black men into the legal state militia. In 1872, illegal white militias attacked a unit of the legal militia. The legal militia lost the fight and surrendered. The illegal white militia massacred the survivors. 13/x
The US government prosecuted the killers. The US Supreme Court dismissed the case against the killers as not properly a federal matter. law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/t… 14/x
Let's leave aside the technical legal issues and just notice this:

Herman Presser's socialist band in Chicago 1879: wrong kind of militia, properly suppressed.

Knights of the White Camellia and Ku Klux Klan in Louisiana 1872: not the wrong kind of militia, not suppressed. 15/x
Gun rights in the US have never been a tool for the powerless.

Gun rights in the US have often been a tool for the locally powerful.

16/x
This remains true today. Everybody understands what would happen if a group of Muslim Americans shouldered AR-15s and marched to the legislature of a "Constitutional Carry" state under green flags and chanting "Allahu Akbar." 17/x
Today's armed groups likewise enjoy the tacit - or even explicit - permission of local power-holders to intimidate or even terrorize the locally disfavored. 18/x
I say all this with zero sympathy for any kind of armed dissident against legal power in a constitutional society like the United States. Got a beef against authority? Use your words and your vote.

19/x
A gun to protect yourself against criminal threats? For most people in most places, it's at best a waste of money, at worst a tragedy in the making. For those who truly need it, there should be some system of proper training and licensing.

20/x
But for those who imagine the private gun as their defense against state oppression - the sad record of American history is that the private gun has much more often been used by local tyrants to oppress neighbors peacefully exercising *their* legitimate rights. END.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with David Frum

David Frum Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @davidfrum

14 Sep
You don't need a new book to tell you that Trump tried to overturn an election and the Constitution by violence.

Or that House/Senate Republicans refused to impeach/convict him for his violent attempt.

Or that Trump is the front-runner for the GOP 2024 presidential nomination.
At this point, the news is not what Trump did in January 2021.

The news is the ever-growing number of Republicans willing to excuse, justify, exonerate, and repeat what Trump did in January 2021.
I know it's hard to keep being shocked.

But it did really actually happen that as a sitting president Donald Trump tried to overturn the US Constitution by violence.

And that a big chunk of the Congress and the country shrugged off the attempt as no big deal.
Read 4 tweets
12 Sep
How's the mass civil disobedience campaign against vaccine mandates going? At United Airlines, 50% of unvaccinated employees have already complied in the first 3 weeks of the 5 week grace period, according to CEO Jack Kirby. npr.org/2021/09/10/103…
How's the mass civil disobedience campaign against vaccine mandates going? At Delta Airlines, the vaccination rate has risen to 78% in just two weeks since a mandate was imposed, with no resignations, says the company's chief health officer. seattletimes.com/business/delta…
How's the mass civil disobedience campaign against vaccine mandates going? Tyson's Food imposed a mandate in August, employee vaccination rate has risen from 45% to 72% - cutting number of unvaccinated workers in half in less than a month whitehouse.gov/covidplan/
Read 17 tweets
11 Sep
In her excellent biography of Nancy Reagan, @ktumulty debunks the claim that Nancy's conservative Republican stepfather Loyal Davis swayed Ronald Reagan's political views. Instead, says @ktumulty, there's only one documented instance of Davis influencing Reagan ... 1/x
@ktumulty ... in 1967, when the California legislature enacted a permissive abortion law. Governor Reagan pondered whether to sign it. Davis - by then one of the country's most eminent brain surgeons - urged that Reagan should. For that reason or others, Reagan did. 2/x
@ktumulty Davis disapproved of the New Deal, but he put on record his distaste for organized religion of any kind and his lack of faith in Christianity in particular. Politics then was different from politics now. 3/3
Read 4 tweets
3 Sep
A toddler in Florida found his father's gun, then fatally shot his mother in the head as she talked to colleagues on Zoom. globalnews.ca/news/8109852/m…

Fewer than half of American gun owners consistently store all their weapons safely. theatlantic.com/magazine/ar
That happened just this past August, shortly after we finished work on my @TheAtlantic piece on guns. Also in August, a North Carolina man who had not secured his gun was fatally shot by his own two-year-old son. independent.co.uk/news/world/ame…
@TheAtlantic Just two days ago, a Minnesota man annoyed by the antics of young people in a car in the next road lane shot and killed an 18 year old boy. twincities.com/2021/09/01/st-…
Read 10 tweets
31 Aug
Powerful by @anneapplebaum - and I'd throw in another literary reference alongside hers to "The Scarlet Letter" 1/x
@anneapplebaum In her novella "Autres Temps," Edith Wharton tells the story of Mrs. Lidcote, who is exiled from New York's high society in disgrace because she divorced her husband sometime in the 1880s. 2/x gutenberg.org/files/24132/24…
@anneapplebaum Then history repeats itself. Sometime in the mid-1910s (the novella was published in 1916), Mrs. Lidcote's daughter Leila divorces her husband. Mrs Lidcote rushes home from European banishment to stand with her daughter against the impending social catastrophe ... 3/x
Read 9 tweets
28 Aug
"Parole Sirhan Sirhan? Are you crazy?"

"Look, the governor appointed you to this commission. You owe him. He's facing a tough recall election. He needs you to tee up for him an easy, crowd-pleasing, tough-on-crime VETO. So do your damn duty for your party, parole commissioner!"
For those asking, yes the governor can over-rule the commission.

And for those making the point that some members of the RFK family support the parole, I'll just note that the family member chiefly pushing it is RFK Jr. cnn.com/2021/08/27/us/…
More about RFK Jr here. Basically, you shouldn't trust him to read the time of day off a digital clock. mcgill.ca/oss/article/co…
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(