We don't usually do this, but we're un-paywalling my latest @wcrowdslive essay for 24 hours. Sign up for free to get it delivered straight to your inbox at 9am tomorrow: wisdomofcrowds.live/signup/
We'll also be lifting the paywall on @dmarusic's latest essay, which makes a bold argument that helps put into perspective the last few weeks of anger and frustration over Afghanistan and how to remember what went wrong
My essay on the legacy of 9/11 is out in @ForeignAffairs. This is my attempt to take stock of what went wrong and how—with a focus not on our own tortured souls but on the people of the Middle East
Americans tend to lament 9/11 for how it divided us and led us into disastrous wars. As bad as it's been for us, though, it's been much worse for the Middle East. The past two decades have been the most costly and tragic in the region's contemporary history 2/x
After 9/11, Arab regimes took their cues from the Bush administration and used the "War on Terror" to fight their own largely unrelated battles. 3/x
It's interesting to watch leftists and progressives hail a speech where the president doubled down on his cruel, Kissingerian disregard for non-Americans. Callous, stubborn, and completely lacking in self-criticism. "America First" but this time under a Democrat
I don't understand why supporting withdrawal means you also have to be cruel and indifferent to the fate of millions of Muslims, but I suppose that's where we are now
Whatever Biden is on foreign policy, it's definitely not "progressive." It's nationalist and Trumpian
"I'm tempted to conclude that, despite laying claim to the skills and talents of the best and brightest, America is uniquely bad at foreign policy, particularly as it relates to anything having to do with Muslims"
Short of having a president with a fundamentally different outlook toward Muslim-majority countries, I'm not sure a better U.S. foreign policy is possible. Or, at least, someone at the level of Tony Blinken or Jake Sullivan, neither of whom have a particular interest in this
The Coordinator for the Middle East under Biden is Brett McGurk, who while competent is not an original, strategic thinker on these issues. Which is fine—if you think Middle East policy just needs to be competently managed
I find it somewhat odd that in conversations about Afghanistan withdrawal and what went wrong, few people talk about the 2004 Bonn Agreement and the 2000s more generally. It's as if people believe in the primacy of force over the primacy of politics
American and EU officials, international NGOs, and their Afghan partners designed the worst imaginable political and electoral system for Afghanistan. Yes, Biden has been utterly incompetent and even cruel, but the foundational flaws happened like 20 years ago
It's rare for a militant groups with (some) popular support and legitimacy to be eliminated entirely. And yet the possibility of integrating Taliban elements in the Afghan government wasn't seriously discussed until maybe 10 years after the initial intervention
1/ I have a new essay for @WCrowdsLive where I offer a more personal reflection on the frustration and futility I've felt these past few weeks. Is it that the U.S. is just hopelessly bad when it comes to Muslim-majority countries?
2/ For me, September 11 was a defining moment. It led to the Iraq war, which is how I gained most of my early politics. I became politicized through the anti-war movement. And then much of what followed was tied to those original sins
3/ A month ago, Americans couldn't care less about Afghanistan, and terrorism had largely removed itself from the American imagination. Biden's #Afghanistan debacle is a reminder that we can try to forget but the legacies of 9-11 will haunt us regardless
American policy in Afghanistan was guided by fantasies. Chief among them was the idea that the Taliban could be eliminated and that an entire culture could be transformed in the process. What exactly went wrong? Here's my essay in @TheAtlantic
Once the United States concluded that the Taliban was evil, it was almost doomed to make a series of fatal mistakes. To deem a group evil is to cast it outside of time and history, and that makes it all the more difficult to understand why people might support it. 2/
The fundamental America error is mind-boggling in retrospect. The US and Europe promoted a strong, centralized authority and a constitution that invested the president with sweeping powers. A bizarre and extremely rare electoral system guaranteed a weak parliament. 3/