Quick example of sophistry and rhetorical trickery to muddy the waters. In a 20 minute video discussing how Umberto Eco's semiotic analysis of fascism is being abused by certain leftists, Tali made ONE comment (not even close to the main point) that Eco was not a socialist...
The MAIN point was that the 14 points can't be used as a "definition" of fascism in the way many leftists use them, that they have to be viewed in the context of semiotics to be of any use. But we got dozens of comments fixating on the "Eco wasn't doing socialist analysis" aside.
This is obviously a deflection, ignoring the main point that semiotics can't be used the way so many leftists are using them, and that trying to shoehorn these semiotic "14 points" leads to misunderstanding and mislabeling of people as fascists who are not.
This is what happens when a "movement" is based on idealist rhetorical trickery. This is not going to lead to progress, just more misunderstanding of the nature of fascism, more left-anti-communism, and the fascist-jacketing of more oppressed people.
Here's the video being referenced:

If you want a good analysis of fascism from a class conscious perspective, we highly recommend Parenti's Black Shirts and Reds. It's also available as an audio book from a few people on YouTube!
BTW: it's totally valid to criticize socialists for not having a socialist definition of fascism. As Parenti makes it very clear in Black Shirts and Reds, fascism is tightly aligned with the capitalist plutocracy and used to suppress the working class wherever it gains power.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Luna Oi! 🇻🇳 ¡ANTI-USAID ACTION! 🇨🇺

Luna Oi! 🇻🇳 ¡ANTI-USAID ACTION! 🇨🇺 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @LunaOi_VN

30 Sep
🧵 Dialectical Materialist Analysis of Land Back / Indigenous Liberation: a Thread🧵

I have seen SO many communists display a range of misunderstanding ranging from honest ignorance to aggressive bigotry pertaining to the indigenous concept of LAND BACK.

So let's discuss!
First, indigenous people are NOT a monolith. I can't speak for all indigenous people. Land Back means different things for different indigenous people. This relates to the Dialectical Materialist concept which in Vietnamese socialism we call "private and common."
Just like with communism, Land Back manifests in different ways for individual indigenous peoples (private aspects), but there are also commonalities which exist across most indigenous movements.
Read 34 tweets
30 Sep
As an officially trained Marxist-Leninist from an actual Marxist nation, I'm so sorry I have to tell you that you're 100% wrong.
We literrally did "land back" in 1954 lol. We call it "land reforms".

My grandparents' land were literally seized by the communists and it was redistributed equally to all poor peasants in the village 😂
Read 4 tweets
30 Sep
Some have said I "make my content for an American audience" and appeal to USA viewers. One thing I'm proud of is how international my audience is. The people in the USA I'm most interested in reaching are the marginalized and oppressed: black, indigenous, trans, migrants, etc. Image
I make my content to try and offer a Vietnamese communist perspective that seldom gets heard directly. Unfortunately, NOBODY can live beyond the shadow of USA politics. I won't apologize for commenting on the largest terrorist nation in the world and how it threatens us.
In fact, I will talk about whatever the hell I want. I'm not here to serve your expectations of what a Vietnamese person should discuss or sound like. I interview comrades from Brazil, China, Thailand, Chile, India, all over the world. And we are all concerned with the USA.
Read 4 tweets
29 Sep
🧵 A Dialectical Materialist's Guide to Social Change: A Thread 🧵

Any time I talk about secondary contradictions of class society - land back/indigenous liberation, dismantling patriarchy, trans rights, dismantling whiteness, etc. - I hear the same objections.

Let's discuss.
1. "These are all distractions! You are dividing the working class! Ignore this idpol and focus on CLASS!"

This is a gross misunderstanding of the dialectical materialist worldview. All things, phenomena, and ideas are defined by INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL RELATIONS.
The working class is not a static, monolithic entity. It is composed of objective social relations between real people. There exist secondary contradictions (many created and exacerbated intentionally by capitalism) which need to be negated.
Read 20 tweets
29 Sep
Remember: If the colonizers won't join your side you can always send them packing, like we did in 1973 Image
Hanoi Hannah invited them to join our side and help us fight for liberation but nobody accepted our lovely hospitality! Image
Today there are tens of thousands of foreigners living in Vietnam, and we welcome them. I even married one, and he plans to become a citizen, which I think is wonderful. But we won't be your slaves ever again! Image
Read 4 tweets
29 Sep
We need SOLIDARITY against the pro-imperialist/anti-communist, white supremacist faux-left. Right now they are controlling BIPOC socialists & indigenous people through fear, silencing us with mass harassment, softening young whites up for fascism with "white genocide" mythology.
If you think land back "goes too far" then what are you going to do? Send indigenous victims of genocide a fucking gift card every year?
These people push white supremacist talking points and build fear and distrust of the colonized then accuse US of "dividing the left." Classic DARVO: deny, attack, reverse victim/offender."
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(