1/7 #forcedloans Horrified to see Homes England advertising for an 18 month fixed term employee to oversee development of loans for 11-18 metre buildings (advert here: homesenglandcareers.co.uk/search/657)
2/7 #forcedloans would see innocent leaseholders pay the full cost of cladding works, plus interest. That is unjust.
If there are any non-cladding defects, then leaseholders would have to stump up the full costs AND pay these loans. Work may still not get done.
3/7 Of course, we have only the sketchy details the government has given so far. But that limited detail suggests that #forcedloans will not work, for some or all of the reasons below.
4/7 Capping the loan repayments at £50 a month, as the government as promised, would make this idea unworkable for a loan of the size of some of the bills being seen. The £50 a month would never repay it.
5/7 Increasing service charges by £50 a month, as the government appears to propose, would also affect the ability of leaseholders to remortgage and obtain other forms of consumer finance (car loans, credit cards). Service charges feature in FCA loan affordability calculations.
6/7 Last but not least, if the plan is to make freeholders the borrowers then wherever there is secured lending in place over a freehold, loan terms and negative pledges will prevent the freeholder borrowing more money and/or giving security for new loans.
7/7 #forcedloans will not work. They are unjust. All leaseholders in buildings of any height should be treated equally and given equal access to funding to fix all issues.
@nbdbuk#BuildingSafetyBill we are just coming to the end of the statement on NHS Care, about 5 speakers to go.
There is then a 10 minute rule bill about pension transfers and then the Second Reading debate will start, probably just after 3.
@nbdbuk In terms of what to expect today, the Commons is being asked to agree whether the Bill proceeds to the next stage of scrutiny, known as Committee Stage.
There will be a vote on that around 7 p.m. this evening.
@nbdbuk The Commons is also being asked to agree a programme motion setting out the timetable for the next stages of the Bill.
The Commons will send the Bill to a Public Bill Committee, which will start work in September and report back no later than 26 October.
1/9 #BuildingSafetyBill: the Commons has just agreed to abolish English Votes for English Laws (EVEL), without a formal vote.
EVEL was introduced in 2015 to exclude Scottish MPs from laws decided in Westminster but which did not apply in Scotland.
2/9 The idea behind EVEL was to create an English Parliament, to reflect the fact that Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland can make their own laws, whereas there is no separate Parliament for England.
3/9 After only slightly more than an hour's debate this evening, EVEL was abolished.
EVEL had been suspended since coronavirus restrictions were introduced to Parliament in March 2020.
At around 1 p.m. @BishopStAlbans will be asking what steps the government has taken to identify the number of leaseholders at risk of bankruptcy.
2/10 We can expect that the answer is "none" and to hear a a repeat of the same platitudes regarding £5.1 billion of funding and its £50/month #forcedloans scheme.
The question keeps the issue high on the political agenda and is likely to be a further embarrassment for the gov't
3/10 At around 2.40 this afternoon the Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Bill will have its Second Reading.
This will last about 3 hours. The purpose of the debate is to discuss the general principles of the bill.
If the gov't had been defeated today then it may have been expected to resign, see here for details: bit.ly/3tZbBBl
3/13 Main encouraging sign from today's debate is that more Conservative backbench MPs started to speak out on the issue, including that it's #notjustcladding
This mirrored Lords last week, showing there is increasing concern inside the gov't over its handling of the issue
1/6 Using MHCLG’s own estimates there are 8,000 >18 m buildings with cladding requiring an EWS1. Multiply that by the £2.2 million average full BSF funding per building awarded to date (£241.5m/106) gives an estimated cost of £18.23 billion. #EndOurCladdingScandal
2/6 While you’re thinking about that MHCLG, on Tuesday you estimated the Building Safety Bill will apply to 13,000 >18 metre buildings. Multiplying that by £2.27m per block gives £29.5 billion, or nearly 6 times what’s currently on offer.
3/6 Your estimate of buildings 11-18 metres with cladding requiring an EWS1 is 50,000. Assuming each costs 1/2 of a >18m building that’s £56.75 billion just on them. You may not have focussed on that because your planned #forcedloans dump that cost + interest on l-holders.