Deeply moved to see a dear colleague - one of the brightest and most original historians of the Middle East I know - detained in a military jeep, his eyes covered, for the crime of delivering water to Palestinians in the south Hebron hills.
He writes: "Why did we try to deliver water? Because Palestinians in Area C suffer deep discrimination in access to water. They can get water in trucks, on certain days of the week, for very high prices, while the nearby settlements are connected to the Israeli water grid...
"Israel claims the Palestinians cannot be connected to water because they live in illegal houses. But nearby outpost of Avigail, illegal even according to Israel, receives constant supply of water in pipes...
"Two populations live between the river and the sea; one rules over the other, and prevents it from democratically determining its future; one systematically expropriates land for the other, to settle its own population; it dispossesses the ruled population...
"... by denying access to water, theft of resources, checkpoints, walls, fences, complicated bureaucratic mechanisms. Systemic, institutional, organised violence, defends this undemocratic order and crushes any resistance to it".
It's a beautiful and thought provoking piece from @ArielleLAngel on the meaning and limits of Jewish solidarity. I have actually much to say here. Probably too much. Two comments, on history, and on Palestine jewishcurrents.org/on-loving-jews/
2/ History: we can trace "Jewish peoplehood" as *global* *political* mobilisation to 18th century efforts to support Jewish communities in Palestine (as M. Lehmann does). Yes, if Jewish peoplehood means something politically, good chance it has something to do with Palestine
3/ But we should remember WWI when hundreds of thousands of Jewish soldiers fought on opposing sides. Killed each others. For their nations. That's how much Jewish solidarity meant - not that much.
1/ Recognising that Israel is a settler state is crucial because in 2021 Israel is still committed to an active project of expansionary Jewish settlement and Palestinian dispossession - as we see in Sheikh Jarrah, Silwan, Beita, and Araqib.
2/ And that project is written deep into policy, budgets, and law.
Basic Law of Israel as a Nation State of the Jewish People:
7A "The state views the development of Jewish settlement as a national value and will act to encourage and promote its establishment and consolidation"
3/ The state sees settling Jews (and removing Palestinians in the process) as its prerogative. The logic of settlement is not going to stop by itself, it's not going to go away by itself.
It has to be identified, confronted, and stopped.
Dr Weizmann, 1931: I don't like the demand for a Jewish majority... we don't need a majority to feel secure, or to develop Hebrew culture... the world would only read it as a plan to expel the Arabs... why would we make such a provocative demand.
17th Zionist Congress
Note: in 1931 Jews made up 17% of Palestine's population
"Damascus Gate, the most beautiful of all the city's gates; through it enter the city's Pasha, its officials and nobility, as well as most of the Europeans princes and aristocrats [who came to visit Jerusalem]."
A. M. Luncz, the First Jerusalem Guidebook, 1876 (Hebrew)
Note that only 20 years later, Kaiser Wilhelm will enter Jerusalem not through Damascus Gate but through Jaffa Gate, and 20 years more, General Allenby will follow him.
In many ways, the changing fortunes of these two gates is the history of the entire country.
1/ Yesterday we saw forceful and vocal response from Palestinians worldwide to incidents in which people waving the Palestine flags targeted Jewish neighbourhoods in London with vile antisemitic harassment and threats.
The response below is one of many.
2/ Antisemitism in the Palestine activism scene in the West almost never comes from Palestinians, almost always comes from non-Palestinian activists. We should acknowledge the heavy burden this places on Palestinians, especially in this moment.
3/ So while they face bombing, attacks, displacement, and brutalisation in Palestine, Palestinians also now need to find the time and space to reject what some racist idiots are doing in the name of their cause.