On a break at the Lacey Larkin Trial. Attorney for Jim Larkin, Whitney Bernstein, did a very effective cross examination of the woman who said that she was trafficked and that ads of her appeared on #Backpage, posted either by herself or by her trafficker. 1/
This was during a time where she had run away from home during several months in 2010. Bernstein established that the witness, A tall thin woman with long red hair in a black pantsuit, had never met or communicated with any of the defendants. 2/
I am not using her Name here because she was trafficked and the persons who trafficked her are in prison, save for a female trafficker who has never been found. 3/
Under questioning by Bernstein the woman admitted that she lied about her age on Backpage and that she had violated the website’s terms of use. 4/
The woman could not recall how many times she had posted on. She said that some ads may have been re-posted as many as 70 times. 5/
Under questioning she admitted that she had been arrested at least one time for prostitution before the time she was rescued by police. After 1st arrest she was questioned for 6 hours by the police. She gave police a fake name & fake age. Police suspected she was underage…6/
And she was not charged and she was released. Bernstein asked, “so the police were not able to determine your age by looking at you?” The woman admitted that they were not able to prove that she was underage by looking at her in person. 7/
The woman was arrested at the time in question as part of a prostitution sting. The cops had responded to an ad placed by her pimp. This is a significant point. Because the police were not able to determine whether or not the girl in front of them was a minor. 8/
Remember, according to the woman she was 15 at the time of this arrest. The police had seen and responded to the advertisement that was on backpage. So if the police cannot determine if a girl that Young is underage when she is right in front of them…9/
… then how is a moderator sitting in front of a computer looking at a photo that is likely obscured in someway supposed to determine age? Again please remember that the prosecution says these ads were obviously for prostitution. If so why couldn’t the police arrest her? 10/
Our break is almost over. So I will check back in after court is done for the day. 11/11

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Stephen Lemons

Stephen Lemons Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @stephenlemons

11 Sep
Court out in the Lacey Larkin Trial just a few minutes ago. After the Young woman left the stand her mother took the stand. And basically just discussed her activism trying to get a law in Washington state passed to require in person ID for any adult online activity 1/
That law, which was passed, actually was found to be unconstitutional and was overturned. Under questioning the mom had to admit that the law would’ve applied to a lot of different websites including google Twitter etc. any website they might have adult content on it 2/
In other words it was a dangerous law. And you know why it was overturned? Because Backpage challenged it. The mom was also asked about this supposed quote from Lacey where she says he looked at her and referred to her and the people she was with as yahoos. 3/
Read 23 tweets
10 Sep
LaceyLarkin and Trial just broke for lunch after the tearful testimony of a young woman who was trafficked out in early age she had three pimps during a time where she had run away from home twice 1/
I’m not going to use the woman’s name because she obviously was victimized by somebody when she was age 15 and 16. My caveat would be that she was not victimized by Michael Lacey or Jim Larkin or any of their four codefendants 2/
Attorneys for the defense fought to keep this testimony out, because it does not relate to any of the underlying 50 ads in the indictment 3/
Read 14 tweets
10 Sep
On a brief break from court at the Lacey and Larkin Trial. Most of this morning has been taken up with the cop from California who basically is reading from what he says are old ads that appeared on #Backpage 1/
The cop explained how he posted an ad for a nonexistent sex worker in The Sacramento Section of Backpage under escorts. And he also posted an ad for a green couch under the furniture section of the Sacramento Backpage 2/
Guess which one got more responses? Drumroll please. The escort. No surprise there. He said he only got one call on the couch. Granted the couch didn’t look like very much. 3/
Read 9 tweets
10 Sep
Back to federal court in Phoenix for the #LaceyLarkinTrial. Scuttlebut is codefendant who was feeling unwell yesterday did not test positive 4 Covid, but court has yet to verify this. ICYMI, please watch @morganloewcbs5's recent piece on #Backpage 1/
In it, Loew explains that the federal government admitted Backpage's takedown in 2018 hurt its ability to find and rescue endangered women and minors. Backpage was a goldmine of info for the FBI and other LEAs & responded to subpoenas w/in 24 hrs. Less if need be.2/
Adult-oriented ads have since migrated overseas to platforms that do not recognize U.S. subpoenas or feel any need to cooperate with U.S. LEAs. As are result, women and marginal communities are less safe. 3/
Read 6 tweets
9 Sep
Court in the #LaceyLarkinTrial recessed 20 minutes ago. In the Last hour, after the jury had been dismissed for the day, a fight broke out between the prosecution and the defense with defense lawyer Whitney Bernstein who represents Jim Larkin bringing up the infamous DOJ memos 1/
These are DOJ memos from 2012 & 2013 which argued #Backpage should not be prosecuted in large part because Backpage was helpful to law-enforcement the in tracking down trafficked victims. The memos also discussed difficulty of determining the age of a female depicted in the ads2/
These memos are out in the public.@WIRED magazine first mentioned them in a 2019 article, and @ENBrown of @reason published the entirety of the memos shortly thereafter. 3/
Read 18 tweets
8 Sep
On the afternoon break in the Lacey Larkin Trial, attorneys for some of the co-defendants reinforced many of the arguments that Bennett had made at the beginning of the day. 1/#Backpage #FirstAmendment
I don’t have much time, but Lacey‘s attorney Paul Cambria ended with a rousing defense of his client. In a booming voice he discussed how Lacey and Larkin were “the real deal “when it came to defending freedom of speech. 2/
He discussed how they were arrested by Joe Arpaio in the middle of the night but they fought back sued and won more than $3.5 million, which they then gave to charity. 3/
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(